热带地理 ›› 2018, Vol. 38 ›› Issue (5): 617-628.doi: 10.13284/j.cnki.rddl.003076
方远平,唐艳春,赖慧珍
出版日期:
2018-09-05
发布日期:
2018-09-05
作者简介:
方远平(1974―),男,湖南桂东人,教授,博士,主要研究方向为旅游休闲与区域发展、服务业创新地理,(E-mail)fyp21cn@163.com。
基金资助:
国家自然科学基金项目(41471106)
FANG Yuanping,TANG Yanchun,LAI Huizhen
Online:
2018-09-05
Published:
2018-09-05
摘要:
转型期城市公共纪念空间从神圣空间向居民休闲空间的转变成为学界和社会的关注热点。以广州起义烈士陵园为例,运用空间生产理论以及观察法、访谈法等质性研究方法,探讨广州起义烈士陵园在城市转型中从神圣纪念空间向市民休闲空间的转变过程、空间主体所起的作用及其内在机制。研究发现:1)广州起义烈士陵园在发展过程中经历了2次空间转换,1954―1978年烈士墓园的空间生产阶段以及1978年到现在公共纪念与休闲空间生产的阶段。2)政府自上而下的主导作用和居民自下而上的休闲需求是推动烈士陵园空间生产的主要动力。3)政府和居民的共同作用,塑造了烈士陵园多样化空间局面。从政府角度来看,不论是空间规划还是符号化空间的建构都是为了更好地强化其神圣空间特质,公共休闲只是一种衍生功能。从居民角度看,休闲需求在居民生活中占据更为重要的位置,由此形成了混合公共空间。
方远平,唐艳春,赖慧珍. 从公共纪念空间到公共休闲空间:广州起义烈士陵园的空间生产[J]. 热带地理, 2018, 38(5): 617-628.
FANG Yuanping,TANG Yanchun,LAI Huizhen. From Public Memorial Space to Public Leisure Space:Production of Space of the Guangzhou Insurrectional Martyr Cemetery Park[J]. TROPICAL GEOGRAPHY, 2018, 38(5): 617-628.
ALLEN J and PRVKE M.1994.The Production of Service Space.Environment and Planning D:Society and Space,12(4):453-475.爱德华.2005.第三空间.陆扬,刘佳林.译.上海:上海教育出版社.[EDWARD W.2005.The third space.LU Yang and LIU Jialin. trans..Shanghai:Shanghai Education Press.]BORDEN I.2001.Skateboarding,Space and the City:Architecture and the Body.Berg:Oxford,10(1):156-170.包亚明.2003.现代性与空间的生产.上海:上海教育出版社.[BAO Yaming.2003.Modernity and production of space.Shanghai:Shanghai Education Press.]CHARLES W J.2005.Landscape,Memory,History:Gloomy Memories and the 19th-century Scottish Highlands.Scottish Geographical Journal,121(1):29-44.COOKE S.2000.Negotiating memory and identity:the Hyde Park Holocaust Memorial,London.Journal of Historical Geography,26(3):449-465.陈蕴茜.2012.纪念空间与社会记忆.学术月刊,(7):134-137.[CHEN Yunqian.2012.Memory,History and Space.Academic Monthly,(7):134-137.]陈竹,叶珉.2009.什么是真正的公共空间?——西方城市公共空间理论与空间公共性的判定.国际城市规划,24(3):44-49,53.[CHEN Zhu and YE Min.2009.What is Authentic Urban Public Space?-A Review of Western Public Space Theories and A Evaluation of the “Publicness” of Public Space.Urban Planning International,24(3):44-49,53.]DEGEN M.2008.Sensing cities:Regenerating public life in Barcelona and Manchester.London:Routledge.ELDEN S.2004.Understanding Henri Lefebvre:Theory and the possible. London:Continuum.方远平,毕斗斗,甘巧林.2012.转型期居民对城市公园免费开放的感知分析——以广州市为例.旅游学刊,27(8):78-87.[FANG Yuanping,BI Doudou and GAN Qiaolin.2012.Analysis on the Urban Residents’ Perception of the Park Free Opening-up Policy in the Context of Socioeconomic Transformation:A Case of Guangzhou. Tourism Tribune,27(8):78-87.] GOUGH P.2000.From heroes’ groves to parks of peace:Landscapes of remembrance,protest and peace.Landscape Research,25(2):213-228.高萍.2011.社会记忆理论研究综述.西北民族大学学报(哲学社会科学版),(3):112-120.[GAO Ping.2011.Summary of Social Memory Theory Studies.Journal Northwest University for Nationalities(Philosophy and Social Science),(3):112-120.]郭文,黄震方.2013.基于场域理论的文化遗产旅游地多维空间生产研究——以江南水乡周庄古镇为例.人文地理,28(2):117-124.[GUO Wen and HUANG Zhenfang.2013.A field theory to the production of multi-dimensional space of cultural heritage tourism destination-A case study of Zhouzhuang ancient town.Human Geography,28(2):117-124.]郭晓勇.2006.城市公共空间刍议[D].成都:四川大学.[GUO Xiaoyong. 2006.Research on Urban Public Leisure Space[D].Chengdu:Si Chuan University.]广州市人民政府.2015.广州市政公园免费开放工作方案.广州:广州市人民政府.[Guangzhou Municipal People’s government.2015.Free and open work plan for Guangzhou Municipal Park. Guangzhou: Guangzhou People’s government.]HARNIK P.2000.Inside City Parks.Washington D C:Urban Land Institute Press.HARVEY D.1989.the Condition of Postmodernity:An Enquiry into the Origins of Cultural Change.Journal of Architecture Education,(10):915-916.HARVEY D.2012.Rebel Cities:From the Right to the City to the Urban Revolution.New York:Verso Books.黄东兰.2005.身体·心性·权力.杭州:浙江人民出版社.[HUANG Donglan. 2005.The body-mind-power.Hangzhou:Zhejiang people’s press.]JACKSON J B.1984.The American public space.American Journal of Political Science,28(4):52-65.姜文锦,陈可石,马学广.2011.我国旧城改造的空间生产研究——以上海新天地为例.城市发展研究,18(10):84-89,96.[JIANG Wenjin,CHEN Keshi and MA Xueguang.2011.Study on the Spatial Production of Urban Renewal in China:A Case of Shanghai Xintiandi Square.Urban Studies,18(10):84-89,96.]蒋志杰,吴国清,白光润.2003.城市意象空间分析在旅游地理研究中的应用——以江南水乡古镇为例.中山大学学报(自然科学版),42(2):248-253.[JIANG Zhijie,WU Guoqing and BAI Guangrun. 2003.A Spatial Analysis of the Image of Tourism Destination-A Case Study on Ancient Water Towns in Southern Yangtze River.Acta Scientiarum Natural University Sun-yat-sen,42(2):248-253.]KOWARIK I,BUCHHOLZ S,LIPPE M and SEITZ B.2016.Biodiversity functions of urban cemeteries:Evidence from one of the largest Jewish cemeteries in Europe.Urban Forestry & Urban Greening,(19):68-78.凯文·林奇.2001.城市意象.北京:华夏出版社.[KEVIN Lynch.2001.The Image of City.Beijing:Huaxia Publishing House.]LEFEBVRE H.1991.The production of space.Oxford:Blackwell. LOWENTHAL David.1975.Past Time,Present Place:Landscape and Memory.Geographical Review,65(1):1-36.LEARY Michael Edema.2013.A Lefebvrian analysis of the production of glorious,gruesome public space in Manchester.Progress in Planning,(85):1-52.兰洁.2010.空间生产:上海世博会对文化创意产业发展的启示.探索与争鸣,(5):64-66.[LAN Jie.2010.The production of space:the Enlightenment of Shanghai World Expo on the Development of Cultural and Creative Industry.Exploration and Free Views,(5):64-66.]李凡,朱竑,黄维.2010.从地理学视角看城市历史文化景观集体记忆的研究,人文地理,25(4):60-66.[LI Fan,ZHU Hong and HUANG Wei.2010.A Geographical Study on the Collective Memory of Urban Historical Cultural Landscape.Human Geography,25(4):60-66.] 刘平.2011.广州烈士陵园的发展变迁[D].广州:华南理工大学.[LIU Ping.2011.Guangzhou Martyrs Cemetery’s Development[D]. Guangzhou:South China University of Technology.]吕小辉.2011.“生活景观”视域下的城市公共空间研究[D].西安:西安建筑科技大学.[LV Xiaohui.2011.Research on urban public space from the perspective of “life landscape”[D].Xi’an:Xi’an University of Architecture and Technology.]MCINROY N.2000.Urban Regeneration and Public Space:The Story of An Urban Park.Space & Policy,4(1):23-40.马超,李璐,付敬.2015.都市文化景观的空间生产与消费.新闻研究导刊,6(6):131-133.[MA Chao,LI Lu and FU Jing.2015.The Production and Consumption of Urban Cultural Landscape space.Journal of News Research,6(6):131-133.]莫里斯·哈布瓦赫.2006.论集体记忆.毕然,郭金华.译.台北:巨流图书公司,75,230-231.[MAURICE H.2006. On Collective Memory.BI Ran and GUO Jinhua.trans..Taibei:Ju Liu Books CO.,75,230-231.]PATRICIA M.2010.From Liberating Production to Unleashing Consumption: Mapping Landscapes of Power in Beijing.Political Geography,29(6):302-310.彭兆荣.2002.人类学仪式研究评述.民族研究,(2):109-110.[PENG Zhaorong.2002.Review of the research on anthropology ritual.Ethno- National Studies,(2):109-110.]SIMON B,ALICIA M and PENNY T.2007.Mapping research priorities for green and public urban space in the UK.Urban Forestry & Urban Greening,6(2):103-115.SOJA.1989.Postmodern Geographies:The Reassertion of Space in Critical Social Theory.London:Verso.STEWART L.1995.Bodies,visions,and spatial politics:a review essay on Henri Lefebvre’s The Production of Space.Environment & Planning D Society & Space,13(5):609-618.STANEK L.2011.Henri Lefebvre on Space:Architecture,Urban Research,and the Production of Theory.Minneapolis:University of Minnesota Press.STEVEN Hoelscher and DEREK H Alderman.2004.Memory and place:Geographies of A Critical Relationship.Social & Cultural Geography,5(3):347-355.STEVENS Franck K Q.2006.Loose space:Possibility and diversity in urban life.London:Routledge.孙九霞,苏静.2014.旅游影响下传统社区空间变迁的理论探讨——基于空间生产理论的反思.旅游学刊,29(5):78-86.[SUN Jiuxia and SU Jing.2014.Traditional Community Space Change under the Influence of Tourism:A Reflective Study Based on Space Production Theory.Tourism Tribune,29(5):78-86.]孙萌.2009.后工业时代城市空间的生产:西方后现代马克思主义空间分析方法解读中国城市艺术区发展和规划.国际城市规划,24(6):60-65.[SUN Meng.2009.The production of urban space in Post- industrial age:A Marxist spatial interpretation of urban art district development and planning in Chinese Cities.Urban Planning International,24(6):60-65.]TILL Karen.1999.Staging the Past:Landscape Designs,Cultural Identity and Erinnerungspolitik at Berlin’s Neue Wache.Ecumene,6(3):251-283.TIM B.2013.The making of urban ‘healtheries’:the transformation of cemeteries and burial grounds in late-Victorian East London.Journal of Historical Geography,42(100):12-23.汤茂林.2000.文化景观的内涵及其研究进展.地理科学进展,(1):70-79.[TANG Maolin.2000.The Contents and Research Progress of Cultural landscape.Progress in Geography,(1):70-79.]WEGNER P E.2002.Spatial Criticism:Critical Geography,Space,Place and textuality.In:WOLFREYS Julian.Introducing Criticism at the 21st Century.Edinburgh:Edinburgh University Press.王灿,赖玉芹.2011.历史景观与公共记忆——以黄州东坡赤壁为例.甘肃理论学刊,(6):96-99.[WANG Can and LAI Yuqin.Historical Attractions and Public Memory-Taking Huanghzou Dongpo Chibi as an Example.Gansu Theory Research,(6):96-99.]王嘉行.2011.异化中的中国城市空间——以列斐伏尔的空间生产理论为视角[D].武汉:武汉理工大学.[WANG Jiaxing.2011.Alienation in the Urban Space in China-To Lefebvre’s Theory of Perspective Space Production[D].Wuhan:Wuhan University of Technology.]王晓葵.2008.国家权力、丧葬习俗与公共记忆空间——以唐山大地震殉难者的埋葬与祭祀为例.民俗研究,(2):5-25.[WANG Xiaokui. 2008.The State Power,Funeral Custom and Public Memory Space:A Case study of the Burial and Sacrifice of the Great Earthquake Victims of Tangshan.Floklore Studies,(2):5-25.]王志弘.2009.多重的辩证——列斐伏尔空间生产概念三元组演绎与引申.地理学报(台湾),(55):1-24.[WANG Zhihong.2009.The Multiple Dialectical-Deduction and Extension of Lefever’ Space Production Triple Concepts.Acta Geographica Sinica(Taiwan),(55):1-24.]杨贵庆.2013.城市公共空间的社会属性与规划思考.上海城市规划,(6):28-35.[YANG Guiqing.2013.Social Attribute of Urban Public Space and Its Planning Considerations.Shanghai Urban Planning Review,(6):28-35.]叶超.2011.马克思主义与城市问题结合研究的典范——大卫·哈维的《资本的城市化》述评.国际城市规划,26(4):98-101.[YE Chao.2011.Review on “Urbanization of Capital” Written by David Harvey.Urban Planning International,26(4):98-101.]叶超,蔡运龙.2012.地理学方法论演变与价值判断.地理研究,29(5):947-958.[YE Chao and CAI Yunlong.2012.The Geographical Methodology Between Subjectivity and Objectivity.Geographical Research,29(5):947-958.]张四维.2008.城市纪念性空间的功能整合与空间套叠——雨花台烈士陵园江苏公安英烈纪念墙及纪念广场剖析.现代城市研究,(9):71-75.[ZHANG Siwei.2008.The Function Integration and the Space Overlap of the Urban Monumental Space.Modern Urban Research,(9):71-75.]张天洁,李泽,孙媛.2011.纪念语境、共和话语与公共记忆——武昌首义公园刍议.新建筑,(5):7-11.[ZHANG Tianjie,LI Ze and SUN Yuan.2011.Commemorative Context,Republican Discourse and Public Memory:An Investigation on the Creation of Wuchang Shouyi Park.New Architecture,(5):7-11.]张露,杜娟.2016.广州公园划定噪声“限值”.广州日报,2016-10-21(A6).[ZHANG Lu and DU Juan.Guangzhou Park delineated Noise “limit value”.Guangzhou Daily,2016-10-21(A6).]张子凯.2007.列斐伏尔《空间的生产》述评.江苏大学学报(社会科学版),9(5):10-14.[ZHANG Zikai.2007.Review of Henri Lefebvre’s the Production of Space.Journal of Jiangsu University(Social Science Edition),9(5):10-14.]郑杭生.2003.社会转型论及其在中国的表现——中国特色社会学理论探索的梳理和回顾之二.广西民族学院学报(哲学社会科学版),25(5):62-73.[ZHENG Hangsheng.2003.On the theory of social type transformation and its realization in China-A study and review of sociological theory with Chinese Characteristics.Journal of Guangxi University for Nationalities(Philosophy and Social Science Edition),25(5):62-73.]郑震.2010.空间:一个社会学的概念.社会学研究,(5):167-192. [ZHENG Zhen.2010.Space:A Concept of Sociology.Sociological Studies,(5):167-192.]朱蓉.2006.集体记忆的场所——从心理学、社会学角度探讨城市公共空间营造的基本原则.南京艺术学院学报(美术与设计版),(4):82-85.[ZHU Rong.2006.A Place of collective memory:exploring principles of urban public space from perspective of psychology and sociology.Journal of Nanjing Art College(Art and Design),(4):82-85.]邹丹丹.2012.现代性怀旧和记忆的空间生产——以上海新天地为例.现代城市研究,(2):24-29.[ZOU Dandan.2012.Space Production of Modern Nostalgia and Memory-With Xintiandi in Shanghai as an Example.Modern Urban Research,(2):24-29.] |
[1] | 余构雄,戴光全. 期刊视角的中国旅游空间生产研究述评 ——从空间生产研究知识体系谈起[J]. 热带地理, 2018, 38(1): 13-24. |
[2] | 陈品宇. 资本、权力与空间:不平衡地理研究进展[J]. 热带地理, 2017, 37(1): 120-129. |
[3] | 李倩菁,蔡晓梅. 广州沙面空间的生产与重构[J]. 热带地理, 2015, 35(6): 814-821. |
[4] | 李 鹏,张小敏,陈 慧. 行动者网络视域下世界遗产地的空间生产——以广东开平碉楼与村落为例[J]. 热带地理, 2014, 34(4): 429-437. |
|