展馆迁址对城市星级酒店营收格局的空间重构——广交会实证

doi:10.13284/j.cnki.rddl.003264

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

城市大型会展事件对酒店业的空间差异化影响一直是学界关注的热点。现有研究多关注某一届展会造成的短期且静态化的经济格局影响，较少关注展馆迁址所产生的长期而动态化的格局变化。因此，文章以2008年秋季广交会会展业务整体迁至琶洲为例，探究了展馆迁址对广州市域星级酒店在展会期间营收格局的空间重构，具有一定的现实意义。基于计量统计和ArcGIS平台，研究揭示了展会期间广州市域星级酒店营收格局的变化趋势及其背后逻辑。研究发现，在展馆迁址后的8年间，广交会期间的市域星级酒店：1）总体及平均营收均从“单核”转向“双核”格局，营收重心的“东延”“南拓”与展馆迁址在空间上具有相对一致性。展馆迁址改变了酒店与展会的空间距离，引发住宿需求在空间上的转移，推动市域酒店业“双核”营收格局的形成。2）营收变化率随时间呈现出由剧烈到平缓的趋势，且迁出地的变化率小于迁入地。3）迁入地酒店供给增长不足以消化会展期间巨大的住宿需求，而迁出地酒店供给格局在区域竞争中仍占优势，并且特殊的酒店购买模式使得原有住宿需求仍较多留在展馆迁出地酒店，抑制市域酒店业“双核”营收格局向以展馆新迁入地为中心的“单核”格局的演变，这使得在展馆迁址后，迁出地酒店业的总体与平均营收水平依然会保持较长时期的营收优势。

关键词: 会议会展, 星级酒店, 营收格局, 空间重构, 广交会, 广州

Abstract:

The impact of large-scale urban conventions and exhibitions on the spatial differentiation of the hotel industry has always been a topic of interest in the academic community. Existing researches, however, pay more attention to the short-term and static economic patterns caused by certain exhibitions and less to the long-term and dynamic pattern changes caused by the relocation of the exhibition hall. Therefore, this study takes the overall movement of the Canton Fair to Pazhou in the fall of 2008 as an example with which to explore the practical impact of the relocation of its pavilion on the spatial reconstruction of the star-rated hotels in Guangzhou city during the exhibition period. It uses measurement statistics and ArcGIS software to compare data on these hotels during the Spring Fair in 2008, 2012, and 2016, attempting to reveal the changes in and logic behind their revenue trends based on supply of and demand. The main conclusions of the study, in terms of the overall and average revenue of these hotels during the Canton Fair in the eight years after the relocation of the pavilion are as follows. 1) Before the relocation of the exhibition hall, the overall and average revenue of star-rated hotels had "single-core" spatial characteristics, with Yuexiu District as the core; after the relocation, income earned in Yuexiu District gradually decreased while that of Tianhe and Haizhu districts gradually increased, showing that a "dual core" pattern centered on Yuexiu and Tianhe. In addition to this shift, the focus of the revenue saw an "eastward extension". A "southern extension" was relatively consistent with the spatial relocation of the pavilion, which changed the spatial distance between the hotel and the exhibition and triggered the transfer of demand for accommodation and promoted the formation of the "dual-core" revenue pattern for the municipal hotel industry. 2) The fluctuation of hotel revenue in each region from 2008—2012 was greater than that from 2012—2016; and this was smaller in Yuexiu District and the nearby Liwan District, where the exhibition moved to halls that were smaller than those used in Haizhu and Tianhe districts when the exhibition moved to the latter. This indicates that the impact of the relocation of the exhibition hall on changes in hotel revenue has shown a trend moving from large to small over time, and the rate of change in the areas to which it emigrated is less than that from which it immigrated. 3) Simultaneously, however, the growth in the number of hotels near Pazhou are not enough to manage the surge in demand for accommodation during the exhibition, and the hotel supply pattern of the Yuexiu District still dominates the regional competition due to a special hotel purchase mode which ensures that the original demand for accommodation remains there. This inhibits the "dual-core" revenue pattern of the municipal hotel industry from evolving into a "single-core" pattern centered on the new location of the exhibition hall. This will ensure that the overall and average revenue of the hotel industry in Yuexiu District maintains a long-term revenue advantage after the relocation of the exhibition hall.

Key words: conference and exhibition, star-rated hotel, revenue pattern, spatial reconstruction, Canton Fair, Guangzhou

中图分类号:

F592.99

辛晓东, 保继刚, 刘义. 展馆迁址对城市星级酒店营收格局的空间重构——广交会实证[J]. 热带地理, 2020, 40(5): 930-941.

Xiaodong Xin, Jigang Bao, Yi Liu. Relocating the Canton Fair Changes the Spatial Construction of the Income Pattern of Regional Star-Rated Hotels in Guangzhou[J]. Tropical Geography, 2020, 40(5): 930-941.

图/表 10

图1

图2

图3

图4

图5

表1

图6

图7

表2

图8

参考文献 0

	Braun Bradley M. 1992. The Economic Contribution of Conventions: The Case of Orlando, Florida. Journal of Travel Research, 30(3): 32-37.
	保继刚，梁增贤．2011.基于层次与等级的城市旅游供给分析框架．人文地理，26（6）：1-9．[Bao Jigang and Liang Zengxian. 2011. An Analysis Framework for Supply-Side of Urban Tourism Based on Levels and Hierarchies. Human Geography, 26(6): 1-9. ]
	保继刚，李郇．2012．“借口”：中国城市资本高度集聚的政治经济学分析框架．人文地理，27（4）：1-8．[Bao Jigang and Li Xun. 2012. "Excuses": A Political Economic Analysis of the High Concentration of Capital in Urban China. Human Geography, 27(4): 1-8. ]
	Connell J and Page S J. 2005. Evaluating the Economic and Spatial Effects of an Event: The Case of the World Medical and Health Games. Tourism Geographies, 7(1): 63-85.
	Crompton J L. 1995. Economic Impact Analysis of Sports Facilities and Events: Eleven Sources of Misapplication. Journal of Sport Management, 9(1): 14-35.
	程露悬．2002．论广州新会展中心的形成对广州酒店业的影响．旅游学刊，17（2）：49-51．[Cheng Luxuan. 2002. On the Impact of the Forming of Guangzhou's New Convention and Exhibition Centre on Its Hospitality Industry. Tourism Tribune, 17(2): 49-51. ]
	戴光全．2004．重大事件的影响研究——以99昆明世界园艺博览会为例．广州：中山大学．[Dai Guangquan. 2004. Study on the Impact of Mega-Events—Taking the '99 Kunming World Horticultural Exposition as an Example. Guangzhou: Sun Yat-sen University. ]
	戴光全，保继刚．2007．昆明世博会效应的定量估算：本底趋势线模型．地理科学，27（3）：426-433．[Dai Guangquan and Bao Jigang. 2007. Quantitative Effects Assessments of Expo '99 Kunming: Model of Background Trend Line. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 27(3): 426-433. ]
	Daniels M J. 2007. Central Place Theory and Sport Tourism Impacts. Annals of Tourism Research, 34(2): 332-347.
	方忠权．2013．广州会展企业空间集聚特征与影响因素．地理学报，68（4）：464-476．[Fang Zhongquan. 2013. The Agglomeration Characteristics and Influencing Factors of Exhibition Enterprises in Guangzhou. Acta Geographica Sinica, 68(4): 464-476. ]
	郭光明．2012．广州酒店患上广交会依赖症房价出现负增长．（2012-05-09）[2019-10-05]．中国旅游报，https://www.meadin.com/jd/.73703.html．[Guo Guangming. 2012. Guangzhou Hotel Suffered from Canton Fair Dependence Disorder Shows Negative Price Growth. (2012-05-09）[2019-10-05]. China Tourism News, https://www.meadin.com/jd/73703.html. ]
	Kim S S, Chon K and Chung K Y. 2003. Convention Industry in South Korea: An Economic Impact Analysis. Tourism Management, 24(5): 533-541.
	刘嘉毅，赵磊．2013．中国五星级酒店区位布局：特征与影响因素．旅游学刊，28（8）：87-93．[Liu Jiayi and Zhao Lei. 2013 Location Layout of Chinese Five-Star Hotel: Characteristics and Influencing Factors. Tourism Tribune, 28(8): 87-93. ]
	罗秋菊，李晓莉．2005．会展与酒店效益及配置关系研究——以中国出口商品交易会（广交会）为例．旅游科学，19（2）：66-72．[Luo Qiuju and Li Xiaoli. 2005. Research on the Relationship between Exhibition and Hotel Benefit and Configuration—A Case Study of the China Export Commodities Fair (Canton Fair). Tourism Science, 19(2): 66-72. ]
	罗秋菊，庞嘉文，靳文敏．2011a．基于投入产出模型的大型活动对举办地的经济影响——以广交会为例．地理学报，66（4）：487-503．[Luo Qiuju, Pang Jiawen and Jin Wenmin. 2011a. An Empirical Study on the Economic Impact of the Events with Input-Output Model: A Case Study of Canton Fair, China. Acta Geographica Sinic, 66(4): 487-503. ]
	罗秋菊，杨娟．2011b．大型展会终端客户住宿产品购买模式研究——以广交会为例．人文地理，26（5）：105-110．[Luo Qiuju and Yang Juan. 2011b. A Study on Purchase Style of Terminal Clients in Mega Exhibition Buying Accommodation Products: A Case Study of Canton Fair. Human Geography, 26(5): 105-110. ]
	李庄容．2007．基于竞争视角的广州高星级酒店集聚分析．经济地理，27（4）：697-700．[Li Zhuangrong. 2007. An Analysis of High-Star Hotels Agglomeration in Guangzhou: Based on Competitive Perspective. Economic Geography, 27(4): 697-700. ]
	梅林，韩蕾．2011．中国星级酒店空间分布与影响因子分析．经济地理，31（9）：1580-1584．[Mei Lin and Han Lei. 2011. A Study into the Factors Influencing the Spatial Distribution of Star-Rated Hotels in China. Economic Geography, 31(9): 1580-1584. ]
	Mistilis N and Dwyer L. 1999. Tourism Gateways and Regional Economies: The Distributional Impacts of MICE. The International Journal of Tourism Research, 1(6): 441.
	彭青，张骁鸣，曾国军．2009．广交会与2010年亚运会对广州酒店空间格局的影响．地理科学，29（2）：154-160．[Peng Qing, Zhang Xiaoming and Zeng Guojun. 2009. The Impacts of Canton Fair and Asian Games 2010 on the Spatial Pattern of Guangzhou's Hotels. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 29(2): 154-160. ]
	仇学琴．2002．世博会之后云南省饭店业现状及发展趋势研究．经济问题探索，（2）：113-118．[Qiu Xueqin. 2002. Research on the Status and Development Trend of Hotel Industry in Yunnan Province after the World Expo. Inquiry into Economic Issues, (2): 113-118. ]
	孙平，师佳英．2001．昆明酒店业现状、发展及对策研究．云南经济管理干部学院学报，（1）：26-30．[Sun Ping and Shi Jiaying. 2001. Research on the Status, Development and Countermeasures of Kunming Hotel Industry. Journal of Yunnan Finance & Economics University, (1): 26-30. ]
	王朝辉，陆林，方婷，夏巧云．2012．世博建设期上海市旅游住宿产业空间格局演化．地理学报，67（10）：129-143．[Wang Chaohui, Lu Lin, Fang Ting and Xia Qiaoyun. 2012. Spatial Pattern Evolution of Shanghai Tourist Lodging Industry during the World Expo Construction Period. Acta Geographica Sinica, 67(10): 129-143. ]
	王云龙．2005．关于会展经济空间运动形式的分析——以北京、上海与广州三地为例．人文地理，20（4）：26-29．[Wang Yunlong. 2005. On the Mode of Spatial Movement of Mice Economy—A Case Study of Beijing, Shanghai and Guangzhou. Human Geography, 20(4): 26-29. ]
	吴国清．2010．大型节事对城市旅游空间发展的影响机理．人文地理，25（5）：137-141．[Wu Guoqing. 2010. Influence Mechanism of Mega-Event on the Urban Tourist Spatial Development. Human Geography, 25(5): 137-141. ]
	文吉. 2006. 广州市星级酒店空间发展格局. 经济地理，26（3）：451-455. [Wen Ji. 2006. Study on Star-Hotel Spatial Distribution Development in Guangzhou. Economic Geography, 26(3): 451-455. ]
	熊伟，吴必虎．2008．大型展会对高星级酒店房价影响的空间分析——以第100届广交会为例．旅游学刊，23（2）：80-86．[Xiong Wei and Wu Bihu. 2008. A Spatial Analysis of the Impact of Large-Scale Exhibitions on the Room Rates of Luxury Hotels—A Case Study of the 100th Canton Commodities Fair. Tourism Tribune, 23(2): 80-86. ]
	许艳，陆林，周李，储小乐，胡璇，宋丹然．2019．广交会对珠三角经济圈星级酒店房价影响研究——以第117届和第118届为例．安徽师范大学学报（自然科学版），42（2）：76-84．[Xu Yan, Lu Lin, Zhou Li,Chu Xiaole, Hu Xuan and Song Danran. 2009. Research on the Influence of Canton Fair on the Star Hotels' Housing Price in the Pearl River Delta: Take the 117th and 118th Canton Fair as an Example. Journal of Anhui Normal University (Natural Science), 42(2): 76-84. ]
	姚壮波．2013．CF展会境外采购商酒店选择的影响因素研究．广州：华南理工大学，51-52．[Yao Zhuangbo. 2013. The Study on the Influence Factors of CF Overseas Buyers Select Hotel. Guangzhou: South China University of Technology, 52-52. ]
	余构雄，戴光全．2017．标志性政府运作型展览会对城市展览业发展的负面效应——以广交会为例．当代经济管理，39（1）：66-72．[Yu Gouxiong and Dai Guangquan. 2017. The Negative Effects of the Iconic Government-Operating Expositions to the Development of City Exhibition Industry—A Case Study of the Canton Fair. Contemporary Economic Management, 39(1): 66-72. ]
	张京祥，殷洁，罗震东．2007．地域大事件营销效应的城市增长机器分析：以南京奥体新城为例．经济地理，27（3）：452-457．[Zhang Jingxiang, Yin Jie and Luo Zhendong. 2007. Analysis of Urban Growth Machine Based on Great Event Marketing: Case Study of Nanjing New Olympic City. Economic Geography, 27(3): 452-457. ]
	张玲，邬永强．2010．标志性事件与城市饭店的空间布局——以广交会为例．经济地理，30（8）：1304-1309．[Zhang Ling and Wu Yongqiang. 2010. Hallmark Event and Spatial Distribution of Urban Hotel—Taking Canton Fair as a Case. Economic Geography, 30(8): 1304-1309. ]
	张玲，邬永强．2013．广州市会展旅游产业集聚过程及形成机理研究．人文地理，28（2）：111-116．[Zhang Ling and Wu Yongqiang. 2013. The Evolution and Formation Mechanism of Mice Tourism Cluster in Guangzhou. Human Geography, 28(2): 111-116. ]
	张海洲，朱其静，陆林，徐雨晨．2018．广交会商务旅游者的空间行为模式与空间扩散．世界地理研究，27（2）：131-142．[Zhang Haizhou, Zhu Qijing, Lu Lin and Xu Yuchen. 2018. Spatial Behavior Patterns and Spatial Diffusion of Chinese Domestic Participants of Canton Fair. World Regional Studies, 27(2): 131-142. ]
	周常春．2004a．城市会展业影响的初步研究—以2003中国国际旅游交易会为例．社会科学家，（4）：94-96．[Zhou Changchun. 2004a. A Preliminary Study on the Impact of Urban Convention and Exhibition Industry—Taking the 2003 China International Tourism Trade Fair as an Example. Social Scientist, (4): 94-96. ]
	周常春．2004b．城市会展业直接经济影响的对比研究．思想战线，30（5）：89-93．[Zhou Changchun. 2004b. A Comparative Study of the Direct Economic Impacts of Urban Convention and Exhibition Industry. The Ideological Front, 30(5): 89-93. ]
	周李，张清源，朱其静，陆林．2017．广交会对星级酒店房价影响的时空分异研究——以第117和118届广交会为例．地理科学，37（9）：1363-1373．[Zhou Li, Zhang Qingyuan, Zhu Qijing and Lu Lin. 2017. Spatio-Temporal Differentiation in the Effects of Canton Fair on Hotel Prices: A Case Study of the 117th and 118th Canton Fair. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 37(9): 1363-1373. ]

行政区	结构	2008年春交会		2012年春交会
行政区	结构	收入/万元	占比/%	收入/万元	占比/%
越秀	合计	21 958		17 691
	高星	17 962	81.80	15 195	85.89
	低星	3 996	18.20	2 496	14.11
荔湾	合计	3 757		2 212
	高星	3 088	82.19	2 065	93.35
	低星	669	17.81	147	6.65
海珠	合计	1 470		4 457
	高星	789	53.69	3 930	88.17
	低星	681	46.31	527	11.83
天河	合计	5 414		9 707
	高星	2 201	40.65	6 673	68.74
	低星	3 213	59.35	3 034	31.26
白云	合计	1 228		1 218
	高星	580	47.22	*
	低星	648	52.78	*
黄埔	合计	110		1 497
	高星	*		1 280	85.51
	低星	*		217	14.49
番禺	合计	1 784		2 781
	高星	652	36.56	1 711	61.52
	低星	1 132	63.44	1 070	38.48

酒店所在地区	与流花展馆距离平均值		与琶洲展馆距离平均值
酒店所在地区	时间/min	距离/km	时间/min	距离/km
流花地区酒店	5（步行）	0.5	23	15.3
环市东路酒店	7	4.1	19	12.3
体育中心酒店	16	9.7	15.3	9.1
珠江新城酒店	16	10.25	11.5	6.6

[1]	朱洪平, 朱文涛, 郑荣宝. 地铁对服务业集聚的影响——以广州市为例[J]. 热带地理, 2021, 41(1): 114-123.
[2]	李嘉欣, 郑卓, 谷俊杰, 马婷, 易西兵, 汤永杰. 广州城区晚全新世环境变迁与人类活动[J]. 热带地理, 2021, 41(1): 67-81.
[3]	潘卓林, 刘晔, 刘于琪, 李志刚. 基于场域理论的城中村村民市民化研究——以广州猎德复建房社区为例[J]. 热带地理, 2020, 40(6): 981-992.
[4]	林琳, 严程棋, 杨莹, 范艺馨, 吴箐. 广州老年人小病慢病“旁路”就医行为及其影响因素[J]. 热带地理, 2020, 40(6): 993-1003.
[5]	金利霞, 文志敏, 范建红, 杜志威. 乡村空间重构的理论研究进展与理论框架构建[J]. 热带地理, 2020, 40(5): 765-774.
[6]	陈嘉平, 李静, 温耀鸿. “土地租金剩余”视角下旧厂房改造为创新空间的路径研究——基于广州、深圳对比分析[J]. 热带地理, 2020, 40(5): 795-807.
[7]	边艳, 周春山, 胡锦灿. 基于住房需求意愿的广州市中产阶层住房区位选择[J]. 热带地理, 2020, 40(5): 832-842.
[8]	贺辰戋, 欧阳婷萍, 彭莎莎. 广州市表层土壤磁学性质的空间插值方法比较[J]. 热带地理, 2020, 40(5): 903-918.
[9]	刘颖, 袁媛, 邢汉发, 孟媛, 牛通. 街景图片识别城市贫困的适用性——基于广州市中心城区的验证[J]. 热带地理, 2020, 40(5): 919-929.
[10]	朱战强, 陶小芳, 周素红. 城市居民超重的居住分异[J]. 热带地理, 2020, 40(3): 487-497.
[11]	张晨, 肖大威, 黄翼. 广州市美丽乡村空间分异特征及其影响因素[J]. 热带地理, 2020, 40(3): 551-561.
[12]	宋洁, 周素红, 彭伊侬, 林荣平, 徐建斌. 基于移动监测的城市PM_2.5污染时空模式研究——以广州市中心区为例[J]. 热带地理, 2020, 40(2): 229-242.
[13]	林勋媛, 王广兴, 胡月明. 基于开放大数据的广州市中心城区职住平衡特征研究[J]. 热带地理, 2020, 40(2): 254-265.
[14]	张晨, 周霞, 李勇, 杨骥, 李林. 半封闭大棚实验下广州市植被滞尘光谱特征分析[J]. 热带地理, 2020, 40(2): 266-277.
[15]	赵鑫, 宋英强, 刘轶伦, 陈飞香, 胡月明. 基于卫星遥感和POI数据的人口空间化研究——以广州市为例[J]. 热带地理, 2020, 40(1): 101-109.