海南岛人工与天然红树林重金属污染、
富集与转运能力比较

doi:10.13284/j.cnki.rddl.003083

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 以海南岛东寨港、清澜港与三亚河3个红树林自然保护区为研究区，综合比较了人工与天然红树林6种重金属（Cd、As、Cu、Cr、Pb和Zn）的地累积指数、潜在生态危害指数、生物富集系数与转运系数的差异。结果表明：1）研究区红树林沉积物中，Cd呈现强度—极强度污染，As为中度—强度污染，Cr属中度污染，Zn为轻度污染，Cu与Pb表现为无至轻度污染；从区域空间看，Cd污染表现为：东寨港（强度—极强度）＞清澜港（强度）＞三亚河（无污染），As污染表现为：清澜港（中度—强度）＞东寨港（中度—强度）＞三亚河（中度）；Cr污染表现为：东寨港（中度）＞清澜港（轻度）＞三亚河（无污染）。2）东寨港人工无瓣海桑、天然白骨壤、人工与天然桐花树、人工与天然海莲，清澜港的天然桐花树Cd的值（单一重金属潜在生态危害系数）属较强潜在生态风险，东寨港与清澜港的天然正红树林、清澜港的人工无瓣海桑、天然杯萼海桑和天然海莲Cd的值属中等潜在生态风险，其余红树植物6种参评元素的值与RI值（多重金属总潜在生态风险指数）均属轻微级；综合而言，Cd、As、Pb和Cr似乎更易引发海莲、桐花树与无瓣海桑的健康风险问题。3）人工与天然红树植物各器官对6种参评重金属的富集系数大体表现为：根＞枝＞叶；红树植物植株平均富集系数总趋势为：三亚河人工红树林＞三亚河天然红树林＞清澜港天然红树林＞东寨港天然红树林＞清澜港人工红树林＞东寨港人工红树林。4）人工与天然红树林的重金属转运系数都显示出：叶—枝＞枝—根＞叶—根；植株平均转运系数总趋势：三亚河人工红树林＞三亚河天然红树林＞东寨港天然红树林＞东寨港人工红树林＞清澜港天然红树林＞清澜港人工红树林。5）红树植物与林下沉积物重金属含量之间具有强的正相关关系，这表明控制沉积物重金属含量和减少外源重金属污染是维护红树林湿地生态系统健康重要而有效的环节。6）同一地区同种红树植物在吸附重金属能力上人工林略强于天然林，这可能与人工红树林的营林环境、人为扰动存在一定关联。

关键词: 天然红树林, 人工红树林, 重金属, 富集, 转运, 海南岛

Abstract: The Muller indices, potential ecological hazard coefficients, biological accumulating coefficients (BAC) and the biological transfer coefficients (BTC) of 6 heavy metals (Cd, As, Cu, Cr, Pb and Zn) are compared between artificial and natural mangroves in mangrove nature reserves of Dongzhaigang, Qinglangang, and Sanya River, in Hainan Island. The results show that: 1) In the mangrove sediments of the study area, Cd has the higher intensity - extreme intensity pollution, As is moderate-intensity pollution, Cr is basically moderate pollution, Zn is mild pollution, Cu and Pb show no or slight pollution. In spatial distribution, the pollution of Cd is shown as: Dongzhaigang (intensity-extreme intensity) > Qinglangang (intensity) > Sanya River (pollution-free), the pollution of As is as follows: Qinglangang (moderate - intensity) > Dongzhaigang (moderate - intensity) > Sanya River (moderate); and the pollution of Cr is Dongzhaigang (moderate) > Qinglangang (mild) > Sanya River (no pollution). 2) The values (the potential ecological hazard coefficients of a single heavy metal) of Cd in artificial Sonneratiaapetala, natural Avicennia marina, artificial and natural Aegicerascorniculatum, artificial and natural Bruguierasexangula of Dongzhaigang are strong potential ecological risk, while the values of Cd in natural Rhizophoraapiculata Blume of Dongzhaigang and Qinglangang，artificial Sonneratiaapetala and natural Sonneratia alba of Qinglangang belong to medium potential ecological risk. The values of residual mangrove plants and RI values (the total potential ecological risk index of heavy metals) of all mangrove plants are all of slight grade. Generally speaking, it seems that Cd, As, Pb and Cr are more likely to cause health risks of Bruguierasexangula, Sonneratiaapetala and Aegicerascorniculatum. 3) The BAC of 6 heavy metals in artificial and natural mangrove plants show: root > branch > leaf, and the general trend of BAC is the artificial mangrove of Sanya River > the natural mangrove of Sanya River > the natural mangrove of Qinglangang > the natural mangrove of Dongzhaigang > the artificial mangrove of Qinglangang > the artificial mangrove of Dongzhaigang. 4) The BTC of heavy metals in artificial and natural mangrove are leaf-branch > branch-root > leaf-root, and the general trend of BTC is the artificial mangrove of Sanya River > the natural mangrove of Sanya River > the natural mangrove of Dongzhaigang > the artificial mangrove of Dongzhaigang > the natural mangrove of Qinglangang > the artificial mangrove of Qinglangang. 5) There is a significant positive correlation in heavy metal contents between mangrove plants and the sediments under the plants. This indicates that controlling the heavy metal content and exogenous pollution of the sediments is an important and effective way to maintain the health of the mangrove wetland ecosystem. 6) The ability of mangrove plants to accumulate heavy metals in the same area is slightly stronger than that in natural forests. That may be related to the afforestation environment and human disturbance of artificial mangrove forestation.

Key words: natural mangrove, artificial mangrove, heavy metals, accumulation and transfer, Hainan Island

邱彭华，王德智，谢跟踪，徐颂军，曹瑞，王军广. 海南岛人工与天然红树林重金属污染、富集与转运能力比较[J]. 热带地理, 2018, 38(6): 836-847.

QIU Penghua, WANG Dezhi, XIE Genzong, XU Songjun, CAO Rui1 WANG Junguang. Comparison of Heavy-metal Pollutions, Accumulation and Transfer Capacity between Artificial and Natural Mangroves in the Hainan Island[J]. TROPICAL GEOGRAPHY, 2018, 38(6): 836-847.

参考文献

Antizar-Ladislao B, Mondal P, Mitra S and Sarkar S K. 2015. Assessment of trace metal contamination level and toxicity in sediments from coastal regions of West Bengal, eastern part of India. Marine Pollution Bulletin, 101: 886–894.

丁振华，刘金铃，李柳强，林慧娜，吴浩，虎贞贞. 2009. 中国主要红树林湿地沉积物中汞的分布特征. 环境科学，30（8）：2210-2215. [ Ding Zhenhua, Liu Jinling, Li Liuqiang, Lin Huina, Wu Hao and Hu Zhenzhen. 2009. Distribution of mercury in surficial sediments from main mangrove wetlands of China. Environmental Science, 30(8): 2210-2215. ]

Fernández-Cadena J C, Andrade S, Silva-Coello C L and De La Iglesia R. 2014. Heavy metal concentration in mangrove surface sediments from the north-west coast of South America. Marine Pollution Bulletin, 82: 221–226.

郭菊兰，朱耀军，武高洁，郭志华. 2013. 海南清澜港红树林湿地沉积物环境质量评价. 林业资源管理，（6）：121-126. [Guo Julan, Zhu Yaojun, Wu Gaojie and Guo Zhihua. Assessment on sediment environmental quality of mangrove forest in Qinglan Harbour, Hainan Province. Forest Resources Management, (6): 121-126. ]

Muller G. 1979. Schwermetalle in den sedimenten des Rheins- Veranderungen seit 1971. Umschau Verlag, 79 (24): 778–783.

Hakanson L A. 1980. Ecological risk index for aquatic pollution control, a sediment approach. Water Res., 14: 977-985.

黄星. 2017. 红树林土壤有机碳、重金属特征对红树林景观格局变化的响应. 上海：华东师范大学. [Huang Xing. 2017. Responses of mangrove soil organic carbon and heavy metals to the change of mangrove landscape-A case study in Dongzhai Harbor, Hainan Island and Qinzhou Bay, Guangxi. Shanghai: East China Normal University. ]

Islam M A, Al-Mamun A, Hossain F, Quraishi S B, Naher K, Khan R, Das S, Tamim U, Hossain S M and Nahid F. 2017. Contamination and ecological risk assessment of trace elements in sediments of the rivers of Sundarban mangrove forest, Bangladesh. Marine Pollution Bulletin, 124: 356–366.

季一诺，赵志忠，吴丹，伏箫诺．2016．海南东寨港红树林沉积物中重金属的分布及其生物有效性. 应用生态学报，27（2）：593-600. [Ji Yinuo, Zhao Zhizhong, Wu Dan and Fu Xiaonuo. 2016. Distribution and bioavailability of seven heavy metals in mangrove wetland sediments in Dongzhai Harbor, Hainan Island, China. Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology, 27(2): 593-600. ]

李翠. 2012. 海南红树林湿地积累重金属的功能研究. 海口：海南师范大学. [Li Cui. 2012. Study of mangrove wetlands function in accumulating heavy metals in Hainan Islands. Haikou: Hainan Normal University. ]

刘金铃. 2008. 中国主要红树林湿地中汞的迁移、转化规律. 厦门：厦门大学. [Liu Jinling. 2008. Transport and transformation of mercury in main mangrove wetlands of China. Xiamen: Xiamen University. ]

Macfarlane G R, Koller C E and Blomberg S P. 2007. Accumulation and partitioning of heavy metals in mangroves: A synthesis of field-based studies. Chemosphere, 69(9): 1454-1464.

Macfarlane G R, Pulkownik A and Burchett M D. 2003. Accumulation and distribution of heavy metals in the grey mangrove, Avicennia marina (Forsk.) Vierh.: biological indication potential. Environmental Pollution, 123(1): 139-151.

Page A L and Bingham F T. 1973. Cadmium residues in the Environment. Reisdue Reviews, 48: 1-43.

Prabhat Ranjan, Ramanathan A L, Alok Kumar, Singhal R K, Dilip Datta and Venkatesh M. 2018. Trace metal distribution, assessment and enrichment in the surface sediments of Sundarban mangrove ecosystem in India and Bangladesh. Marine Pollution Bulletin, 127: 541–547.

Preda M and Cox M E. 2002. Trace metal occurrence and distribution in sediments and mangroves, Pumicestone region, southeast Queensland, Australia. Environment International, 28(5): 433-449.

Qiu Yaowen, Yu Kefu, Zhang Gan and Wang Wenxiong. 2011. Accumulation and partitioning of seven trace metals in mangroves and sediment cores in three estuarine wetlands of Hainan Island, China. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 190: 631-638.

丘耀文，余克服. 2011. 海南红树林湿地沉积物中重金属的累积. 热带海洋学报，30（2）：102-108. [Qiu Yaowen and Yu Kefu. 2011. Accumulation of heavy metals in sediment of mangrove wetland from Hainan Island. Journal of Tropical Oceanography, 30(2): 102-108.]

Sandilyan S and Kathiresan K. 2014. Decline of mangroves: A threat of heavy metal poisoning in Asia. Ocean & Coastal Management, 102: 161-168.

Tam N F Y and Wong W S. 2000. Spatial variation of heavy metals in surface sediments of Hong Kong mangrove swamps. Environmental Pollution, 110(2): 195-205.

Usman A R, Alkredaa R S and Al-Wabel M I. 2013. Heavy metal contamination in sediments and mangroves from the coast of Red Sea: Avicennia marina as potential metal bioaccumulator. Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety, 97(5): 263-270.

王刚，张秋平，管东生. 2016. 红树林植物生物量沿纬度分布特征. 湿地科学，14（2）：259-269. [Wang Gang, Zhang Qiuping and Guan Dongsheng. 2016. Distribution characteristics of biomass of plants in mangrove forest along latitude. Wetland Science, 14(2): 259-269. ]

王鹏，赵志忠，马荣林，李香，王军广．2014．海南岛北部潮间带红树林对重金属的累积特征．生态环境学报，23（5）：842-846. [Wang Peng, Zhao Zhizhong, Ma Ronglin, Li Xiang and Wang Junguang. 2014. Bioaccumulation characteristics of heavy metal in intertidal zone sediments from northern Hainan Island. Ecology and Environmental Sciences, 23(5): 842-846. ]

王仁恩，杨文杰，张钰，黄勃，陈玉军，陈元海. 2012. 不同红树林群落土壤吸附重金属的研究. 安徽农业科学，40（4）：2037-2038，2197. [Wang Renen, Yang Wenjie, Zhang Yu, Huang Bo, Chen Yujun and Chen Yuanhai. 2012. Study on absorbing heavy metal in different mangrove ecosystem. Journal of Anhui Agri. Sci., 40(4): 2037-2038, 2197. ]

王云，魏复盛. 1995. 土壤环境元素化学. 北京：中国环境科学出版社，1-394. [Wang Yun and Wei Fusheng. 1995. Elemental chemistry of soil environment. Beijing: China Environmental Science Press, 1-394. ]

Xu Songjun, Lin Chuxia, Qiu Penghua, Song Yan, Yang Wenhuai, Xu Guanchang, Feng Xiaodan, Yang Qian, Yang Xiu and Niu Anyi. 2015. Tungsten-and cobat-dominated heavy metal contamination of mangrove sediments in Shenzhen, China. Marine Pollution Bulletin, 100(1): 562-566.

谢陈笑，丁振华，高卫强，谢忠，吴彦慜. 2006. 漳江口红树林区沉积物中Cu、Zn、Cr的分布及形态特征. 厦门大学学报（自然科学版），45（增刊）：100-104. [ Xie Chenxiao, Ding Zhenhua, Gao Weiqiang, Xie Zhong and Wu Yanmin. 2006. Distribution and speciation of Cu, Zn and Cr in mangrove sediments from Zhangjiang Estuary. Journal of Xiamen University (Natural Science), 45(Sup.): 100-104. ]

咎启杰，王勇军，王柏荪．2002. 深圳福田红树林无瓣海桑与海桑群落的重金属累积和循环. 环境科学，23（4）：81-88. [Zan Qijie, Wang Yongjun and Wang Bosun. 2002. Accumulation and cycle of heavy metal in Sonneratia apetala and S. caseolaris mangrove community at Futian of Shenzhen, China. Environmental Science, 23(4): 81-88.]

章金鸿，李玫，潘南明. 2000. 深圳福田红树林对重金属Cu、Pb、Zn、Cd的吸收、累积与循环. 云南环境科学，19（增刊）：53-56. [ Zhang Jinhong, Li Mei and Pan Nanming. 2000. Absorption, accumulation and cycle of several heavy metals by mangrove. Yunnan Environmental Science, 19 (Sup.): 53-56. ]

郑文教，林鹏. 1996. 深圳福田白骨壤红树林Cu、Pb、Zn、Cd的累积及分布. 海洋与湖沼，27（4）：386-393. [ Zheng Wenjiao and Lin Peng. Accumulation and Distribution of Cu, Pb, Zn and Cd in Avicennia Marina Mangrove Community of Futian in Shenzhen. Oceanologia ET Limnologia Sinica, 27(4): 386-393. ]

邹烨燔. 2014. 海南岛北部潮间带红树林沉积物-孔隙水-植物系统中重金属元素迁移富集规律研究. 海口：海南师范大学. [Zou Yefan. 2014. Study on the enrichment and migration of heavy metals in mangrove sediments-pore water-Mangrove plant systems in Northern Hainan Island intertidal zone. Haikou: Hainan Normal University. ]

[1]	黄沛桓, 王刚, 黄子茵, 管东生. 华南近岸海域水质评价及其影响因素[J]. 热带地理, 2021, 41(1): 124-135.
[2]	王子爱, 唐少霞, 傅雨萱, 郑苗, 吴丹, 陈珂珂, 戴文博. 高位虾池底质重金属富集特性及污染、生态风险评价[J]. 热带地理, 2021, 41(1): 136-146.
[3]	张丽, 廖静娟, 袁鑫, 穆晓东, 宋茜茜, 毕京鹏. 1987—2017年海南岛海岸线变化特征遥感分析[J]. 热带地理, 2020, 40(4): 659-674.
[4]	罗松英，梁艺琼，陈碧珊，林梦婷，梁家新，邱锦坤. 徐闻南山镇红树林沉积物及红树植物中重金属的累积特征与迁移规律[J]. 热带地理, 2019, 39(3): 347-356.
[5]	赵志忠，李燕，赵泽阳，邢瑶丽，刘玉燕. 海南岛东部地区土地利用方式对土壤有机碳与易氧化有机碳的影响 [J]. 热带地理, 2019, 39(1): 144-152.
[6]	王璐，余克服，王英辉，王少鹏，黄学勇，张瑞杰，王丽伟. 南海中沙群岛、西沙群岛珊瑚岛礁区海水重金属的分布特征 [J]. 热带地理, 2017, 37(5): 718-727.
[7]	许莉佳，余克服，李淑. 海南岛澄黄滨珊瑚共生藻对环境变化的适应性[J]. 热带地理, 2016, 36(6): 915-922.
[8]	李茂芬，李玉萍，罗微，李海亮. 海南岛逐日太阳总辐射长期演变特征与关联因子[J]. 热带地理, 2016, 36(4): 666-672.
[9]	王梦媛，郑卓，黄康有，张怡萌．. 海南岛南部MIS-5海相沉积地层的发现及其意义[J]. 热带地理, 2016, 36(3): 399-405.
[10]	田成静, 欧阳婷萍, 朱照宇, 邱燕, 彭学超, 李明坤. 海南岛周边海域表层沉积物磁化率空间分布特征及其物源指示意义 [J]. 热带地理, 2013, 33(6): 666-673.
[11]	杨龙，温美丽，周霞，李鑫华，付淑清，张虹鸥，方国祥，黄建明. 南坑河污染初步调查及河岸植物的富集能力[J]. 热带地理, 2013, 33(5): 549-554.
[12]	杨龙，温美丽，周霞，李鑫华，付淑清，张虹鸥，方国祥，黄建明. 南坑河污染初步调查及河岸植物的富集能力[J]. 热带地理, 2013, 33(5): 549-554.
[13]	吴清华，闵兴玲，周永章，卢强. 珠三角空间梯度葫芦藓的重金属含量及其环境指示意义 [J]. 热带地理, 2013, 33(2): 224-230.
[14]	吴志祥, 杜莲英, 兰国玉, 谢贵水, 杨川, 周兆德. 海南岛橡胶林辐射通量特征[J]. 热带地理, 2012, 32(6): 575-581.
[15]	邱彭华, 徐颂军, 符英, 谢跟踪. 海南岛海岸带土地利用现状及问题分析[J]. 热带地理, 2012, 32(6): 582-592.