西方国家社区依恋研究

doi:10.13284/j.cnki.rddl.002711

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

文章对西方国家的“社区依恋”研究进行了回顾总结，首先将社区依恋和地方依恋2个概念进行了对比，之后分为线性发展模型、系统模型和多因素模型等3个发展阶段介绍了社区依恋的研究阶段，并总结了社区依恋的研究方法和影响因素。研究方法主要有以深度访谈、话语分析和图形法等为主的质性研究方法和以问卷调查、测量量表和统计分析为主的量性研究方法，亦有将两者相结合的综合研究方法；影响因素则主要集中在3个方面：人口统计学因素、社会因素和物质环境因素。最后指出，中国的社区依恋研究应充分考虑中国国情，探索适合自身的理论与方法，综合质性与量性研究方法，针对中国丰富多样的社区类型和具有中国特色的影响因素展开研究，为中国相关政策的制定提供依据。

关键词: 地方, 社区依恋, 地方依恋, 居民情感

Abstract:

Based on the literature review of community attachment studies in western countries, this paper 1) compared the concepts of community attachment and place attachment, 2) introduced three research stages including linear-development model, systemic model and multi-model of community attachment research, and 3) summarized the research methods and predictors of community attachment. Specifically, research methods included qualitative methods, such as in-depth interview, discursive analysis and pictorial methods, as well as quantitative methods, such as survey method, scale development and statistical analysis. In addition, some studies combined the above two types of methods. Predictors of community attachment included socio-demographic predictors, social predictors and physical-environmental predictors. Conclusions suggested that research of community attachment in China should explore theories and methods adapted to China’s own conditions, combine qualitative and quantitative methods, conduct research that focuses on various community forms and predictors with Chinese characteristics, so as to provide basis for government’s policy formulation in China.

Key words: place, community attachment, place attachment, sentiment of residents

常江，谢涤湘，黄健文. 西方国家社区依恋研究[J]. 热带地理, 2015, 35(4): 507-514.

CHANG Jiang，XIE Dixiang，HUANG Jianwen. Community Attachment Studies in Western Countries[J]. TROPICAL GEOGRAPHY, 2015, 35(4): 507-514.

参考文献

[1] TUAN Y F．Topophilia：A study of environmental perception [M]．Englewood Cliffs，N J：Columbia University Press，1974．

[2] RELPH E．Place and placelessness[M]．London：Pion，1976．

[3] CRESSWELL T．Place：An introduction[M]．New York：John Wiley & Sons，2014．

[4] GIERYN T F．A space for place in sociology[J]．Annual Review of Sociology，2000，26：463-496．

[5] GUSTAFSON P．Place，place attachment and mobility：Three sociological studies[D]．Gothenburg：University of Gothenburg，2002．

[6] BEATLEY T．Native to nowhere：Sustaining home and community in a global age[M]．Washington D C：Island Press，2005．

[7] CASEY E S．The fate of place：A philosophical history[M]．Oakland：University of California Press，2013．

[8] STEDMAN R C．Toward a social psychology of place predicting behavior from place-based cognitions，attitude，and identity[J]．Environment and Behavior，2002，34（5）：561-581．

[9] BECHTEL R B，CHURCHMAN A．Handbook of environmental psychology[M]．New York：John Wiley & Sons，2002．

[10] WILLIAMS D R．Leisure identities，globalization，and the politics of place[J]．Journal of Leisure Research，2002，34（4）：351-367．

[11] 黄向，保继刚．场所依赖（place attachment）：一种游憩行为现象的研究框架[J]．旅游学刊，2006，21（9）：19-24．

[12] 唐文跃．地方感研究进展及研究框架[J]．旅游学刊，2007，22（11）：70-77．

[13] 朱竑，刘博．地方感、地方依恋与地方认同等概念的辨析及研究启示[J]．华南师范大学学报：自然科学版，2011（1）：1-8．

[14] 朱竑，钱俊希，陈晓亮．地方与认同：欧美人文地理学对地方的再认识[J]．人文地理，2010（6）：1-6．

[15] 朱竑，钱俊希，吕旭萍．城市空间变迁背景下的地方感知与身份认同研究[J]．地理科学，2012，32（1）：18-24．

[16] 单菁菁．社区归属感与社区满意度[J]．城市问题，2008（3）：58-64．

[17] 叶继红．城郊农民集中居住区移民社区归属感研究[J]．西北人口，2011（3）：27-30.

[18] 陈宏胜，李志刚．广州住房与保障房的建设与评价[J]．热带地理，2014，34（6）：823-830．

[19] TÖNNIES F．Community and society[M]．Translated by LOOMIS C．New York：Harper Torchbook，1957．

[20] 单菁菁．城市社区情感研究[D]．北京：中国社会科学学院，2003．

[21] THEODORI G L，LULOFF A E．Urbanization and community attachment in rural areas[J]．Society & Natural Resources，2000，13（5）：399-420．

[22] TRENTELMAN C K．Place attachment and community attachment：A primer grounded in the lived experience of a community sociologist [J]．Society and Natural Resources，2009，22（3）：191-210．

[23] SUNDBLAD D R，SAPP S G．The persistence of neighboring as a determinant of community attachment：A community field perspective [J]．Rural Sociology，2011，76（4）：511-534．

[24] WASSERMAN I M．Size of place in relation to community attachment and satisfaction with community services[J]．Social Indicators Research，1982，11（4）：421-436．

[25] MATARRITA-CASCANTE D，LULOFF A E．Profiling participative residents in western communities[J]．Rural Sociology，2008，73（1）：44-61．

[26] HIDALGO M C，HERNANDEZ B．Place attachment：Conceptual and empirical questions[J]．Journal of Environmental Psychology，2001，21（3）：273-281．

[27] PRETTY G H，CHIPUER H M，BRAMSTON P．Sense of place amongst adolescents and adults in two rural Australian towns：The discriminating features of place attachment，sense of community and place dependence in relation to place identity[J]．Journal of Environmental Psychology，2003，23（3）：273-287．

[28] BREHM J M．Community attachment：The complexity and consequence of the natural environment facet[J]．Human Ecology，2007，35（4）：477-488．

[29] BROWN B，PERKINS D，BROWN G．Place attachment in a revitalizing neighborhood：Individual and block levels of analysis[J]．Journal of Environmental Psychology，2003，23（3）：259-271．

[30] BREHM J M，EISENHAUER B W，KRANNICH R S．Community attachments as predictors of local environmental concern：The case for multiple dimensions of attachment[J]．American Behavioral Scientist，2006，50（2）：142-165．

[31] WIRTH L．Urbanism as a way of life[J]．American Journal of Sociology，1938，44（1）：1-24．

[32] FISCHER C S．Toward a subcultural theory of urbanism[J]．American Journal of Sociology，1975，80（6）：1319-1341．

[33] KASARDA J D，JANOWITZ M．Community attachment in mass society [J]．American Sociological Review，1974，39（3）：328-339．

[34] BUTTEL F H，MARTINSON O B，WILKENING E A．Size of place and community attachment：a reconsideration[J]．Social Indicators Research，1979，6（4）：475-485．

[35] THOMAS W I．On social organization and social personality：Selected papers[M]．Chicago：University of Chicago Press，1966．

[36] PARK R E，BURGESS E W．Introduction to the science of sociology [M]．Chicago：University of Chicago Press，1921．

[37] SAMPSON R J．Local friendship ties and community attachment in mass society：A multilevel systemic model[J]．American Sociological Review，1988，53（5）：766-779．

[38] GOUDY W J．Community attachment in a rural region[J]．Rural Sociology，1990，55（2）：178-198．

[39] BROWN B．Rural community satisfaction and attachment in mass consumer society[J]．Rural Sociology，1993，58（3）：387-403．

[40] BREHM J M，EISENHAUER B W，KRANNICH R S．Dimensions of community attachment and their relationship to well-being in the amenity-rich rural west[J]．Rural Sociology，2004，69（3）：405-429．

[41] STEDMAN R C．Is it really just a social construction? The contribution of the physical environment to sense of place[J]．Society & Natural Resources，2003，16（8）：671-685．

[42] BONAIUTO M，FORNARA F，BONNES M．Indexes of perceived residential environment quality and neighbourhood attachment in urban environments：a confirmation study on the city of Rome[J]．Landscape and Urban Planning，2003，65（1）：41-52．

[43] THEODORI G L．Community attachment，satisfaction，and action [J]．Community Development，2004，35（2）：73-86．

[44] VAN PATTEN S R，WILLIAMS D R．Problems in place：Using discursive social psychology to investigate the meanings of seasonal homes[J]．Leisure Sciences，2008，30（5）：448-464．

[45] BOW V，BUYS L．Sense of community and place attachment：The natural environment plays a vital role in developing a sense of community[C]// Queensland University of Technology．The Social Change in the 21st Century．Brisbane：Queensland University of Technology，2003：1-18．

[46] PLAS J M，LEWIS S E．Environmental factors and sense of community in a planned town[J]．American Journal of Community Psychology，1996，24（1）：109-143．

[47] STEDMAN R，BECKLEY T，WALLACE S，et al．A picture and 1000 words：Using resident-employed photography to understand attachment to high amenity places[J]．Journal of Leisure Research，2004，36（5）：580-606．

[48] BECKLEY T M，STEDMAN R C，WALLACE S M，et al．Snapshots of what matters most：Using resident-employed photography to articulate attachment to place[J]．Society & Natural Resources，2007，20（10）：913-929．

[49] GUEST A M，LEE B A．Sentiment and evaluation as ecological variables [J]．Sociological Perspectives，1983，26（2）：159-184．

[50] AUSTIN D M，BABA Y．Social determinants of neighborhood attachment [J]．Sociological Spectrum，1990，10（1）：59-78．

[51] O'BRIEN D J，HASSINGER E W．Community attachment among leaders in five rural communities[J]．Rural Sociology，1992，57（4）：521-534．

[52] RIGER S，LAVRAKAS P J．Community ties：Patterns of attachment and social interaction in urban neighborhoods[J]．American Journal of Community Psychology，1981，9（1）：55-66．

[53] STINNER W F，LOON M，CHUNG S W，et al．Community size，individual social position，and community attachment[J]．Rural Sociology，1990，55（4）：494-52．

[54] BO?AÇ C．Place attachment in a foreign settlement[J]．Journal of Environmental Psychology，2009，29（2）：267-278．

[55] BROWN G，RAYMOND C．The relationship between place attachment and landscape values：Toward mapping place attachment[J]．Applied Geography，2007，27（2）：89-111．

[56] PONZETTI J．Growing old in rural communities：A visual methodology for studying place attachment[J]．Journal of Rural Community Psychology，2003，6（1）：1-11．

[57] LEWICKA M．What makes neighborhood different from home and city? Effects of place scale on place attachment[J]．Journal of Environmental Psychology，2010，30（1）：35-51．

[58] BONAIUTO M，AIELLO A，PERUGINI M，et al．Multidimensional perception of residential environment quality and neighborhood attachment in the urban environment[J]．Journal of Environmental Psychology，1999，19（4）：331-352．

[59] FLEURY-BAHI G，FÉLONNEAU M L，MARCHAND D．Processes of place identification and residential satisfaction[J]．Environment and Behavior，2008，40（5）：669-682．

[60] GOUDY W J．Further consideration of indicators of community attachment[J]．Social Indicators Research，1982，11（2）：181-192．

[61] GUSTAFSON P．Mobility and territorial belonging[J]．Environment and Behavior，2009，41（4）：490-508．

[62] HAY R．Sense of place in developmental context[J]．Journal of Environmental Psychology，1998，18（1）：5-29．

[63] HERNÁNDEZ B，HIDALGO M C，SALAZAR-LAPLACE M E，et al．Place attachment and place identity in natives and non-natives [J]．Journal of Environmental Psychology，2007，27（4）：310-319．

[64] BOLAN M．The mobility experience and neighborhood attachment [J]．Demography，1997，34（2）：225-237．

[65] NG S H，KAM P K，PONG R W M．People living in ageing buildings：Their quality of life and sense of belonging[J]．Journal of Environmental Psychology，2005，25（3）：347-360．

[66] MCANDREW F T．The measurement of "rootedness" and the prediction of attachment to home-towns in college students[J]．Journal of Environmental Psychology，1998，18（4）：409-417．

[67] BROWN B，PERKINS D，BROWN G．Incivilities，place attachment and crime：Block and individual effects[J]．Journal of Environmental Psychology，2004，24（3）：359-371．

[68] RICHARD K，THOMAS G．Personal well-being in rapid growth and stable communities：multiple indicators and contrasting results[J]．Rural Sociology，1984，49（4）：541-552．

[69] LEWICKA M．Ways to make people active：The role of place attachment，cultural capital，and neighborhood ties[J]．Journal of Environmental Psychology，2005，25（4）：381-395．

[70] FRIED M．Continuities and discontinuities of place[J]．Journal of Environmental Psychology，2000，20（3）：193-205．

[71] LEWICKA M．Place attachment：How far have we come in the last 40 years?[J]．Journal of Environmental Psychology，2011，31（3）：207-230．

[72] MESCH G S，MANOR O．Social ties，environmental perception，and local attachment[J]．Environment and Behavior，1998，30（4）：504-519．

[73] BOULIANNE S，BRAILEY M．Attachment to community and civic and political engagement：A case study of students[J]．Canadian Review of Sociology，2014，51（4）：375-388．

[74] RAMKISSOON H，Smith L D，WEILER B．Testing the dimensionality of place attachment and its relationships with place satisfaction and pro-environmental behaviours：A structural equation modelling approach [J]．Tourism Management，2013，36：552-566．

[75] ARNBERGER A，EDER R．The influence of green space on community attachment of urban and suburban residents[J]．Urban Forestry & Urban Greening，2012，11（1）：41-49．

[76] HUR M，NASAR J L，CHUN B．Neighborhood satisfaction，physical and perceived naturalness and openness[J]．Journal of Environmental Psychology，2010，30（1）：52-59．

[77] KIM J，KAPLAN R．Physical and psychological factors in sense of community new urbanist Kentlands and nearby Orchard Village [J]．Environment and Behavior，2004，36（3）：313-340．

[78] WILSON-DOENGES G．An exploration of sense of community and fear of crime in gated communities[J]．Environment and Behavior，2000，32（5）：597-611．

[79] CASAKIN H，HERNÁNDEZ B，RUIZ C．Place attachment and place identity in Israeli cities：The influence of city size[J]．Cities，2014，42（B）：224-230．

[80] GIFFORD R．The consequences of living in high-rise buildings [J]．Architectural Science Review，2007，50（1）：2-17．

[81] GILLIS A R．High-rise housing and psychological strain[J]．Journal of Health and Social Behavior，1977，18（4）：418-431．