热带地理 ›› 2018, Vol. 38 ›› Issue (1): 13-24.doi: 10.13284/j.cnki.rddl.002980
余构雄,戴光全
出版日期:
2018-01-05
发布日期:
2018-01-05
通讯作者:
戴光全(1966―),男,江西赣州人,博士,教授,博士生导师,主要研究方向为节事旅游与旅游地理、会展经济与管理,(E-mail)gqdai@scut.edu.cn
作者简介:
余构雄(1985―),男,广东饶平人,博士研究生,主要研究方向为旅游空间生产、节事旅游与会展管理,(E-mail)81386182@qq.com
基金资助:
国家自然科学基金项目(41571132);国家旅游局万名旅游英才计划(WMYC20151033)
YU Gouxiong,DAI Guangquan
Online:
2018-01-05
Published:
2018-01-05
摘要:
基于期刊视角,采用文献计量法和内容分析法,通过高频关键词构建了由空间生产理论演变、研究主要背景、研究主要视角、空间主要类型等8部分组成的空间生产研究知识体系,籍此探讨了空间生产在中国的研究热点。在此基础上,对中国旅游空间生产研究进行述评,研究发现:旅游空间生产研究文献所在期刊及发文作者均较集中,研究方法以定性为主,主要集中在古镇旅游和社区旅游空间,主要内容包括概念界定、生产主体探究、生产框架建构、生产动力剖析。在此基础上,指出了目前中国旅游空间生产研究存在的不足之处。最后,从理论、实证及方法等方面展望了旅游空间生产研究。
余构雄,戴光全. 期刊视角的中国旅游空间生产研究述评 ——从空间生产研究知识体系谈起[J]. 热带地理, 2018, 38(1): 13-24.
YU Gouxiong,DAI Guangquan. Review of Domestic Tourism Space Production Research Based on the Journal Perspective: Starting with the Space Production Research Knowledge System[J]. TROPICAL GEOGRAPHY, 2018, 38(1): 13-24.
包亚明,2001.后现代性与地理学的政治.上海:上海教育出版社.[BAO Yaming,2001.Post modernity and the politics of Geography.Shanghai:Shanghai Education Press.]包亚明,2003.现代性与空间的生产.上海:上海教育出版社.[BAO Yaming,2003.Modernity and space production.Shanghai:Shanghai Education Press.] BENCKENDORFF P,ZEHRER A,2013.A network analysis of tourism research.Annals of Tourism Research,(43):121-149.BRADFORD S C,1985.Sources of Information on Specific Subjects.Journal of Information Science,(10):176–180.蔡运龙,叶超,马润潮,夏铸九,周尚意,陈忠,于海,石计生,李志刚,胡大平,何深静,杨宇振,段进军,吴启焰,苏晓波,董慧,陈明星,郭文,刘天宝,王丰龙,任政,王晓阳,2016.马克思主义地理学及其中国化:“跨国、跨界、跨代”知识行动.地理研究,35(7):1205-1229.[CAI Yunlong,YE Chao,MA Laurence,HSIA Chu-joe,ZHOU Shangyi,CHEN Zhong,YU Hai,SHI Jisheng,LI Zhigang,HU Daping,HE Shenjing,YANG Yuzhen,DUAN Jinjun,WU Qiyan,SU Xiaobo,DONG Hui,CHEN Mingxing,GUO Wen,LIU Tianbao,WANG Fenglong,REN Zheng,WANG Xiaoyang,2016.Knowledge as action:Marxist geography and its development in China.Geographical Research,35(7):1205-1229.] CHEN C M,2006.CiteSpace II:Detecting and Visualizing Emerging Trends and Transient Patterns in Scientific Literature.Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology,57(3):359-377.陈金美,1997.论主体性与客体性、主体间性的关系.求索,(5):85-88.[CHEN Jingmei,1997.On the relationship between subjectivity,objectivity and Intersubjectivity.Seeker,(5):85-88.] 陈忠,2010.空间批判与发展伦理——空间与伦理的双向建构及“空间乌托邦”的历史超越.学术月刊,42(1):17-23.[CHEN Zhong,2010.Space criticism and development ethic:The inter-built of space ethic and the historically transcendent of the spatial-utopia.Academic Monthly,42(1):17-23.] FOUCAULT M,1980.‘Questions and Geography’[M]//GORDON C.Power/Knowledge:Selected Interviews and Other Writings 1972-1977.New York:Pantheon Books,63-77.高峰,2010.城市空间生产的运作逻辑——基于新马克思主义空间理论的分析.学习与探索,(1):9-14.[GAO Feng.Operational logic of urban space production.Study & Exploration,(1):9-14.] 桂榕,吕宛青,2013a.符号表征与主客同位景观:民族文化旅游空间的一种后现代性——以“彝人古镇”为例.旅游科学,27(3):37-49.[GUI Rong,LV Wanqing,2013a.Symbol representation And subject-object appositive sight:A case study on postmodernism of ethnic cultural tourism spatial production in Yi People’Ancient Town.Tourism Science,27(3):37-49.] 桂榕,吕宛青,2013b.民族文化旅游空间生产刍论.人文地理,28(3):154-160.[GUI Rong,LV Wanqing,2013b.Brief discussion on spatial production of ethnic cultural tourism.Human Geography,28(3):154-160.] 郭文,王丽,黄震方,2012.旅游空间生产及社区居民体验研究——江南水乡周庄古镇案例.旅游学刊,27(4):28-38.[GUO Wen,WANG Li,HUANG Zhenfang,2012.Study on the production of tourism space and residents’ experience-A case study of Zhouzhuang ancient water town in the south of Yangtze River.Tourism Tribune,27(4):28-38.] 郭文,黄震方,2013.基于场域理论的文化遗产旅游地多维空间生产研究——以江南水乡周庄古镇为例.人文地理,28(2):117-124.[GUO Wen,HUANG Zhenfang,2013.A field theory to the production of multi-dimensional space of cultural heritage tourism destination.Human Geography,28(2):117-124.] 郭文,2015a.旅游空间生产:理论探索与古镇实践.北京:科学出版社.[GUO Wen,2015.Tourism space production.Beijing:Science Press.] 郭文,黄震方,王丽,2015b.文化旅游地空间生产背景下居民社会空间感知模型与实证研究——基于对周庄古镇的调查.地理研究,34 (4):762-774.[GUO Wen,HUANG Zhenfang,WANG Li,2015.A structural equation model for the empirical study of resident perception of social space in the context of space production at cultural tourist destination:Based on a survey of Ancient Town of Zhouzhuan.Geographical Research,34(4):762-774.] 郭凌,王志章,2014a.乡村旅游开发与文化空间生产——基于对三圣乡红砂村的个案研究.社会科学家,(4):83-86.[GUO Lin,WANG ZhiZhang,2014.Rural tourism development and cultural space production.Social Scientist,(4):83-86.] 郭凌,阳宁东,王志章,2014b.民族旅游开发与民族文化的空间生产研究——基于对四川省凉山彝族自治州盐源县泸沽湖的个案研究.西南民族大学学报(人文社科版),(2):144-149.[GUO Lin,YANG Lingdong,WANG ZhiZhang,2014.Research on national tourism development and space production of national culture.Journal of Southwest University for Nationalities,(2):144-149.] 郭凌,王志章,陈丹丹,2016.旅游影响下城市历史街区的空间再生产研究——基于列斐伏尔空间生产理论视角.四川师范大学学报(社会科学版),43(4):53-60.[GUO Lin,WANG ZhiZhang,CHEN Dandan,2016.Space reproduction of historical street under the influence of tourism:From the perspective of Henri Lefebvres space production theory.Journal of Sichuan Normal University(Social Sciences Edition),43(4):53-60.] HALL C M,2005.Systems of surveillance and control:Commentary on ‘an analysis of institutional contributors to three major academic tourism journals:1992–2001’.Tourism Management,26(5):653–656.戴维?哈维著,2006.希望的空间.胡大平,译.南京:南京大学出版社.[HARVEY D,2006.Spaces of hope.HU Daping,Trans..Nanjing:Nanjing University Press.] 胡大平,2016.“地方性空间生产知识”的公正之维.探索与争鸣,(8):73-78.[HU Daping,2016.The justice dimension of "local space production knowledge".Exploration and Free Views,(8):73-78.] 胡毅,张京祥,2015.中国城市住区更新的解读与重构.北京:中国建筑工业出版社.[HU Yi,ZHANG Jinxiang,2015.Interpretation and reconstruction of urban residential renewal in China.Beijing:China Architecture and Building Press.] 黄剑锋,陆林,2015a.空间生产视角下的旅游地空间研究范式转型——基于空间涌现性的空间研究新范式.地理科学,35(1):47- 55.[HUANG Jianfeng,LU Lin,2015.The paradigm transformation of space in tourism destination from perspective of production of space:A new paradigm of space based on emergence of space.Scientia Geographica Sinica,35(1):47-55.] 黄剑锋,陆林,2015b.旅游业“新常态”:空间生产与空间重构的新动力.南京社会科学,(6):39-44.[HUANG Jianfeng,LU Lin,2015.Production and reconstruction of space of tourism industry in the new normal of economic development.Nanjing Journal of Social Sciences,(6):39-44.] 黄娅,2010.后现代结构主义空间范式下民族旅游的符号建构.新疆社会科学(汉文版),(1):96-101.[HUANG Ya,2010.Symbol construction of ethnic tourism under the space paradigm of postmodern structuralism.Social Sciences in Xinjiang,(1):96-101.] LEFEBVRE H,1991.The Production of Space.Donald Nicholson-Smith trans..Oxford:Blackwell.李鹏,张小敏,陈慧,2014.行动者网络视域下世界遗产地的空间生产——以广东开平碉楼与村落为例.热带地理,34(4):429-437.[LI Peng,ZHANG Xiaomin,CHEN Hui,2014.Production of world heritage based on actor network theory:A case study of Kaiping Diaolou and village in Guangdong.Tropical Geography,34(4):429-437.] 廖云路,2014.现代性与空间想象——拉萨报纸建构的城市空间研究.国际新闻界,(12):55-67.[LIAO Yunlu,2014.Modernity and space imagination:the construction of city space in Lhasa newspapers.Chinese Journal of Journalism & Communication,(12):55-67.] 廖卫华,2017.消费主义视角下城市遗产旅游景观的空间生产:成都宽窄巷子个案研究.北京:科学出版社.[LIAO Weihua,2017.The spatial production of urban heritage tourism landscape from the perspective of Consumerism:a case study of Chengdu Kuan Alley and Zhai Alley.Beijing:China Architecture and Building Press.] 刘怀玉,2006.现代性的平庸与神奇:列斐伏尔日常生活批判哲学的文本学解读.北京:中央编译出版社.[LIU Huaiyu,2006.The banality and magic of Modernity:a textual interpretation of Lefebvre's critical philosophy of everyday life.Beijing:Central Compilation & Translation Press.] 刘洋,车震宇,2016.基于社区居民行为的旅游空间生产研究综述.价值工程,35(6):16-20.[LIU Yang,CHE Zhenyu,2016.A survey of tourism spatial production based on the behavior of community residents.Value Engineering,35(6):16-20.] 刘俊,黄秀波,2014.空间思想演变视角下的西方滨海旅游研究.人文地理,29(3):22-27.[LIU Jun,HUANG Xiubo,2014.Literature review on western coastal tourism research from perspective of ever-changing thoughts on space.Human Geography,29(3):22-27.] 陆扬,2008.社会空间的生产——析列斐伏尔《空间的生产》.甘肃社会科学,(5):133-136.[LU Yang,2008.Production of social space:Analysis of the “production of space”.Gansu Social Sciences,(5):133-136.] 陆小成,2016a.新型城镇化的空间生产与治理机制——基于空间正义的视角.城市发展研究,23(9):94-100.[LU Xiaocheng,2016a.Spatial production and governance mechanism of new urbanization:Based on the perspective of spatial justice.Urban Development Studies,23(9):94-100.] 陆小成,万千,2016b.新型城镇化的空间生产与网络治理——基于五大发展理念的视角.西南民族大学学报(人文社会科学版),(9):119-126.[LU Xiaocheng,WAN qiang,2016b.Space production and network governance of new urbanization.Journal of Southwest University for Nationalities,(9):119-126.] 弗朗索瓦?利奥塔著.1997,后现代与公正性游戏.谈瀛洲,译.上海:上海人民出版社.[LYOTARD J F,1997.Postmodern and justice games.TAN Yinzhou,Trans..Shanghai:Shanghai People Press.] MACHARZINA K,WOLF J,ROHN A,2004.Quantitative evaluation of German research output in business administration:1992–2001.Management International Review,44(3):335–359.马克思,恩格斯,1995.马克思恩格斯选集(第2卷).中央编译局,译.北京:人民出版社.[MARX K,ENGELS F,1995.Marx Engels Anthology(2nd ed.).Central Compilation Bureau,trans..Beijing:People Press.] 明庆忠,段超,2014.基于空间生产理论的古镇旅游景观空间重构.云南师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版),46(1):42-48.[MING Qingzhong,DUAN Chao,2014.Spatial reconstruction of tourism landscapes of old towns in the theoretical perspective of spatial production.Journal of Yunnan Normal University(Humanities and Social Sciences),46(1):42-48.] 朴松爱,樊友猛,2012.文化空间理论与大遗址旅游资源保护开发——以曲阜片区大遗址为例.旅游学刊,27(4):39-47.[PIAO Songai,FAN Youmeng,2012.Theory of cultural space and preservation and development of great historical site tourism resources.Tourism Tribune,27(4):39-47.] 爱德华?索亚著,2004.后现代地理学.王文斌,译.北京:商务印书馆.[SOJA E W,2004.Postmodern geographies.WANG Wenbin,trans..Beijing:The Commercial Press.] 孙江,2010.工业资本主义时代的空间拜物教批判.学习与探索,(1):21-23.[SHUN Jiang,2010.Fetishism of industrial capitalism in the era of space.Study & Exploration,(1):21-23.] 孙九霞,周一,2014.日常生活视野中的旅游社区空间再生产研究——基于列斐伏尔与德塞图的理论视角.地理学报,69(10):1575-1589.[SUN Jiuxia,ZHOU Yi,2014.Study on the reproduction of space of tourism community from the perspective of everyday life:Based on theories of Lefebvre and De Certeau.Acta Geographica Sinica,69(10):1575-1589.] 孙小逸,2015.空间的生产与城市的权利:理论、应用及其中国意义.公共行政评论,(3):176-206.[SUN Xiaoyi,2015.The Production of space and the right to the City:Theories,applications,and It implications for China.Journal of Public Administration,(3):176- 206.] 唐正东,2015.当代资本主义的全球化:一种批判性的解读.河海大学学报(哲学社会科学版),17(4):1-6.[TANG Zhengdong,2015.Globalization of contemporary capitalism:A critical interpretation.Journal of Hehai University(Philosophy and Social Sciences),17(4):1-6.] 王丰龙,刘云刚,2011.空间的生产研究综述与展望.人文地理,26(2):13-30.[WANG Fenglong,LIU Yungang,2011.A review of researches on the production of space.Human Geography,26(2):13-30.] 王丰龙,刘云刚,2013.空间生产再考:从哈维到福柯.地理科学,33(11):1293-1301.[WANG Fenglong,LIU Yungang,2013.Revisiting production of space:From Harvey to Foucault.Scientia Geographica Sinica,33(11):1293-1301.] 王玉珏,2011.都市化、全球化与空间政治批判.天津社会科学,(1):31-34.[WANG Yuyu,2011.Urbanization,globalization and criticism of space politics.Tianjin Social Sciences,(1):31-34.] 王志刚,2012.论社会主义空间正义的基本架构——基于主体性视角.江西社会科学,(5):36-40.[WANG Zhigang,2012.On the basic framework of socialist Spatial Justice.Jiangxi Social Sciences,(5):36-40.] 韦俊峰,吴忠军,2015.“隐性介体”视野下的旅游地空间生产与形象建构话语——以龙胜金坑大寨红瑶梯田为例.人文地理,30(6):153-159.[WEI Junfeng,WU Zhongjun,2015.The tourism descourse in space production and image formation under the perspective of "implicit media":A case study of Dazhai Terraced Fields in Longsheng.Human Geography,30(6):153-159.] WEINER G,2001.The academic journal:Has it a future? Education Policy Analysis Archives,9(9):1-19.XIAO H G,SMITH S L J,2006.The making of tourism research:Insights from a social sciences Journal.Annals of Tourism Research,33(2):490–507.杨新军,马晓龙,2004.区域旅游:空间结构及其研究进展.人文地理,19(1):76-81.[YANG Xinjun,MA Xiaolong,2004.Spatial structure and its progress on regional tourism. Human Geography,19(1):76-81.] 杨芬,丁杨,2016.亨利?列斐伏尔的空间生产思想探究.西南民族大学学报(人文社会科学版),(10):183-187.[YANG Fen,DING Tang,2016.Henri Lefebvre's space production thought. Journal of Southwest University for Nationalities,(10):183-187.] 殷洁,罗小龙,2012.资本、权力与空间:“空间的生产”解析.人文地理,27(2):12-16.[YIN Jie,LUO Xiaolong,2012.Capital,power and space:Decoding production of space.Human Geography,27(2):12-16.] 张敏,张捷,姚磊,2013.南京大学文化地理学研究进展.地理科学,33(1):23-28.[ZHANG Min,ZHANG Jie,YAO Lei,2013.Progress of Nanjing university’s cultural geography.Scientia Geographica Sinica,33(1):23-28.] 张羽佳,2016.权力、空间知识型与乌托邦.探索与争鸣,(8):84- 88.[ZHANG Yujia,2016.Power,space knowledge and Utopia.Exploration and Free Views,(8):84-88.] 庄友刚,2012.空间生产与当代马克思主义哲学范式转型.学习论坛,28(8):62-66.[ZHUANG Yougang,2012.Space production and the transformation of contemporary Marxist philosophy.Tribune of Study,28(8):62-66.] 庄友刚,仇善章,2013.资本空间化与空间资本化:关于空间生产的现代性和后现代性话语.山东社会科学,(2):33-37.[ZHUANG Yougang,CHOU Shanzhang,2013.Capital spatialization and spatial capitalization:on the modernity and post modernity discourse of space production.Shandong Social Science,(2):33-37.] 宗晓莲,2005.旅游地空间商品化的形式与影响研究——以云南省丽江古城为例.旅游学刊,20(4):30-36.[ZONG Xiaolian,2005.A study on the form and impact of the destinations spatial commoditization:With Lijiang ancient town as a case study.Tourism Tribune,20(4):30-36.] |
[1] | 方远平,唐艳春,赖慧珍. 从公共纪念空间到公共休闲空间:广州起义烈士陵园的空间生产[J]. 热带地理, 2018, 38(5): 617-628. |
[2] | 陈品宇. 资本、权力与空间:不平衡地理研究进展[J]. 热带地理, 2017, 37(1): 120-129. |
[3] | 李倩菁,蔡晓梅. 广州沙面空间的生产与重构[J]. 热带地理, 2015, 35(6): 814-821. |
[4] | 李 鹏,张小敏,陈 慧. 行动者网络视域下世界遗产地的空间生产——以广东开平碉楼与村落为例[J]. 热带地理, 2014, 34(4): 429-437. |
[5] | 黄振庆, 汪宇明. 广西旅游空间结构及其演变研究[J]. 热带地理, 2007, 27(6): 558-563. |
|