Tropical Geography ›› 2019, Vol. 39 ›› Issue (5): 711-720.doi: 10.13284/j.cnki.rddl.003176
Previous Articles Next Articles
Received:
2019-03-05
Revised:
2019-09-02
Online:
2019-09-10
Published:
2019-11-08
Contact:
Zhao Ziqi
E-mail:zzq2017@csu.edu.cn
CLC Number:
Fu Yi, Zhao Ziqi. Development and Construction of Institutional Theory for Economic Geography[J].Tropical Geography, 2019, 39(5): 711-720.
Add to citation manager EndNote|Reference Manager|ProCite|BibTeX|RefWorks
Tab.1
Comparison of institutional economic geography, geographic economics and evolutionary economic geography"
比较项目 | 制度经济地理学 | 地理经济学 | 演化经济地理学 |
---|---|---|---|
理论来源 | 老制度经济学、 法国调节学派 | 新古典经济学,区域科学 | 老制度经济学、新熊彼特学派、 奥地利学派、法国调节学派 |
方法论 | 集体主义 | 个体主义 | 整体主义 |
归纳 | 演绎 | 兼有演绎与归纳 | |
案例和比较研究 | 均衡分析 | 研究方法多样化 | |
时间观 | 静态 | 静态 | 动态 |
空间观 | 真实空间 | 中性空间 | 从中性空间到真实空间 |
基础 | 生物学、经济社会学 | 牛顿力学、复杂科学 | 生物学、复杂科学 |
研究尺度 | 从宏观到微观 | 从微观到宏观 | 宏观与微观的相互作用 |
制度 | 制度与情景是特定的 | 制度中性或外生 | 制度与情景是变化的 |
关注区域制度 | 用模型来解释制度效率与福利 | 关注制度本身、制度与偏好、制度与惯例、制度与技术的演化过程 |
Tab.2
Comparison of economic geography in various periods of the 20th century"
比较项目 | 区域地理学时期 | 计量革命时期 | 激进地理学时期 | 制度转向期 | 当前经济地理学 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
时间 | 20世纪30—50年代 | 20世纪50—70年代 | 20世纪70—80年代 | 20世纪90年代 | 2000年以来 |
经济地理 学思潮 | 区域研究 | 区位论、 空间科学 | 马克思主义、 批判现实主义 | 网络与嵌入、地理经济学、 区域集聚 | 演化经济地理学、制度经济地理学、地理经济学、关系经济地理学 |
基本范式 | 区域地理学 范式 | 新古典经济学 范式 | 政治经济学范式 | 社会经济学范式、 地理经济学范式 | 制度经济学、演化经济学、地理 经济学、关系经济地理学 |
关注焦点 | 实体经济的 分布与差异 | 形式经济的 空间法则 | 实体经济中的 社会结构 | 实体经济中的制度、 形式经济的区位规律 | 实体经济的关系、尺度、演化, 技术与创新、区域分异、 |
空间观 | 实际区域 | 中性空间 | 社会关系的场所 | 经济活动嵌入的空间、中性空间 | 视角多样化 |
1 | Amin A and Thrift N . 2000. What Kind of Economic Theory for What Kind of Economic Geography?. Antipode, 32(1):4-9. |
2 | 安虎森, 季赛卫 . 2014. 演化经济地理学理论研究进展. 学习与实践,( 7):5-18. |
[ An Husen and Ji Saiwei . 2014. Theoretical Research Progress of Evolutionary Economic Geography. Study and Practice, ( 7):5-18. ] | |
3 | Balland P A, Boschma R, Crespo J and Rigby D L . 2018. Smart Specialization Policy in the European Union: Relatedness, Knowledge Complexity and Regional Diversification. Papers in Evolutionary Economic Geography, ( 4):1-17. |
4 | Barnes T J. 2000. Inventing Anglo-American Economic Geography, 1989-1960. In: Sheppard E and Barnes T J. A Companion to Economic Geography. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing, 11-26. |
5 | Barnes T J . 2001. ‘In the Beginning Was Economic Geography’-A Science Studies Approach to Disciplinary History. Progress in Human Geography, 25(4):521-544. |
6 | Boschma R A and Lambooy J G . 1999. Evolutionary Economics and Economic Geography. Social Science Electronic Publishing, 9(4):411-429. |
7 | Boschma R A and Frenken K . 2006. Why is Economic Geography not an Evolutionary Science? Towards an Evolutionary Economic Geography. Papers in Evolutionary Economic Geography, 6(3):273-302. |
8 | Boschma R A and Martin R . 2007. Editorial: Constructing an Evolutionary Economic Geography. Journal of Economic Geography, 7(5):537-548. |
9 | Boschma R and Frenken K . 2009 a. Some Notes on Institutions in Evolutionary Economic Geography. Economic Geography, 85(2):151-158. |
10 | Boschma R and Iammarino S . 2009b. Related Variety, Trade Linkages, and Regional Growth in Italy. Economic Geography, 85(3):23. |
11 | Boschma R and Martin R . 2009. The Aims and Scope of Evolutionary Economic Geography. In: Boschma R and Martin R. The Handbook of Evolutionary Economic Geography. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar, 3-39. |
12 |
Boschma R A and Fornahl D . 2011. Cluster Evolution and a Roadmap for Future Research. Regional Studies, 45(10):1295-1298.
doi: 10.1080/00343404.2011.633253 |
13 | Boschma R A and Frenken K . 2015. Evolutionary Economic Geography (2018-01-30)[2018-12-06]. . |
14 | Boschma R, Coenen L, Frenken K and Truffer B . 2018. Towards a Theory of Regional Diversification: Combining Insights from Evolutionary Economic Geography and Transition Studies. Regional Studies, 51(1):31-45. |
15 | Broekel T and Boschma R A . 2012. Knowledge Networks in the Dutch Aviation Industry: The Proximity Paradox. Papers in Evolutionary Economic Geography, 12(2):409-433. |
16 | Carli G and Morrison A . 2018. On the Evolution of the Castel Goffredo Hosiery Cluster: A Life Cycle Perspective. European Planning Studies, 26(5):915-932. |
17 | Chisholm G G . 1908. Handbook of Commercial Geography. London and New York, Bombay and Calcutta: Longmans, Green, and Co. |
18 | Clark G L, Feldman M P and Gertler M S . 2000. Economic Geography: Transition and Growth. In: Clark G L, Feldman M P and Gertler M S. The Oxford Handbook of Economic Geography. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 3-17. |
19 |
David P A . 2007. Path Dependence: A Foundational Concept for Historical Social Science. Cliometrica, 1(2):91-114.
doi: 10.1007/s11698-006-0005-x |
20 | Diodato D, Neffke F and O’Clery N . 2018. Why Do Industries Coagglomerate? How Marshallian Externalities Differ by Industry and Have Evolved Over Time (2018-03-16)[2018-12-06]. . |
21 | Essletzbichler J . 2009. Evolutionary Economic Geography, Institutions, and Political Economy. Economic Geography, 85(2):159-165. |
22 | 傅星, 林寅 . 2006. 基于多主体经济仿真的应用研究. 系统仿真学报, 18(2):434-438. |
[ Fu Xing and Lin Yin . 2006. Application Research Based on Multi-agent Economic Simulation. Journal of System Simulation, 18(2):434-438. ] | |
23 | 傅沂 . 2008. 路径依赖经济学分析框架的演变――从新制度经济学到演化经济学. 江苏社会科学,( 3):63-70. |
[ Fu Yi . 2008. Evolution of the Analytical Framework of Path Dependence Economics-From New Institutional Economics to Evolutionary Economics. Jiangsu Social Sciences, ( 3):63-70. ] | |
24 | 傅沂 . 2018. 路径构造理论与演化经济学:分离还是融合? 学习与探索,( 8):122-129. |
[ Fu Yi . 2018. Path Construction Theory and Evolutionary Economics: Separation or Integration? Study & Exploration, ( 8):122-129. ] | |
25 | Gertler M S . 2010. Rules of the Game: The Place of Institutions in Regional Economic Change. Regional Studies, 44(1):1-15. |
26 | Grabber G . 2009. Yet Another Turn? The Evolutionary Project in Economic Geography. Economic Geography, 85(2):119-127. |
27 | 顾朝林, 王恩儒, 石爱华 . 2002. “新经济地理学”与经济地理学的分异与对立. 地理学报, 57(4):497-504. |
[ Gu Chaolin, Wang Enru and Shi Aihua . 2002. Divarication and Opposability between “New Economic Geography” and Economic Geography. Acta Geologica Sinica, 57(4):497-504. ] | |
28 | Harvey D . 1973. Social Justice and the City. London: Edward Arnold. |
29 | Harvey D . 1982. The Limits of Capital. Oxford: Blackwell. |
30 | 贺灿飞, 郭琪, 马妍, 范帅邦, 赵瑜嘉 . 2014. 西方经济地理学研究进展. 地理学报, 69(8):1207-1223. |
[ He Canfei, Guo Qi, Ma Yan, Fan Shuaibang and Zhao Yujia . 2014. Progress of Economic Geography in the West: A Literature Review. Acta Geologica Sinica, 69(8):1207-1223. ] | |
31 | 贺灿飞 . 2018 a.区域产业发展演化:路径依赖还是路径创造? 地理研究, 37(7):1253-1267. |
[ He Canfei . 2008 a. Regional Industrial Development and Evolution: Path Dependence or Path Creation? Geographical Research, 37(7):1253-1267. ] | |
32 | 贺灿飞 . 2018 b.演化经济地理学研究. 北京: 经济科学出版社. |
[ He Canfei. 2018b. Research on Evolutionary Economic Geography. Beijing: Economic Science Press. ] | |
33 | 何一鸣 . 2016. 制度经济地理学范式. 北京: 科学出版社. |
[ He Yiming. 2016. Paradigm of Institutional Economic Geography. Beijing: Science Press. ] | |
34 | 黄凯南, 黄少安 . 2009. 认知理性与制度经济学. 南开经济研究,( 6):3-17. |
[ Huang Kainan and Huang Shaoan . 2009. Cognitive Rationality and Institutional Economics. Nankai Economic Research, ( 6):3-17. ] | |
35 | 黄凯南 . 2010. 主观博弈论与制度内生演化. 经济研究,( 4):134-146. |
[ Huang Kainan . 2010. Subjective Games and Endogenous Evolution of Institutions. Economic Research Journal, ( 4):134-146. ] | |
36 | 黄凯南 . 2016. 制度演化经济学的理论发展与建构. 中国社会科学,( 5):65-78. |
[ Huang Kainan . 2016. Theoretical Development and Construction of Institutional Evolutionary Economics. Social Sciences in China, ( 5):65-78. ] | |
37 | 黄利秀 . 2014. 从新经济地理学到演化经济地理学:区域政策含义及其启示. 商业研究,(9): 21-26, 80. |
[ Huang Lixiu . 2014. From New Economic Geography to Evolutionary Economic Geography: Regional Policy Implications and Its Enlightenment. Commercial Research,(9): 21-26, 80. ] | |
38 | Hodgson G M . 2003. The Hidden Persuaders: Institutions and Individuals in Economic Theory. Cambridge Journal of Economics, 27(2):159-175. |
39 | Hodgson G M . 2006. What Are Institutions?. Journal of Economic Issues, 40(1):1-25. |
40 | Hodgson G M . 2007. Institutions and Individuals: Interaction and Evolution. Organization Studies, 28(1):95-116. |
41 | Hodgson G M . 2009. Agency, Institutions, and Darwinism in Evolutionary Economic Geography. Economic Geography, 85(2):167-173. |
42 | 霍奇逊 . 2012. 制度经济学的演化: 美国制度主义中的能动性、结构和达尔文主义.杨虎涛,王爱君,黄载曦,马芳. 译. 北京: 北京大学出版社. |
[ Hodgson . 2012. Evolution of Institutional Economics: Agency, Structure and Darwinism in American Institutionalism. Yang Hutao, Wang Aijun, Huang Zaixi and Ma Fang. Trans. Beijing: Peking University Press. ] | |
43 | 霍奇逊 . 2017. 演化与制度: 论演化经济学和经济学的演化.任荣华,张林,洪福海,徐华,杨永锋,岳超云,王峰,孟捷,译. 北京: 中国人民大学出版社. |
[ Hodgson. 2017. Evolution and Institutions: On Evolutionary Economics and Evolution of Economics. Ren Ronghua, Zhang Lin, Hong Fuhai, Xu Hua, Yang Yongfeng, Yue Chaoyun, Wang Feng and Meng Jie. Translation. Beijing: China Renmin University Press. ] | |
44 | 洪永淼 . 2007. 计量经济学的地位、作用和局限. 经济研究,( 5):139-153. |
[ Hong Yongmiao . 2007. The Status, Roles and Limitations of Econometrics. Economic Research Journal, ( 5):139-153. ] | |
45 | 胡志丁, 葛岳静, 侯雪, 唐顺英 . 2012. 经济地理研究的第三种方法:演化经济地理. 地域研究与开发, 31(5):89-94. |
[ Hu Zhiding, Ge Yuejing, Hou Xue and Tang Shunying . 2012. The Third Approach of Economic Geography: Evolutionary Economics. Areal Research and Development, 31(5):89-94. ] | |
46 | Huiwen G and Robert H . 2019. Co-evolution in Contemporary Economic Geography: Towards a Theoretical Framework. Regional Studies, 53(9):1344-1355. |
47 | 贾根良 . 2004. 理解演化经济学. 中国社会科学,( 2):33-41. |
[ Jia Genliang . 2004. Understanding Evolutionary Economics. Social Sciences in China, ( 2):33-41. ] | |
48 | Jing X, Boschma R and Andersson M . 2018. Industrial Diversification in Europe: The Differentiated Role of Relatedness. Papers in Evolutionary Economic Geography, ( 2):1-36. |
49 | 克拉瓦尔. 2015. .郑胜华,刘德美,刘清华,阮绮霞. 译. 北京: 北京大学出版社. |
[ Paul Claval. 2015. History of Geographical Thoughts . Zheng Shenghua, Liu Demei, Liu Qinghua and Ruan Qixia. Translation. Beijing: Peking University Press. ] | |
50 |
Lambooy J G and Boschma R A . 2001. Evolutionary Economics and Regional Policy. Annals of Regional Science, 35(1):113-131.
doi: 10.1007/s001680000033 |
51 | 李福柱 . 2011. 演化经济地理学的理论框架与研究范式:一个文献综述. 经济地理, 31(12):1975-1980. |
[ Li Fuzhu . 2011. The Research Paradigm and Theoretical System of Evolutionary Economic Geography: A Review of Papers. Economic Geography, 31(12):1975-1980. ] | |
52 | 李洪磊, 甘仞初 . 2006. 一种基于多主体仿真的制度有效性分析方法研究. 系统仿真学报, 18(2):444-447. |
[ Li Honglei and Gan Renchu . 2006. A System Effectiveness Analysis Method Based on Multi-agent Simulation. Journal of System Simulation, 18(2):444-447. ] | |
53 | 李小建, 苗长虹 . 2004. 西方经济地理学新进展及其启示. 地理学报,( S1):153-161. |
[ Li Xiaojian and Miao Changhong . 2004. Recent Developments in Western Economic Geography and Theoretical Thinking for China’s Counterpart. Acta Geographica Sinica, ( S1):153-161. ] | |
54 | 刘汉民, 谷志文, 康丽群 . 2012. 国外路径依赖理论研究新进展. 经济学动态,( 4):111-116. |
[ Liu Hanmin, Gu Zhiwen and Kang Liqun . 2012. New Progress of Path Dependence Theory Research Abroad. Economic Perspectives, ( 4):111-116. ] | |
55 | 刘丽艳 . 2013. 计量经济学局限性研究. 财经问题研究,( 3):3-14. |
[ Liu Liyan . 2013. Reflections on Limitations of Econometrics. Research on Financial and Economic Issues, ( 3):3-14. ] | |
56 | 刘志高, 尹贻梅 . 2006 a.经济地理学与经济学关系的历史考察. 经济地理, 26(3):353-358,390. |
[ Liu Zhigao and Yin Yimei . 2006 a. Analysis on the Evolution History of the Relationship between Economic Geography and Economics. Economic Geography, 26(3):353-358, 390. ] | |
57 | 刘志高, 尹贻梅 . 2006 b. 演化经济地理学:当代西方经济地理学发展的新方向. 国外社会科学,( 1):34-39. |
[ Liu Zhigao and Yin Yimei . 2006 b. Evolutionary Economic Geography: A New Development Direction of Contemporary Western Economic Geography. Social Sciences Abroad, ( 1):34-39. ] | |
58 | Mackinnon D, Cumbers A, Pike A, Birch K and McMaster R . 2009. Evolution in Economic Geography: Institutions, Political Economy, and Adaptation. Economic Geography, 85(2):129-150. |
59 | 毛熙彦, 贺灿飞 . 2018. 贸易开放条件下的区域分工与工业污染排放. 地理研究, 37(7):1406-1420. |
[ Mao Xiyan and He Canfei . 2008. Regional Division of Labour and Its Environmental Performance in the Context of Trade Liberalisation. Geographical Research, 37(7):1406-1420. ] | |
60 | Martin R. 2000. Institutional Approaches in Economic Geography. In: Sheppard E and Barnes T J. A Companion to Economic Geography. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing, 77-94. |
61 | 梅尼埃 . 1999. 法国地理学思想史.蔡宗夏,译. 北京: 商务印书馆. |
[ Andre Meynier. 1999. History of the Geographical Thinking in France . Cai Zhongxia. Translation. Beijing: The Commercial Press. ] | |
62 | Menzel M P, Feldman M P and Broekel T . 2017. Institutional Change and Network Evolution: Explorative and Exploitative Tie Formations of Co-inventors during the Dot-com Bubble in the Research Triangle Region. Regional Studies, 51(8):1-13. |
63 | 苗长虹 . 2004. 变革中的西方经济地理学:制度、文化、关系与尺度转向. 人文地理, 19(4):68-76. |
[ Miao Changhong . 2004. Western Economic Geography in Transformation: Institutional, Cultural, Relational and Scalar Turns. Human Geography, 19(4):68-76. ] | |
64 | 苗长虹 . 2007 a.欧美经济地理学的三个发展方向. 地理科学, 27(5):617-623. |
[ Miao Changhong . 2007 a. Three Approaches in Contemporary Economic Geographies. Geographical Science, 27(5):617-623. ] | |
65 | 苗长虹, 魏也华 . 2007b. 西方经济地理学理论建构的发展与论争. 地理研究, 26(6):1233-1246. |
[ Miao Changhong and Wei Yehua . 2007b. Development and Debate in the Theoretical Construction of Economic Geography. Geographical Research, 26(6):1233-1246. ] | |
66 | North D C. 1990. Institutions, Institutional Change and Economic Performance. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. |
67 | 诺斯 . 2013. 理解经济变迁过程.钟正生,邢华,高东明,陈长江,赵晓男,尹振东,王成思. 译. 北京: 中国人民大学出版社. |
[ North D C. 2013. Understanding the Process of Economic Change. Zhong Zhengsheng, Xing Hua, Gao Dongming, Chen Changjiang, Zhao Xiaonan, Yin Zhendong and Wang Chengsi. Translation. Beijing: China Renmin University Press. ] | |
68 | Overman H G . 2004. Can We Learn Anything from Economic Geography Proper? Journal of Economic Geography, 4(5):501-516. |
69 | Peet R . 1975. Inequality and Poverty: A Marxist-geographic Theory. Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 65(4):564-571. |
70 | Pike A, Mackinnon D, Cumbers A and Dawley S . 2015. Doing Evolution in Economic Geography. Papers in Evolutionary Economic Geography, 92(2):123-144. |
71 | Rafiqui P S . 2008. Evolving Economic Landscapes: Why New Institutional Economics Matters for Economic Geography. Journal of Economic Geography, 9(3):329-353. |
72 | Rodríguez-Pose A . 2001. Killing Economic Geography with a “Cultural Turn” Overdose. Antipode, 33(2):176-182. |
73 | Rodríguez-Pose A . 2018. The Revenge of the Places That Don't Matter (and What to Do About it) (2018-04-25) [2018-10-20]. |
74 | 荣朝和 . 2016. 关于经济学时间概念及经济时空分析框架的思考. 北京交通大学学报(社会科学版), 15(3):1-15. |
[ Rong Chaohe . 2016. The Concepts of Time and the Framework of Time-spatial Analysis in Economics. Journal of Beijing Jiaotong University (Social Sciences Edition), 15(3):1-15. ] | |
75 | Scott A J. 2000. Economic Geography: The Great Half-Century. In: Clark G L, Feldman M P and Gertler M S. The Oxford Handbook of Economic Geography. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 18-44. |
76 | Soja E W . 1980. The Socio-spatial Dialectic. Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 70(2):207-225. |
77 | Sydow J, Windeler A, Müller-Seitz G and Lange K . 2012. Path Constitution Analysis: A Methodology for Understanding Path Dependence and Path Creation. Business Research, 5(2):155-176. |
78 | Täube F A, Karna A and Sonderegger P . 2018. Economic Geography and Emerging Market Clusters: A Co-evolutionary Study of Local and Non-local Networks in Bangalore (2018-04-25) [2018-11-20]. |
79 | Voigt S . 2013. How (Not) to Measure Institutions. Journal of Institutional Economics, 9(1):1-26. |
80 | 王爱华 . 1987. 努力学习、研究经济地理学. 理论导刊,( 3):37-39. |
[ Wang Aihua . 1987. Hard Study of Economic Geography. Journal of Socialist Theory Guide, ( 3):37-39. ] | |
81 | 杨虎涛 . 2008. 马克思经济学时间观与演化经济学时间观之比较. 学习与实践,( 2):32-37. |
[ Yang Hutao . 2008. A Comparison between the Time View of Marxist Economics and the Time View of Evolutionary Economics. Study and Practice, ( 2):32-37. ] | |
82 | 杨虎涛 . 2012. 经济学方法论的个体主义、集体主义及其超越. 学术月刊,( 3):90-95. |
[ Yang Hutao . 2012. Individualism, Holism and Transcendence of Them Economics Methodological. Academic Monthly ( 3):90-95. ] | |
83 | 杨吾扬 . 1991. 商业地理学――回顾与前瞻. 人文地理, 6(4):1-5. |
[ Yang Wuyang . 1991. Business Geography-Review and Prospect. Human Geography, 6(4):1-5. ] | |
84 | 颜银根, 安虎森 . 2013. 演化经济地理:经济学与地理学之间的第二座桥梁. 地理科学进展, 32(5):788-796. |
[ Yan Yingen and An Husen . 2013. Evolutionary Economic Geography: The Second Bridge between Economics and Geography. Progress in Geography, 32(5):788-796. ] | |
85 | 叶超, 蔡运龙 . 2009. 地理学方法论变革的案例剖析――重新审视《地理学中的例外论》之争. 地理学报, 64(9):1134-1142. |
[ Ye Chao and Cai Yunlong . 2009. Re-evaluating Schaefer and His Criticizing on Exceptionalism in Geography: A Case Study on the Innovation of Methodology. Acta Geographica Sinica, 64(9):1134-1142. ] | |
86 | 叶超, 蔡运龙 . 2010. 激进地理学的形成和演变――以《异端的传统》为例. 地理科学, 30(1):1-7. |
[ Ye Chao and Cai Yunlong . 2010. Formation and Evolution of Radical Geography-A Case Study as James Blaut’s “The Dissenting Tradition”. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 30(1):1-7. ] | |
87 | Yeung W C . 2003. Practicing New Economic Geographies: A Methodological Examination. Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 93(2):442-462. |
88 | 张祖林 . 1991. 地理学中的计量革命与实证主义方法论. 自然辩证法研究,( 12):8-14. |
[ Zhang Zulin . 1991. Quantitative Revolution and Positivist Methodology in Geography. Studies in Dialectics of Nature, ( 12):8-14. ] | |
89 | Zhu Shengjun, He Canfei and Luo Qian . 2018. Good Neighbors, Bad Neighbors: Local Knowledge Spillovers, Regional Institutions and Firm Performance in China. Small Business Economics, ( 3):1-16. |
|