热带地理 ›› 2021, Vol. 41 ›› Issue (6): 1142-1152.doi: 10.13284/j.cnki.rddl.003403
马腾1,3(), 李永宁4, 李一杰2, 李银河3,5, 杜德斌3(
), 胡志丁3
收稿日期:
2021-06-25
修回日期:
2021-10-21
出版日期:
2021-11-05
发布日期:
2021-11-16
通讯作者:
杜德斌
E-mail:mateng0119@163.com;dbdu@re.ecnu.edu.cn
作者简介:
马腾(1990—),男,江西人,讲师/博士后,硕士生导师,主要研究方向为全球化与地缘环境,(E-mail)mateng0119@163.com;
基金资助:
Teng Ma1,3(), Yongning Li4, Yijie Li2, Yinhe Li3,5, Debin Du3(
), Zhiding Hu3
Received:
2021-06-25
Revised:
2021-10-21
Online:
2021-11-05
Published:
2021-11-16
Contact:
Debin Du
E-mail:mateng0119@163.com;dbdu@re.ecnu.edu.cn
摘要:
基于地缘环境的“地理位置—地缘关系—地缘结构”分析框架,对北极地区的地缘环境进行全面解析,并进一步分析“冰上丝绸之路”对北极地区地缘环境的影响。研究发现:1)北极地区地缘环境复杂,地理位置上,北极位于地球最北端,蕴含着丰富的资源,拥有极高的战略价值,是世界主要国家争夺的对象;地缘关系上,涉及到的主体与主题繁多,主要包括北极国家、近北极国家和原住民相互之间的关于领土、经济、能源、权利等多样议题;地缘结构上,北极地区地缘结构经历了“美苏争霸”—“破冰合作”—“新一轮竞赛”3个阶段的演变,当前结构呈现出“中心—次中心—外围”的特征。2)“冰上丝绸之路”的提出顺应了气候变化的趋势,推动北极地区区域合作,近北极国家参与北极事务,原住民保护,从而使地缘结构的中心更加稳定,地缘体之间联系更加紧密,并且进一步拓展了地缘关系网络。
中图分类号:
马腾, 李永宁, 李一杰, 李银河, 杜德斌, 胡志丁. 北极地缘环境解析与中国的应对之策[J]. 热带地理, 2021, 41(6): 1142-1152.
Teng Ma, Yongning Li, Yijie Li, Yinhe Li, Debin Du, Zhiding Hu. Geo-Setting in the Arctic and Countermeasures of China: A Case Study of the "Polar Silk Road"[J]. Tropical Geography, 2021, 41(6): 1142-1152.
表1
北极国家间地缘关系
领域 | 事件 | 涵盖国家 |
---|---|---|
岛屿归属 | 加拿大与丹麦的关于汉斯岛归属之争 | 加拿大、丹麦 |
挪威对于斯匹次卑尔根群岛的主权 | 挪威 | |
领海争端 | 200 n mile大陆架划界问题 | 俄罗斯、挪威、丹麦、美国、加拿大 |
西经141°线能否作为美国、加拿大两国海上边界 | 美国、加拿大 | |
美国和苏联关于白令海和楚科奇海的争议 | 美国、苏联 | |
美国和加拿大关于波弗特海的争议 | 美国、加拿大 | |
加拿大与丹麦在北冰洋地区的海洋边界 | 加拿大、丹麦 | |
冰岛和丹麦法罗群岛之间的海洋边界 | 冰岛、丹麦 | |
挪威的斯瓦尔巴群岛和丹麦的格陵兰岛之间的海洋边界 | 挪威、丹麦 | |
航道之争 | 东北航道主权 | 俄罗斯、美国、欧盟 |
西北航道主权 | 美国、加拿大 | |
能源开发 | 以军事作为能源开发中保障权益的手段 | 美国、俄罗斯 |
能源开发中的合作 | 挪威、冰岛、俄罗斯 | |
地缘经济 | 美加贸易占北极国家间贸易流的70%以上 | 美国、加拿大 |
地缘经济地位与影响力存在差异 | 冰岛、丹麦、俄罗斯 |
Affairs Norwegian Ministry of Foreign. 2017. Norway's Arctic Strategy-between Geopolitics and Social Development. (2017-03-29) [2021-04-10]. https://www.regjeringen.no/contentassets/fad46f0404e14b2a9b 551ca7359c1000/arctic-strategy.pdf. | |
Blaxekjæ L Ø, Lanteigne M and Shi M. 2018. The Polar Silk Road & the West Nordic Region. In: Heininen L and H Exner-Pirot. Arctic Yearbook 2018. Iceland: Northern Research Forum, 420-436. | |
陈思静. 2018. 北极能源共同开发:现状、特点与中国的参与. 资源开发与市场,34(8):1099-1104. [Chen Sijing. 2018. Joint Development Cases and Chinese Participation in Energy Exploitation in Arctic. Resource Development & Market, 34(8): 1099-1104. ] | |
邓贝西,张侠. 2015. 俄美北极关系视角下的北极地缘政治发展分析. 太平洋学报,23(11):38-44. [Deng Xibei and Zhang Xia. 2015. Analysis on Arctic Geopolitical Development from Perspective of U.S.-Russian Arctic Relations. Pacific Journal, 23(11): 38-44. ] | |
邓贝西,张侠. 2016. 试析北极安全态势发展与安全机制构建. 太平洋学报,24(12):42-50. [Deng Beixi and Zhang Xia. 2016. An Analysis of the Security Dynamics and the Construction of Security Regimes in the Arctic, Pacific Journal, 24(12): 42-50. ] | |
Dodds K. 2010. Flag Planting and Finger Pointing: The Law of the Sea, the Arctic and the Political Geographies of the Outer Continental Shelf. Political Geography, 29(2): 63-73. | |
杜德斌,秦大河,马亚华,杨文龙,夏启繁. 2020. 冰冻圈地缘政治时代的到来. 中国科学院院刊,35(4):514-522. [Du Debin, Qin Dahe, Ma Yahua, Yang Wenlong and Xia Qifan. 2020. The Age of Cryopolitics is Coming. Bulletin of Chinese Academy of Science, 35(4): 514-522. ] | |
Gautier D L, Bird K J, Charpentier R R, Grantz A, Houseknecht D W, Klett T R, Moore T E, Pitman J K, Schenk C J, Schuenemeyer J H, Sørensen K, Tennyson M E, Valin Z C and Wandrey C J. 2009. Assessment of Undiscovered Oil and Gas in the Arctic. Science, 324(5931): 1175-1179. | |
Government of India, Ministry of External Affairs. 2013. India and the Arctic. (2013-06-10) [2021-04-11]. http://mea.gov.in/in-focus-article.htm?21812/India+and+the+Arctic. | |
关晓光,李振福. 2021. “冰上丝绸之路”对中国与沿线北极国家的经济效应研究. 大连理工大学学报(社会科学版),42(1):45-57. [Guan Xiaoguang and Li Zhenfu. 2021. The Economic Effect of the "Polar Silk Road" on China and the Arctic Countries along the Route. Journal of Dalian University of Technology (Social Sciences), 42(1): 45-57. ] | |
郭培清,管清蕾. 2010. 探析俄罗斯对北方海航道的控制问题. 中国海洋大学学报(社会科学版),(2):6-10. [Guo Peiqing and Guan Qinglei. 2010. An Analysis of the Russian Control of the Northern Sea Route. Journal of Ocean University of China (Social Science Edition), (2): 6-10. ] | |
郭锐,孙天宇. 2020. 韩国“新北方政策”下的北极战略:进程与限度. 国际关系研究,(3):136-153,159. [Guo Rui and Sun Tianyu. 2020. The Arctic Strategy under ROK's "New Northern Policy": Process and Constraints. Journal of International Relations, (3): 136-153, 159. ] | |
Havnes H. 2020. The Polar Silk Road and China's Role in Arctic Governance. Journal of Infrastructure Policy and Development, 4(1): 121-138. | |
何奇松. 2010. 气候变化与北极地缘政治博弈. 外交评论(外交学院学报),27(5):113-122. [He Qisong. 2010. Climate Change and the Geopolitical Game in the Arctic. Foreign Affairs Review, 27(5): 113-122. ] | |
胡志丁,曹原,刘玉立,葛岳静. 2013. 我国政治地理学研究的新发展:地缘环境探索. 人文地理,28(5):123-128. [Hu Zhiding, Cao Yuan, Liu Yuli and Ge Yuejing. 2013. A New Development of Political Geography Research in China: Geo-Setting. Human Geography, 28(5): 123-128. ] | |
胡志丁,刘玉立,李灿松,葛岳静. 2014. 权力、地缘环境与地缘位势评价——以中日钓鱼岛之争为例. 热带地理,34(1):50-57. [Hu Zhiding, Liu Yuli, Li Cansong and Ge Yuejing. 2014. Power, Geo-Setting and Evaluation Method of Geo-Potential: A Case Study of the Dispute over China and Japan on the Diaoyu Islands. Tropical Geography, 34(1): 50-57. ] | |
胡志丁,杜德斌. 2020. 日本德川幕府时期的地缘环境分析——兼论国别地缘环境分析框架. 地理学报,75(10):2047-2060. [Hu Zhiding and Du Debin. 2020. An Investigation of Japanese Geo-Setting during the Period of Tokugawa Bakufu: A Tentative Examination of the Analytical Framework for Geo-Setting Research. Acta Geography Sinica, 75(10): 2047-2060. ] | |
贾宇. 2010. 北极地区领土主权和海洋权益争端探析. 中国海洋大学学报(社会科学版),(1):6-10. [Jia Yu. 2010. An Analysis of the Dispute over Arctic Region's Territorial Sovereignty and Maritime Rights. Journal of Ocean University of China (Social Science Edition), (1): 6-10. ] | |
姜胤安. 2019. “冰上丝绸之路”多边合作:机遇、挑战与发展路径. 太平洋学报,27(8):67-77. [Jiang Yinan. 2019. Multilateral Cooperation under the Polar Silk Road Framework: Opportunities, Challenges and Approaches. Pacific Journal, 27(8): 67-77. ] | |
焦敏,陈新军,高郭平. 2015. 气候变化对北极渔业资源的影响研究进展. 极地研究,27(4):454-462. [Jiao Min, Chen Xinjun and Gao Guoping. 2015. Research Progress on the Impact of Climatic Change on Arctic Fishery Resources. Chinese Journal of Polar Research, 27(4): 454-462. ] | |
Kishore K. 2013. Push for a 'Global Commons' Theory. Indian Foreign Affairs Journal, 8(1): 14-22. | |
李振福,李亚军,孙建平. 2011. 北极航道海运网络的国家权益格局复杂特征研究. 极地研究,23(2):122-127. [Li Zhenfu, Li Yajun and Sun Jianping. 2011. Complex Network Characteristics of Arctic Route Shipping Network National Rights Structure. Chinese Journal of Polar Research, 23(2): 122-127. ] | |
李振福,彭琰. 2019. “通权论”与“冰上丝绸之路”建设研究. 东北师大学报(哲学社会科学版),(4):23-32. [Li Zhenfu and Peng Yan. 2019. Research on the Connection Power Theory and the Construction of the Supraglacial Silk Road. Journal of Northeast Normal University (Philosophy and Social Science), (4): 23-32. ] | |
李振福. 2021. 北极地缘政治的多尺度特征——兼论北极问题与南海问题的本质不同. 东北亚论坛,30(2):41-59,127. [Li Zhenfu. 2021. Study on Multi-Dimension Features of Arctic Geopolitics——Also on the Essential Differences Between the Arctic Issue and the South China Sea Issue. Northeast Asia Forum, 30(2): 41-59, 127.] | |
刘新霞. 2018. 丝绸之路经济带与冰上丝绸之路比较研究. 合作经济与科技,(19):84-85. [Liu Xinxia. 2018. A Comparative Study of the Silk Road Economic Belt and the Polar Silk Road. Co-Operative Economy & Science, (19): 84-85. ] | |
陆俊元. 2010. 北极地缘政治竞争的新特点. 现代国际关系,(2):25-29. [Lu Junyuan. 2010. New Characteristics of Geopolitical Competition in the Arctic. Contemporary International Relations, (2): 25-29. ] | |
罗英杰,李飞. 2020. 大国北极博弈与中国北极能源安全——兼论“冰上丝绸之路”推进路径. 国际安全研究,38(2):91-115,159. [Luo Yingjie and Li Fei. 2020. The Great Powers' Arctic Game and China's Arctic Energy Security: Probing into the Advancement Path of the "Ice Silk Road" Framework. Journal of International Security Studies, 38(2): 91-115, 159. ] | |
Oran R Y and Níels E. 2004.The Arctic Human Development Report. Iceland: Arctic Council. | |
彭秋虹,陆俊元. 2013. 原住民权利与中国北极地缘经济参与. 世界地理研究,22(1):32-38. [Pen Qiuhong and Lu Junyuan. 2013. The Rights of Indigenous Peoples and China's Participation in the Arctic Geo-Economy. World Regional Studies, 22(1): 32-38. ] | |
Prescott V and Schofield C. 2004. The Maritime Political Boundaries of the World. 2nd Edition. London: Brill Academic Pub. | |
钱宗旗. 2018. 俄罗斯北极战略与冰上丝绸之路. 北京:时事出版社. [Qian Zongqi. 2018. Russia's Arctic strategy and the Polar Silk Road. Beijing: Cunrrent Affairs Press. ] | |
阮建平. 2019a. “地缘竞争”与“区域合作”:美国对“一带一路”倡议的地缘挑战与中国的应对思考. 太平洋学报,27(12):43-53. [Ruan Jianping. 2019a. Geo-Competition vs Regional Cooperation: Challenge from America against the Belt and Road Initiative and China's Countermeasure. Pacific Journal, 27(12): 43-53. ] | |
阮建平,瞿琼. 2019b. 北极原住民:中国深度参与北极治理的路径选择. 河北学刊,39(6):201-206. [Ruan Jianping and Di Qiong. 2019b. Arctic Aborigines: China's Deep Involvement in the Path of Arctic Governance. Hebei Academic Journal, 39(6): 201-206. ] | |
Schrank W E. 2007. The Acia, Climate Change and Fisheries. Marine Policy, 31(1): 5-18. | |
Shea N. 2019. Scenes from the New Cold War Unfolding at the Top of the World. (2019-05-08). [2021-04-10]. https://www.national geographic.com/environment/2018/10/new-cold-war-brews-as-arc tic-icemelts/. | |
Singapore Ministry of Foreign Affairs. 2014. Singapore in the Arctic. (2014-11-30) [2021-04-11]. http://www.mfa.gov.sg/content/mfa/media_centre/press_room/pr/2013/201310/press_2014 1101.printable. html?status=1. | |
孙凯,郭培清. 2012. 北极治理机制变迁及中国的参与战略研究. 世界经济与政治论坛,(2):118-128. [Sun Kai and Guo Peiqing. 2012. The Change of Arctic Governance Mechanism and China's Participation Strategy. Forum of World Economics & Politics, (2): 118-128. ] | |
孙迁杰,马建光. 2017. 论北极地缘政治博弈中俄罗斯的威慑战略. 上海交通大学学报(哲学社会科学版),25(1):14-21. [Sun Qianjie and Ma Jianguang. 2017. Deterrence Strategy of Russia in Geopolitical Game in the Arctic Region. Journal of SJTU (Philosophy and Social Science), 25(1): 14-21. ] | |
万晓梦. 2017. 剖析日本北极政策的新发展. 改革与开放,(2):17-18. [Wan Xiaomeng. 2017. Analysis of the New Development of Japan's Arctic Policy. Reform & Openning, (2): 17-18. ] | |
王传兴. 2014. 北极治理:主体、机制和领域. 同济大学学报(社会科学版),25(2):24-33. [Wang Chuanxing. 2014. The Arctic Governance: Subjects, Regimes and Areas. Tongji University (Social Science Section), 25(2): 24-33. ] | |
Wang E B. 1977. Canadian Sovereignty in the Arctic: A Comment on the Arctic in Question. Canadian Yearbook of International Law/Annuaire Canadien de Droit International, 14: 307-316. | |
肖洋. 2015. 日本的北极外交战略:参与困境与破解路径. 国际论坛,17(4):72-78,81. [Xiao Yang. 2015. Japan's Arctic Diplomatic Strategy: Participate Dilemma in Participate and Ways of Solution. International Forum, 17(4): 72-78, 81. ] | |
肖洋. 2019a. 竞争性抵制:美国对“冰上丝绸之路”的拒阻思维与战略构建. 太平洋学报,27(7):66-75. [Xiao Yang. 2019a. Competitive Resistance: American Resistance to the 'Polar Silk Road' and Strategic Construction. Pacific Journal, 27(7): 66-75. ] | |
肖洋. 2019b. 中欧共建“冰上丝绸之路”:机遇、挑战与路径. 德国研究,34(3):58-69,134. [Xiao Yang. 2019b. Gemeinsame Schaffung des Chinesisch-Europischen Projekts der "Polaren SeidenstraBe": Gelegenheiten, Herausforderungen und Wege. Deutschland-Studien, 34(3): 58-69, 134. ] | |
徐庆超. 2021. 北极安全战略环境及中国的政策选择. 亚太安全与海洋研究,(1):104-124,104. [Xu Qingchao. 2021. Arctic Security Strategy Environment and China's Policy Choice. Asia-Pacific Security and Maritime Affairs, (1): 104-124, 104. ] | |
叶滨鸿,程杨,王利,杨林生. 2019. 北极地区地缘关系研究综述. 地理科学进展,38(4):489-505. [Ye Binhong, Cheng Yang, Wang Li and Yang Linsheng. 2019. A Systematic Review on Geo-Relations Research in the Arctic. Progress in Geography, 38(4): 489-505. ] | |
叶滨鸿,程杨,王利,李东晔,杨林生. 2021. 北极地区地缘经济关系演变研究. 世界地理研究,30(2):234-244. [Ye Binhong, Cheng Yang, Wang Li, Li Dongye and Yang Linsheng. 2021. The Geo-Economics Relationship in the Arctic Region. World Regional Studies, 30(2): 234-244. ] | |
Young O R. 2005. Governing the Arctic: From Cold War Theater to Mosaic of Cooperation. Global Governance, (11): 9-15. | |
于宏源. 2015. 气候变化与北极地区地缘政治经济变迁. 国际政治研究,36(4):73-87,76-77. [Yu Hongyuan. 2015. Climate Change and the Evolution of Geopolitics and Geoeconomics in the Arctic Region. The Journal of International Studies, 36(4): 73-87, 76-77. ] | |
岳鹏. 2020. 共建“冰上丝绸之路”中的俄方诉求及内在挑战分析. 东北亚论坛,29(2):32-44,127. [Yue Peng. 2020. Analysis of Russian Appeal and Internal Challenge in the Joint Construction of the "Polar Silk Road". Northeast Asia Forum, 29(2): 32-44, 127. ] | |
张璐,张占海,李群,吴辉碇. 2009. 近30年北极海冰异常变化趋势. 极地研究,21(4):344-352. [Zhang Lu, Zhang Zhanhai, Li Qun and Wu Huidian. 2009. Status of the Recent Declining of Arctic Sea Ice Studies. Chinese Journal of Polar Research, 21(4): 344-352. ] | |
张敏娇. 2013. 论气候变化条件下北极治理面临的挑战及思考. 武汉:华中师范大学. [Zhang Minjiao. 2013. The Challenge of Arctic Governance under the Influence of Climate Change and Reflections. Wuhan: Central China Normal University. ] | |
张文木. 2016. 21世纪气候变化与中国国家安全. 太平洋学报, 24(12):51-63. [Zhang Wenmu. 2016. Climate change and China's National Security in 21st Century. Pacific Journal, 24(12): 51-63. ] | |
赵宁宁. 2020. 德国北极政策的新动向、战略考量及影响. 德国研究,35(1):4-16,159. [Zhao Ningning. 2020. New Trends, Strategic Considerations and Influence of German Arctic Policy. Deutschel Studies, 35(1): 4-16, 159. ] | |
赵先进,黄靖兹. 2019. 中国参与共建“冰上丝绸之路”的动力、制约与路径选择. 对外经贸实务,(11):32-35. [Zhao Xianjin and Huang Jingzi. The Motive Force, Restriction and Path Choice of China's Participation in the Co-Construction of "Polar Silk Road". Practice in Foreign Economic Relations and Trade, (11): 32-35. ] | |
中华人民共和国国务院新闻办公室. 2018. 中国的北极政策. (2018-01-26)[2021-04-10]. http://www.gov.cn/xinwen/2018-01/26/content_5260891.htm. [The State Council Information Office of the People's Republic of China. 2018. China's Arctic Policy. (2018-01-26) [2021-04-10]. http://www.gov.cn/zhengce/2018-01/26/content_5260891.htm. ] | |
邹磊磊,付玉. 2017. 北极原住民的权益诉求——气候变化下北极原住民的应对与抗争. 世界民族,(4):103-110. [Zou Leilei and Fu Yu. 2017. The Rights and Interests of the Arctic Indigenous People: the Response and Struggle of the Arctic Indigenous People under Climate Change. Journal of World Peoples Studies, (4): 103-110. ] | |
Zhang Y, Meng Q and Ng S H. 2016. Shipping Efficiency Comparison between Northern Sea Route and the Conventional Asia-Europe Shipping Route Via Suez Canal. Journal of Transport Geography, 57: 241-249. |
[1] | 袁广盛, 安宁. 浅析话语分析方法在地缘环境解析中的应用[J]. 热带地理, 2021, 41(6): 1132-1141. |
[2] | 胡志丁, 顾斐菲, 黄艺丹, 杜德斌. 西方地缘政治视角下北极地区研究进展与展望[J]. 热带地理, 2021, 41(6): 1175-1187. |
[3] | 王武林, 龚姣, 林珍. “冰上丝绸之路”沿线国家贸易网络结构特征分析[J]. 热带地理, 2021, 41(6): 1199-1208. |
[4] | 叶帅, 李永宁, 胡志丁, 葛岳静, 王淑芳, 刘玉立. 地缘战略交汇区地理环境的介质属性及其地缘环境效应——以乌克兰为例[J]. 热带地理, 2021, 41(6): 1121-1131. |
[5] | 高爽, 王少剑, 王泽宏. 粤港澳大湾区知识网络空间结构演化特征与影响机制[J]. 热带地理, 2019, 39(5): 678-688. |
[6] | 李悦佳,贺新光,卢希安,谭子芳. 1960―2015年长江流域风速的时空变化特征[J]. 热带地理, 2018, 38(5): 660-667. |
[7] | 马向明,陈 洋. 粤港澳大湾区:新阶段与新挑战[J]. 热带地理, 2017, 37(6): 762-774. |
[8] | 李 红,韦永贵,徐全龙. 基于中国视角的地缘经济合作研究进展 ——以中国―东盟合作研究为例[J]. 热带地理, 2015, 35(5): 719-729. |
[9] | 胡志丁,骆华松,李灿松,付磊,熊理然.. 2009年后缅甸国内冲突的地缘政治学视角解读[J]. 热带地理, 2015, 35(4): 561-568. |
[10] | 钟 韵,吴 蒙. 区域合作背景下服务业发展的收敛性研究——以大珠三角金融业为例[J]. 热带地理, 2015, 35(2): 147-153. |
[11] | 胡志丁,刘玉立,李灿松,葛岳静. 权力、地缘环境与地缘位势评价——以中日钓鱼岛之争为例[J]. 热带地理, 2014, 34(1): 50-57. |
[12] | 孙海燕, 陈烈, 邓培雁. 湘西南山地旅游开发的区域合作分析[J]. 热带地理, 2004, 24(1): 83-86,96. |
|