Tropical Geography ›› 2019, Vol. 39 ›› Issue (5): 661-670.doi: 10.13284/j.cnki.rddl.003182
Previous Articles Next Articles
Pan Zeqiang1, Ning Chaoqiao2, Yuan Yuan1()
Received:
2019-07-31
Revised:
2019-09-29
Online:
2019-09-10
Published:
2019-11-08
Contact:
Yuan Yuan
E-mail:yuanyuan@mail.sysu.edu.cn
CLC Number:
Pan Zeqiang, Ning Chaoqiao, Yuan Yuan. Collaborative Environmental Management in the Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Greater Bay Area Based on Cross-border Rivers[J].Tropical Geography, 2019, 39(5): 661-670.
Add to citation manager EndNote|Reference Manager|ProCite|BibTeX|RefWorks
Tab.1
The similarities and differences of Danshui River, Shenzhen River and Yayong Canal in collaborative processes"
案例 | 异同分析 | 共性问题 | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
协作模式 | 参与主体 | 规划信息流动 | 机制设计 | ||
淡水河 | 决策主导模式 | 各级政府管理部门 | 以政府间横向流动为主 | 决策主导的协作机制 | ①规划目标不一致。 ②囿于双边协作的形式。 ③公众协作治理意识薄弱。 ④未形成可持续的协作机制。 |
深圳河 | 混合模式 | 政府、环保机构、媒体、公众等 | 政府间与社会公众的横纵向流动 | 市场与政策协调的协作机制 | |
鸭涌河 | 政府主导模式 | 政府、环保机构 | 以政府间横向流动为主 | 政策主导的协作机制 |
1 | Behagel J and Turnhout E . 2011. Democratic Legitimacy in the Implementation of the Water Framework Directive in the Netherlands: towards Participatory and Deliberative Norms?. Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning, 13(3):297-316. |
2 | 曹康, 王晖 . 2009. 从工具理性到交往理性——现代城市规划思想内核与理论的变迁. 城市规划, 33(9):44-51. |
[ Cao Kang and Wang Hui . 2009. From Instrumental Rationality to Communicative Rationality: a Shift of Thought Theories of Modern Urban Planning. City Planning Review, 33(9):44-51.] | |
3 | 陈红燕 . 2010. 界河档案——深港联合治理深圳河工程回顾和展望. 水利发展研究, 10(6):74-77. |
[ Chen Hongyan . 2010. Boundary River Archives- Review and Prospect of Shenzhen-Hong Kong Joint Management of Shenzhen River Project. Water Resources Development Research , 10(6):74-77.] | |
4 | 陈洁汶 . 2011. 基于区域协调发展的流域治理研究——以广东省淡水河流域治理为例. 广州:中山大学. |
[ Chen Jiewen . 2011. Study on River Basin Governance Based on Regional Coordination Development-Based on Danshui River Basin in Guangdong Province. Guangzhou: Sun Yat-Sen University.] | |
5 | 陈翩翩 . 2019. 大力推进鸭涌河综合整治工程建设. 珠海特区报,2019-09-18(2). |
[ Chen Pianpian . 2019. Vigorously Promote the Construction of the Comprehensive Improvement Project of Yayong River. Zhuhai Special Zone Daily, 2019-09-18(2). ] | |
6 | 邓圩 . 2014. 淡水河缘何久治难愈. 人民日报,2014-12-18(9). |
[ Deng Yu . 2014. Why is Danshui River Hard to Repair after a Long-term Control? People’s Daily, 2014-12-18(9). ] | |
7 | 董金柱 . 2004. 国外协作式规划的理论研究与规划实践. 国外城市规划, 19(2):48-52. |
[ Dong Jinzhu . 2004. Foreign Collaborative Planning Theory and Practice. Urban Planning Overseas, 19(2):48-52. ] | |
8 |
Emerson K, Nabatchi T and Balogh S . 2012. An Integrative Framework for Collaborative Governance. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 22(1):1-29.
doi: 10.1093/jopart/mur011 |
9 |
Emery S B and Franks J R . 2012. The Potential for Collaborative Agri-environment Schemes in England: Can a Well-designed Collaborative Approach Address Farmers’ Concerns with Current Schemes? Journal of Rural Studies, 28(3):218-231.
doi: 10.1016/j.jrurstud.2012.02.004 |
10 | Forsyth T . 2004. Critical Political Ecology: the Politics of Environmental Science. London: Routledge. |
11 | Habermas J. 1984. The Theory of Communicative Action. Boston: Beacon Press. |
12 |
Hardy S D and Koontz T M . 2010. Collaborative Watershed Partnerships in Urban and Rural Areas: Different Pathways to Success?. Landscape and Urban Planning, 95(3):79-90.
doi: 10.1016/j.landurbplan.2009.12.005 |
13 | Healey P . 2003. Collaborative Planning in Perspective. Planning Theory, 2(2):101-123. |
14 | 何玮, 曾晓彬 . 2018. 跨域生态治理中政府“不合作”现象分析及完善路径. 管理研究,( 1):1-19. |
[ He Wei and Zeng Xiaobin . 2018. Analysis of the “Non-cooperation” Phenomenon of the Government in Cross-domain Ecological Governance and Improvement of Its Path. Management Research, ( 1):1-19. ] | |
15 | Innes J E and Booher D E . 2004. Reframing Public Participation: Strategies for the 21 st Century . Planning Theory & Practice, 5(4):419-436. |
16 | Innes J E and Booher D E . 2010. Planning with Complexity: An Introduction to Collaborative Rationality for Public Policy. London & New York: Routledge. |
17 | 姜梅, 姜涛 , 2008. “规划中的沟通”与“作为沟通的规划”——当代西方沟通规划理论概述. 城市规划学刊,( 2):31-38. |
[ Jiang Mei and Jiang Tao . 2008. “Communication in Planning” and “Communication as Planning”: A Review on the Contemporary Western Communicative Planning Theory. Urban Planning Forum, ( 2):31-38. ] | |
18 | Kim J S and Batey P W J . 2001. A Collaborative Partnership Approach to Integrated Waterside Revitalization: the Mersey Basin Campaign, North West England. Int. J. Public Priv. Partnerships, 3:145-150. |
19 |
Koehler B and Koontz T M . 2008. Citizen Participation in Collaborative Watershed Partnerships. Environmental Management, 41(2):143.
doi: 10.1007/s00267-007-9040-z |
20 | 李建平 . 2017. 粤港澳大湾区协作治理机制的演进与展望. 规划师, 33(11):53-59. |
[ Li Jianping . 2017. Evolution and Prospect of Cooperative Governance Mechanism in the Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao, Planners, 33(11):53-59. ] | |
21 | 李立勋 . 2017. 关于“粤港澳大湾区”的若干思考. 热带地理, 37(6):757-761. |
[ Li Lixun . 2017. Thinking on the Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Greater Bay Area. Tropical Geography, 37(6):757-761. ] | |
22 | 李郇, 郑莎莉, 梁育填 . 2017. 贸易促进下的粤港澳大湾区一体化发展. 热带地理, 37(6):792-801. |
[ Li Xun, Zheng Shali and Liang Yutian . 2017. Integration Process of the Guangdong- Hongkong- Macao Greater Bay Area under the Promotion of Trade. Tropical Geography, 37(6):792-801. ] | |
23 | 马向明, 陈洋 . 2017. 粤港澳大湾区:新阶段与新挑战. 热带地理, 37(6):762-774. |
[ Ma Xiangming and Chen Yang . 2017. The Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Greater Bay Area: a New Era and a Big Challenge. Tropical Geography, 37(6):762-774. ] | |
24 | 马向明, 吕晓蓓 . 2006. 区域绿地:从概念到实践——一次“协作式规划”的探索. 规划师,( 11):46-50. |
[ Ma Xiangming and Lv Xiaobei . 2006. Regional Greenland: From Concept to Practice. Planners, ( 11):46-50. ] | |
25 | 马小玲 . 2011. 大珠三角环境保护合作进展与区域环境管治分析. 粤港澳区域合作与发展报告(2010—2011). 北京: 社会科学文献出版社, 17. |
[ Ma Xiaoling. 2011. Progress in Environmental Protection Cooperation and Regional Environmental Governance in the Greater Pearl River Delta. Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Regional Cooperation and Development Report (2010-2011). Beijing: Social Sciences Academic Press, 17. ] | |
26 |
Margerum R D . 2008. A Typology of Collaboration Efforts in Environmental Management. Environmental Management, 41(4):487-500.
doi: 10.1007/s00267-008-9067-9 |
27 | Margerum R D and Robinson C J . 2015. Collaborative Partnerships and the Challenges for Sustainable Water Management. Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability, 12:53-58. |
28 | Mcintyre N, Moore J and Yuan M . 2008. A Place-based, Values-centered Approach to Managing Recreation on Canadian Crown Lands. Society and Natural Resources, 21(8):657-670. |
29 | Moore E A and Koontz T M . 2003. Research Note a Typology of Collaborative Watershed Groups: Citizen-based, Agency-based, and Mixed Partnerships. Society & Natural Resources, 16(5):451-460. |
30 | Murdock B S, Wiessner C and Sexton K . 2005. Stakeholder Participation in Voluntary Environmental Agreements: Analysis of 10 Project XL Case Studies. Science, Technology & Human Values, 30(2):223-250. |
31 | 北京大学, 中国电建集团中南勘测设计研究院有限公司. 2016. 深圳河湾流域综合治理方案研究报告(2016-11-01)[2019-04-15]. . |
[ Beijing University and Zhongnan Engineering Corporation Limited. Shenzhen Hewan Basin Comprehensive Management Program Research Report(2016-11-01)[2019-04-15]. ] | |
32 |
Throgmorton J . 2011. Book review. Planning Theory, 10(1):88-91.
doi: 10.1177/1473095210382199 |
33 | Vandenbussche L . 2018. Mapping Stakeholders’ Relating Pathways in Collaborative Planning Processes; A Longitudinal Case Study of an Urban Regeneration Partnership. Planning Theory & Practice, 19(4):534-557. |
34 | 王玉明 . 2018. 粤港澳大湾区环境治理合作的回顾与展望. 哈尔滨工业大学学报(社会科学版), 20(1):117-126. |
[ Wang Yuming . 2018. Retrospect and Prospect of Cooperation on Environmental Governance for Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macau Greater Bay Area. Journal of Harbin Institute of Technology(Social Sciences Edition), 20(1):117-126. ] | |
35 | Weber E P. 2003. Bringing Society Back in: Grassroots Ecosystem Management, Accountability, and Sustainable Communities. Cambridge, America: MIT Press. |
36 | 魏宗财, 陈婷婷, 刘玉亭 . 2019. 粤港澳大湾区跨界地区协同发展模式研究——以广佛为例. 城市规划, 43(1):31-38. |
[ Wei Zongcai, Chen Tingting and Liu Yuting . 2019. Coordinated Development Mode of Cross-border Region of the Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Great Bay Area: A Case Study of Guangzhou-Foshan. City Planning Review, 43(1):31-38. ] | |
37 | 吴磊, 郑君瑜 . 2016. 粤港区域大气环境管理创新机制研究. 资源开发与市场, 32(10):1172-1177. |
[ Wu Lei and Zheng Junyu . 2016. Innovation of Joint Atmospheric Management in Guangdong-Hongkong Region. Resource Development & Market, 32(10):1172-1177. ] | |
38 | 徐静 . 2013. 转型期多方利益诉求下的城市协作设计初探——以江苏连云港北崮山片区城市设计为例//中国城市规划学会. 城市时代,协同规划——2013中国城市规划年会论文集(02-城市设计与详细规划). 北京: 中国城市规划学会, 14. |
[ Xu Jing. 2013. Design of Urban Collaboration under the Multi-interest Demands in the Transition Period-Taking the Urban Design of Beilu Mountain Area in Lianyungang, Jiangsu Province as an Example. In: Urban Planning Society of China. Urban Age, Collaborative Planning - Proceedings of the 2013 China Urban Planning Annual Conference (02-Urban Design and Detailed Planning). Beijing: Urban Planning Society of China, 14. ] | |
39 | 姚华松, 胡蓉, 邵小文 . 2019. 从公共性维度看粤港澳大湾区转型. 热带地理, 39(5):671-677. |
[ Yao Huasong, Hu Rong and Shao Xiaowen . 2019. On Transformation of Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Greater Bay Area from the Public Dimension. Tropical Geography, 39(5):671-677. ] | |
40 | 袁媛, 陈金城 . 2015. 低收入社区的规划协作机制研究——以广州市同德街规划为例. 城市规划学刊,( 1):46-53. |
[ Yuan Yuan and Chen Jincheng . 2015. The Collaborative Mechanism in Urban Planning of Low-income Community-A Case Study of Regulatory Plan of Tongdejie of Guangzhou. Urban Planning Forum, ( 1):46-53. ] | |
41 | 袁媛, 蒋珊红, 刘菁 . 2016. 国外沟通和协作式规划近15年研究进展——基于CitespaceⅢ软件的可视化分析. 现代城市研究,( 12):42-50. |
[ Yuan Yuan, Jiang Shanhong and Liu Jing . 2016. Review on Communicative Planning and Collaborative Planning Research of Foreign Countries in the Past 15 Years: A Visualized Analysis Based on CitespaceⅢ. Modern Urban Research, ( 12):42-50. ] | |
42 | 袁媛, 刘懿莹, 蒋珊红 . 2018. 第三方组织参与社区规划的协作机制研究. 规划师,( 2):11-17. |
[ Yuan Yuan, Liu Yiying and Jiang Shanhong . 2018. The Coordination Mechanism of Third-Party Organization in Community Planning. Planners, ( 2):11-17. ] | |
43 | 张紧跟, 唐玉亮 . 2007. 流域治理中的政府间环境协作机制研究——以小东江治理为例. 公共管理学报,4(3): 50-56, 123-124. |
[ Zhang Jingen and Tang Yuliang . 2007. Research on the Mechanism of Environmental Coordination among Governments to Harness the Pollution of Valleys-Taking Harnessing the Xiao Dong River as an Example. Journal of Public Management, 4(3): 50-56, 123-124. ] | |
44 | 张庭伟 . 2011. 20世纪规划理论指导下的21世纪城市建设——关于“第三代规划理论”的讨论. 城市规划学刊,( 3):1-7. |
[ Zhang Tingwei . 2011. Constructing 21st Century Cities under the Guidance of the 20th Century Planning Theory? On the “Third Generation Planning Theory”. Urban Planning Forum, ( 3):1-7. ] | |
45 | 周春山, 罗利佳, 史晨怡, 王珏晗 . 2017. 粤港澳大湾区经济发展时空演变特征及其影响因素. 热带地理, 37(6):802-813. |
[ Zhou Chunshan, Luo Lijia, Shi Chenyi and Wang Juehan . 2017. Spatio-temporal Evolutionary Characteristics of the Economic Development in the Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Greater Bay Area and Its Influencing Factors. Tropical Geography, 37(6):802-813. ] | |
46 | 周盛盈 . 2017. 粤港澳大湾区视角下跨界水环境保护法治化研究. 一国两制研究, 33(3):119-124. |
[ Zhou Shengying . 2017. Study on the Legalization of Transboundary Water Environment Protection between Zhuhai and Macao. Academic Journal of One Country Two Systems, 33(3):119-124. ] |
|