热带地理 ›› 2021, Vol. 41 ›› Issue (3): 461-471.doi: 10.13284/j.cnki.rddl.003345
收稿日期:
2020-11-30
修回日期:
2021-01-18
出版日期:
2021-05-30
发布日期:
2021-06-24
通讯作者:
张楠
E-mail:mrs_qinsq@163.com;zhangnan.waca@qq.com
作者简介:
秦书茜(1989—),女,四川达州人,博士生,主要研究方向为城乡可持续发展,(E-mail)mrs_qinsq@163.com;
基金资助:
Shuqian Qin1(), Nan Zhang1(
), Yong Zhang2, Chen Zhang1, Peijuan Zhu3
Received:
2020-11-30
Revised:
2021-01-18
Online:
2021-05-30
Published:
2021-06-24
Contact:
Nan Zhang
E-mail:mrs_qinsq@163.com;zhangnan.waca@qq.com
摘要:
城中村更新的方式主要有两种:一种是拆迁重建,另一种是就地整改;两种方式均难以满足城市对经济、社会、环境等多元目标的可持续发展需求,成为制约城市更新进程与效果的关键因素。基于此,引入可持续性科学理论,并借鉴管理学中“对象-主体-过程”的三维分析框架,以社区及单个项目作为研究的空间尺度,构建了城中村可持续更新模式的研究框架。该模式强调:在对象维度追求经济、社会、环境多目标可持续发展;在过程维度运用压力-状态-响应方法进行全过程管理;在主体维度强调利益相关者共同参与的多方合作治理。通过长沙后湖黄鹤村政府总体统筹、企业承包、村社筹房协作的多方合作更新模式的实证研究,从可持续发展的角度对“迁而不拆+整体开发+综合整治”的更新路径进行了评析。实证结果显示:该模式在平衡多方主体利益、盘活存量土地资源、促进产业结构升级、提升城市空间品质和保护村落文化等方面具有积极意义,但由于该模式不涉及农民自建房产权性质的变更,难以从根本上解决城中村在更新过程中所涉及的农民市民化身份转化、农民生计风险等历史遗留问题。本研究是一次运用可持续性科学理论解读城市更新实践的尝试,为促进城中村可持续更新提供一种新思路,可为中国城中村更新工作提供经验和启示。
中图分类号:
秦书茜, 张楠, 张勇, 张趁, 朱佩娟. 城中村可持续更新路径探索——以长沙后湖黄鹤村为例[J]. 热带地理, 2021, 41(3): 461-471.
Shuqian Qin, Nan Zhang, Yong Zhang, Chen Zhang, Peijuan Zhu. Exploration of Sustainable Renewal Path of Urban Villages: A Case Study of Huanghe Village, Hou Lake, Changsha[J]. Tropical Geography, 2021, 41(3): 461-471.
David H. 2003. The Right to the City. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 27(4): 939-941. | |
Kates R W, Clark W C, Robert C, Hall J M, Jaeger C C, Lowe I, James J M C, Schellnhuber H J, Bolin B, Dickson N M, Faucheux S, Gallopin G C, Grübler A, Huntley B, Jäger J, Jodha N S, Kasperson R E, Mabogunje A, Matson P, Mooney H, Moore B III, O'Riordan T and Svedin U. 2001. Sustainability Science. Science, 292(5517): 641-642. | |
Neil S. 2002. New Globalism, New Urbanism: Gentrification as Global Urban Strategy. Antipode, 34(3): 427-450. | |
成德礼. 2008. 对中国城中村发展问题的再思考——基于失地农民可持续生计的角度. 城市发展研究,15(3):68-79. | |
Cheng Deli. 2008. Research on the Scientific Development of Urban Village in China—In Perspective of Land-Losing Farmers' Sustainable Livelihoods. Urban Studies, 15 (3): 68-79. | |
丁凡,伍江. 2017. 城市更新相关概念的演进及在当今的现实意义. 城市规划学刊,(6):87-95. | |
Ding Fan and Wu Jiang. 2017. The Evolution of the Concept of Urban Regeneration and the Practical Connotation in Today's Society. Urban Planning Forum, (6): 87-95. | |
段一行. 2020. 系统性的可持续城市设计——瑞典Citylab导则在中国常州的实验. 城市建筑,17(6):98-101. | |
Duan Yihang. 2020. Systematic Sustainable Urban Design — An Experiment by Citylab in Changzhou, China. Urbanism and Architecture, 17(6): 98-101. | |
何元斌,林泉. 2012. 城中村改造中的主体利益分析与应对措施——基于土地发展权视角. 地域研究与开发,31(4):124-127. | |
He Yuanbin and Lin Quan. 2012. Research on Urban Construction Land Intensive Use Potential Release Technology: A Case of Lanzhou City. Areal Research and Development, 31(4): 124-127. | |
贺艳华,邬建国,周国华,周兵兵. 2020. 论乡村可持续性与乡村可持续性科学. 地理学报,75(4):736-752. | |
He Yanhua, Wu Jianguo, Zhou Guohua and Zhou Bingbing. 2020. Discussion on Rural Sustainability and Rural Sustainability Science. Acta Geographica Sinica, 75(4): 736-752. | |
黄璐. 2015. 中国城市发展及规划可持续性评估. 杭州:浙江大学. [Huang Lu. 2015. Sustainability Assessment of Urban Development and Planning in China: A Sustainability Science and Indicators-Based Approach. Hang Zhou: Zhe Jiang University. ] | |
李培林. 2002. 巨变:村落的终结——都市里的村庄研究. 中国社会科学,(1):168-179. | |
Li Peilin. 2002. Tremendous Changes: The End of Village: A Study of Villages in the Center of Guangzhou City. Social Sciences in China, (1): 168-179. | |
李润国,赵青,王伟伟. 2015. 新型城镇化背景下城中村改造的问题与对策研究. 宏观经济研究,(8):41-47,75. | |
Li Runguo, Zhao Jing and Wang Weiwei. 2015. Research on the Problems and Countermeasures of Urban Village Transformation under the Background of New Urbanization. Macroeconomics, (8):41-47, 75. | |
刘于琪,刘晔,李志刚. 2017. 居民归属感、邻里交往和社区参与的机制分析——以广州市城中村改造为例. 城市规划,41(9):38-47. | |
Liu Yuqi, Liu Ye and Li Zhigang. 2017. Mechanisms of Neighborhood Attachment, Neighborly Interaction, and Community Participation in Process of Urban Village Redevelopment: A Case Study of Guangzhou. City Planning Review, 41(9): 38-47. | |
潘卓林,刘晔,刘于琪,李志刚. 2020. 基于场域理论的城中村村民市民化研究——以广州猎德复建房社区为例. 热带地理,40(6):981-992. | |
Pan Zhuolin1, Liu Ye, Liu Yuqi and Li Zhigang. 2020. Citizenization of Villagers in City Based on Field Theory: A Case Study of Liede Redeveloped Community, Guangzhou. Tropical Geography, 40(6): 981-992. | |
陶海燕,周淑丽,卓莉. 2014. 城中村有序改造的群决策——以广州市城中村改造为例. 地理研究,33(7):1207-1216. | |
Tao Haiyan, Zhou Shuli and Zhuo Li. 2014. Group Decision-Making on Well-Order Renovation of Urban Villages: A Case Study of Guangzhou. Geographical Research, 33(7): 1207-1216. | |
万举. 2008. 国家权力下的土地产权博弈——城中村问题的实质. 财经问题研究,(5):11-16. | |
Wan Ju. 2008. The Game of Land Property Right under the State Power. Research on Financial Economic Issues, (5): 11-16. | |
王谋,康文梅,刘君言,吕献红,张莹,罗东燊. 2018. 我国可持续城市建设:经验、问题与展望. 阅江学刊,10(6):25-35. | |
Wang Mou, Kang Wenmei, Liu Junyan, Lv Xianhong, Zhang Ying and Luo Dongshen. 2018. Analysis of Sustainable Urban Construction in China: Experience, Problems and Prospects. Yuejiang Academic Journal, 10(6): 25-35. | |
邬建国,郭晓川,杨稢,钱贵霞,牛建明,梁存柱,张庆,李昂. 2014. 什么是可持续性科学?. 应用生态学报,25(1):1-11. | |
Wu Jianguo, Guo Xiaochuan, Yang Jie, Qian Guixia, Niu Jianming, Liang Cunzhu, Zhang Qing and Li Ang. What is Sustainability Science?. Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology, 25(1): 1-11. | |
萧俊瑶,张晓宇,李志刚. 2019. “行政吸纳”视角下深圳市城中村改造模式及演化机制研究. 城市与环境研究,(3):72-82. [Xiao Junyao, Zhang Xiaoyu and Li Zhigang. Patterns and Evolution Mechanism of Urban Village Redevelopment in Shenzhen City from the "Administrative Absorption" Perspective. Urban and Environmental Studies, (3): 72-82. ] | |
闫小培,魏立华,周锐波. 2004. 快速城市化地区城乡关系协调研究——以广州市“城中村”改造为例. 城市规划,(3):30-38. | |
Yan Xiaopei, Wei Lihua and Zhou Ruibo. 2004. Research on the Coordination between Urban and Rural Area in the Rapid Urbanization with the Redevelopment of Guangzhou Village-Amid-the-City as a Case. City Planning Review, (3): 30-38. | |
严若谷,周素红,闫小培. 2011. 城市更新之研究. 地理科学进展,30(8):947-955. | |
Yan Ruogu, Zhou Suhong and Yan Xiaopei. 2011. Studies of Urban Regeneration. Progress in Geography, 30(8): 947-955. | |
杨东峰,殷成志,龙瀛. 2011. 城市可持续性的定量评估:方法比较与实践检讨. 城市规划学刊,(3):58-65. | |
Yang Dongfeng, Yin Chenglong and Long Ying. 2011. Quantitative Assessment of Urban Sustainability: Methodological and Practical Review. Urban Planning Forum, (3): 58-65. | |
叶裕民. 2015. 特大城市包容性城中村改造理论架构与机制创新——来自北京和广州的考察与思考. 城市规划,39(8):9-23. | |
Ye Yumin. 2015. Theoretical Framework and Mechanism Innovation of the Inclusive Urban Village Reconstruction in Chinese: Study and Reflections on Beijing and Guangzhou. City Planning Review, 39(8): 9-23. | |
叶裕民,张理政,孙玥,王洁晶. 2020. 破解城中村更新和新市民住房“孪生难题”的联动机制研究——以广州市为例. 中国人民大学学报,34(2):14-28. | |
Ye Yumin, Zhang Lizheng, Sun Yue and Wang Jiejing. 2020. A Coordinated Solution to the Twin Problems of the Regeneration of Chinese “Villages in the City” and New Citizens Affordable Housing: A Case Study of Guangzhou. Journal of Renmin University of China, 34(2): 14-28. | |
叶子君,林坚. 2020. 可持续城市更新决策支持方法研究评述. 地域研究与开发,39(3):59-64. | |
Ye Zijun and Lin Jian. 2020. Review of Decision-Making Support Methods of Sustainable Urban Renewal. Areal Research and Development, 39(3): 59-64. | |
岳隽. 2015. 深圳原农村土地二次开发模式统筹研究——基于土地增值收益合理分配的视角. 地域研究与开发,34(5):153-156. | |
Yue Jun. 2015. Research on Coordination Model of Land Redevelopment of the Original Rural Collective Land in Shenzhen: On the Perspective of Land Value Increase Allocation. Areal Research and Development, 34(5): 153-156. | |
张侠,赵德义,朱晓东,彭补拙. 2006. 城中村改造中的利益关系分析与应对. 经济地理,26(3):496-499. | |
Zhang Xia, Zhao Deyi, Zhu Xiaodong and Peng Buzhuo. 2006. The Countermeasures and Analysis on the Benefit Relationship of the Reconstruction of viliage in City. Economic Geography, 26(3): 496-499. | |
张宇,欧名豪,蔡玉军. 2015. 整村统筹——解决城中村土地利用和发展问题的一个探索. 城市规划,39(2):93-98. | |
Zhang Yu, Ou Minghao and Cai Yujun. 2015. Overall Village Coordination: An Exploration of Land Use and Development Issues of Urban Villages. City Planning Review, 39(2): 93-98. | |
周兵兵,马群,邬建国,胡国华,毛德华,曾小箕,郭杰,房学宁,刘宇鹏,吕立刚. 2019. 再论可持续性科学:新形势与新机遇. 应用生态学报,30(1):325-336. | |
Zhou Bingbing, Ma Qun, Wu Jianguo, Hu Guohua, Mao Dehua, Zeng Xiaoji, Guo Jie, Fang Xuening, Liu Yupeng and Lv Ligang. 2019. Sustainability Science Revisited: Recent Advances and New Opportunities. Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology, 30(1): 325-336. | |
周锐波,闫小培. 2009. 集体经济:村落终结前的再组织纽带——以深圳“城中村”为例. 经济地理,29(4):628-634. | |
Zhou Ruibo and Yan Xiaopei. 2009. Empirical Study of the Impact of Supply on Housing Price: A Case Study of Shanghai. Economic Geography, 29(4): 628-634. | |
朱丽. 2020. 我国城市可持续发展的挑战与应对构想. 人民论坛·学术前沿,(4):73-80. | |
Zhu Li. 2020. Challenges to Urban Sustainable Development in China and Countermeasures. Frontiers, (4): 73-80. | |
诸大建. 2016. 可持续性科学:基于对象—过程—主体的分析模型. 中国人口·资源与环境,26(7):1-9. | |
Zhu Dajian. 2016. Sustainability Science: An Object-Process-Subject Analytical Framework. Chinese Journal of Population Resources and Environment, 26(7): 1-9. | |
诸大建. 2019. 用国际可持续发展研究的新成果和通用语言解读生态文明. 中国环境管理,11(3):5-12. | |
Zhu Dajian. 2019. Explaining Eco-Civilization from the Frontier Research and International Perspective of Sustainable Development. Chinese Journal of Environmental Management, 11(3): 5-12. |
[1] | 常昕, 章新平, 刘仲藜, 王锐. 长沙降水中稳定同位素的昼夜差别[J]. 热带地理, 2021, 41(3): 635-644. |
[2] | 曾迪, 朱金, 何深静. 文化身份视角下移民城市的城中村更新模式探讨——基于新加坡与深圳的实证研究[J]. 热带地理, 2021, 41(3): 449-460. |
[3] | 向雨, 张鸿辉, 刘小平. 多源数据融合的城市体检评估[J]. 热带地理, 2021, 41(2): 277-289. |
[4] | 牛方曲, 杨欣雨, 孙东琪. 不同发展模式下资源环境承载力评价——以海南省为例[J]. 热带地理, 2020, 40(6): 1109-1116. |
[5] | 潘卓林, 刘晔, 刘于琪, 李志刚. 基于场域理论的城中村村民市民化研究——以广州猎德复建房社区为例[J]. 热带地理, 2020, 40(6): 981-992. |
[6] | 陈嘉平, 李静, 温耀鸿. “土地租金剩余”视角下旧厂房改造为创新空间的路径研究——基于广州、深圳对比分析[J]. 热带地理, 2020, 40(5): 795-807. |
[7] | 沈 静,周楚平. 国外环境公正研究综述[J]. 热带地理, 2019, 39(2): 298-308. |
[8] | Terry McGee(著),黄耿志(译). 21世纪中国城市未来的软规划与生态文明建设[J]. 热带地理, 2018, 38(4): 451-457. |
[9] | 常江,谢涤湘,陈宏胜,陈惠琪. 历史街区更新驱动下的旅游绅士化研究 ——以佛山岭南天地为例[J]. 热带地理, 2018, 38(4): 586-597. |
[10] | 赵焕庭,王丽荣,袁家义. 南海诸岛珊瑚礁可持续发展[J]. 热带地理, 2016, 36(1): 55-65. |
[11] | 郭 环,李世杰,周春山. 广州民间金融街城市更新模式探讨[J]. 热带地理, 2015, 35(3): 364-371. |
[12] | 杨俭波,李 凡,黄 维. 历史文化名城改造中城市更新概念的衍生、想象和认知局限性——以佛山岭南天地“三旧”改造为案例[J]. 热带地理, 2015, 35(2): 170-178. |
[13] | 黄煌,章新平,李广,黄一民,廖梦思. 长沙地区蒸发皿水体蒸发过程中稳定同位素的变化特征[J]. 热带地理, 2014, 34(6): 776-782. |
[14] | 谢涤湘,李华聪. 我国城市更新中的权益博弈研究述评[J]. 热带地理, 2013, 33(2): 231-236. |
[15] | 杨云源,史正涛,何 萍. 基于多源数据的昆明市主城区建筑区热环境分析[J]. 热带地理, 2013, 33(1): 21-27. |
|