缅北局势及其对中缅经济走廊建设的影响

doi:10.13284/j.cnki.rddl.003199

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

通过系统梳理缅北局势发展历程,剖析冲突各主体的诉求,分析缅北局势对中缅经济走廊建设的具体影响,并从第三方介入构建缅军与少数民族地方武装之间双方认可的《全国全面停火协定》的视角提出应对的机制和措施。结果显示：目前,缅北局势呈现出冲突规模随时间推移持续上升的趋势,冲突从果敢爆发后向南北方向扩散并高度集中于中间区域;受地缘环境复杂和大国利益交汇影响,缅北冲突在短时间内无法消除;缅军与少数民族地方武装之间的冲突在短期内无法消除,冲突各方缺乏平等对话的平台与和谈共识,持续性冲突将是缅北的常态。缅北局势影响了中缅经济走廊建设,致使中缅经济走廊的投资项目无法有效推进,阻滞“人字形”走廊的通畅,并有损中国政府及企业在缅形象。针对缅北局势的影响,中国及其他国际组织等应认真调研和精确把握双方诉求和缅甸的局势,积极协助缅甸冲突双方、为主要政党搭建对话平台、构建平等的协商机制、促进和谈有效推进。经济走廊建设既要注重硬环境的建设,更要加强软环境的投资等,这些将是保证中缅经济走廊建设有效推进的关键。因此,以缅甸为突破口,在中国周边构建“一带一路”建设的样板,探讨落实倡议的有效路径,总结各类经验。

关键词: 缅北局势, 地缘政治, 武装冲突, 中缅经济走廊

Abstract:

If Myanmar is the bridge of “the Belt and Road Initiative” connecting south and southeast Asia in the geographical pattern of Asia, then northern Myanmar is the key to entering the bridge. The present situation in northern Myanmar shows the following characteristics: 1) the scale of the conflict continues to rise over time, with the conflict spreading from Kokang to the north-south direction of Myanmar and being highly concentrated in the central region; 2) the geographical environment of northern Myanmar is complex, and it is a region where interests of great powers converge; 3) the conflict between the Burmese army and the ethnic armed groups cannot be eliminated in the short term, and this persistent conflict will be the norm in northern Myanmar; and 4) the parties to the conflict lack a platform for equal dialog and consensus in peace talks, and are unable to reach a consensus in the short term. This situation in northern Myanmar has affected the construction of the China-Myanmar Economic Corridor, resulting in the inability to effectively push forward its investment projects, blocking the development of the “herringbone” corridor, and damaging the image of the Chinese government and enterprises in Myanmar. In view of the impact of the situation in northern Myanmar, China and other international organizations should seriously research on and accurately grasp the demands of both sides and the situation in Myanmar and actively assist both sides in conflict. Major political parties must set up a dialog platform, establish an equal consultation mechanism, and promote the effective advancement of peace talks. The creation of the economic corridor should focus not only on the construction of a hard environment, but also on the strengthening of investment in a soft environment, which will be the key to ensuring the effective advancement of the China-Myanmar economic corridor construction. Therefore, taking the case of Myanmar as a breakthrough is greatly significant in building a model of “the Belt and Road” construction around China and in exploring effective ways of implementing the initiative and summarizing various experiences.

Key words: The situation in northern Myanmar, geopolitics, armed conflict, China-Myanmar Economic Corridor

中图分类号:

K901.4

李灿松, 胡平平, 杨旺舟. 缅北局势及其对中缅经济走廊建设的影响[J]. 热带地理, 2019, 39(6): 823-832.

Li Chansong, Hu Pingping, Yang Wangzhou. Impact of the Northern Myanmar Situation on the China-Myanmar Economic Corridor Construction[J]. Tropical Geography, 2019, 39(6): 823-832.

图/表 4

参考文献 42

[1]	Bi Shihong . 2017. India Pursues Act East policy via Myanmar. (2017-07-16)[ 2019-10-09]. http://www.globaltimes.cn/content/1056542.shtml .
[2]	Brenner D . 2018. Inside the Karen Insurgency: Explaining Conflict and Conciliation in Myanmar’s Changing Borderlands. Asian Security, 14(2):83-99. doi: 10.1080/14799855.2017.1293657
[3]	Buchanan J . 2016. Militias in Myanmar. Yangon: The Asia Foundation.
[4]	Burma Centrum Nederland. Conflict or Peace? Ethnic Unrest Intensifies in Burma. TNI-BCN Burma Policy Briefing Nr 7, 2011-07-23. doi: 10.1364/AO.58.009305 pmid: 31873610
[5]	Burma Centrum Nederland. Ending Burma’s Conflict Cycle? Prospects for Ethnic Peace. TNI-BCN Burma Policy Briefing Nr 8, 2013-12-14.
[6]	成汉平, 瞿俊峰, 宁威 . 2017. 缅甸“世纪彬龙会议”特点与走向分析. 缅甸研究,( 2):1-12.
	[ Cheng Hanping, Qu Junfeng and Ningwei. 2017. An Analysis of the Characteristics and Trend of the Binlong Conference of Myanmar in the 21st Century. Myanmar Studies, ( 2):1-12. ]
[7]	村主道美, 刘务 . 2014. 缅甸佛教徒与穆斯林冲突对其民主改革的影响. 印度洋经济体研究 (2): 121-138, 160.
	[ Village leader and Liu Wu . 2014. The Impact of Conflict between Buddhists and Muslims in Myanmar on Their Democratic Reform. Indian Ocean Economic Research, (2): 121-138, 160. ]
[8]	戴永红, 秦永红 . 2016. 缅甸“民地武”问题对中国“一带一路”建设的影响及应对. 广西大学学报(哲学社会科学版), 38(4):72-76.
	[ Dai Yonghong and Qin Yonghong . 2016. The influence of Burma’s “Civil Land and Wu” Issue on China’s “One Belt and One Road” Construction and Its Countermeasures. Journal of Guangxi University (Philosophy and Social Sciences), 38(4):72-76. ]
[9]	方铁 . 2009. 云南跨境民族的分布、来源及其特点. 广西民族大学学报(哲学社会科学版), 29(5):9-14, 20.
	[ Fang Tie . 2009. Distribution, Source and Characteristics of Cross-border Ethnic Groups in Yunnan. Journal of Guangxi University for Nationalities (Philosophical and Social Sciences Edition), 29(5):9-14, 20. ]
[10]	封顺, 郑先武 . 2016. 中缅跨境安全复合体及其治理. 国际安全研究, 34(5):122-145, 151-152.
	[ Feng Shun and Zheng Xianwu . 2016. China-Myanmar Cross-border Security Complex and Its Governance. International Security Research, 34(5):122-145, 151-152. ]
[11]	李司坤, 鲁同 . 2016. 缅甸反华媒体大佬遭拘捕多次发布不实报道抹黑中国. 环球时报,2016-11-14.
	[ Global Times. 2016. Myanmar’s Anti-Chinese Media Mogul was Arrested and Repeatedly Published False Reports to Discredit China. Global Times, 2016-11-14. ]
[12]	环球国际. 2019. 中国亚洲事务特使孙国祥周二会见了北方联军三家民武. (2019-08-22)[2019-10-05]. http://www.sthrzs.com/?id=46 .
	[ Globe International. 2019. China’s Special Envoy for Asia, Sun Guoxiang, Met with Three Northern Coalition Militaries. (2019-08-22)[ 2019-10-05]. http://www.sthrzs.com/?Id=46 ]
[13]	宫玉涛 . 2016. 近年来缅甸国内的民族冲突对我国西南边疆地区的影响. 西南民族大学学报(人文社科版), 37(2):37-43.
	[ Gong Yutao . 2016. The Impact of Ethnic Conflicts in Myanmar on the Southwestern Frontier of China in Recent Years. Journal of Southwest University for Nationalities (Humanities and Social Sciences Edition), 37(2):37-43. ]
[14]	郭铁 . 2009. 昂山素季: 将确定中缅经济走廊合作领域. 新京报, 2009-09-26.
	[ Guo Tie . 2009. Aung San Suu Kyi: Will Identify the Area of Sino-Myanmar Economic Corridor Cooperation. Beijing News, 2009-09-26. ]
[15]	龚丽娜, 曼帕凡•考尔, 阿里斯泰尔•库克, 祝湘辉, 王欢欢 . 2011. ERM和RAM模型在缅甸族群冲突中的应用. 南洋资料译丛,( 3):29-38.
	[ Gong Lina, Manpavan Kaul, Alistair Cook, Zhu Xianghui and Wang Huanhuan . 2011. Application of ERM and RAM Model in Ethnic Conflict in Myanmar. Nanyang Data Translation, ( 3):29-38. ]
[16]	贺圣达, 李晨阳 . 2009. 列国志: 缅甸. 2版. 北京: 社会科学文献出版社, 173.
	[ He Shengda and Li Chenyang . 2009. Guide to the World States: Myanmar. 2nd Edition. Beijing: Social Sciences Literature Publishing House, 173. ]
[17]	扈琼瑶 . 2009. 从“果敢88事件”反思中国对缅政策. 东南亚之窗,( 3):37-41.
	[ Hu Qiongyao . 2009. Reflections on China’s Myanmar Policy from the “Kokang 8.8 Incident”. Window to Southeast Asia, ( 3):37-41. ]
[18]	黄春萍 . 2016. 缅甸族群矛盾对中缅油气管道安全的影响. 广州:广东外语外贸大学.
	[ Huang Chunping . 2016. The Impact of Ethnic Conflicts in Myanmar on the Safety of Oil and Gas Pipelines in China and Myanmar. Guangzhou: Guangdong University of Foreign Studies. ]
[19]	Jolliffe K . 2014. Ethnic Conflict and Social Services in Myanmar’s Contested Regions. Yangon: Asia Foundation, 2-5.
[20]	蒋姮 . 2011. 高冲突地区投资风险在认识——中国投资缅甸案例调研. 国际经济合作,( 11):9-12.
	[ Jiang Ruo . 2011. Recognition of Investment Risk in High Conflict Areas: A Case Study of China’s Investment in Myanmar. International Economic Cooperation, ( 11):9-12. ]
[21]	孔志坚, 雷著宁 . 2014. 国际非政府组织在缅甸的发展及其影响. 国际研究参考,( 4):34-38.
	[ Kong Zhijian and Lei Zhuning . 2014. Development and Impact of International NGOs in Myanmar. International Research Reference, ( 4):34-38. ]
[22]	李灿松, 骆华松, 胡志丁, 付磊, 熊理然 . 2015a. 2015年缅北局势的未来走向及中国应对策略, 热带地理, 35(4):569-576,600. doi: 10.13284/j.cnki.rddl.002731
	[ Li Cansong, Luo Huasong, Hu Zhiding, Fu Lei and Xiong Liran . 2015a. Future Trend of the Situation in North Myanmar in 2015 and China’s Response Strategy .Tropical Geography, 35(4):569-576, 600. ] doi: 10.13284/j.cnki.rddl.002731
[23]	李灿松, 葛岳静, 马纳, 胡志丁 . 2015b. 基于行为主体的缅甸排华思潮产生及其原因解析. 世界地理研究, 24(2):20-30.
	[ Li Cansong, Ge Yuejing, Ma Na and Hu Zhiding . 2015b. The Emergence of Myanmar’s Anti-Chinese Trend of Thought Based on Actors and Its Causes. World Geographic Research, 24(2):20-30. ]
[24]	李贵梅 . 2017. 缅甸克伦族分离运动研究. 上海:华东师范大学, 23.
	[ Li Guimei . 2017. Research on Karen Separation Movement in Myanmar. Shanghai: East China Normal University, 23. ]
[25]	刘稚 . 1997. 缅甸民族问题的由来与发展. 世界民族 (2): 18-22, 67.
	[ Liu Zhi . 1997. Origin and Development of Myanmar’s Ethnic Problem. World Ethnic Groups, (2): 18-22, 67. ]
[26]	罗圣荣, 汪爱平 . 2009. 缅甸果敢冲突及其影响. 现代国际关系 (12): 22-26, 47.
	[ Luo Shengrong and Wang Aiping . 2009. Kokang Conflict in Myanmar and Its Impact. Modern International Relations, (12): 22-26, 47. ]
[27]	梅英, 彭海林 . 2018. 缅北动荡局势下我国边境安全应对刍议. 民族学刊, 9(4):64-70, 118-121.
	[ Mei Ying and Peng Hailin . 2018. On China’s Border Security Response under the Turbulent Situation in Northern Myanmar. Journal of Ethnology, 9 (4): 64-70, 118-121. ]
[28]	Nan Lwin . 2019a. Myanmar Military Chief Backs BRI Projects in Talks with China’s Xi.(2019-04-11)[2019-10-05]. https://www.irrawaddy.com/news/burma/myanmar-military-chief-backs-bri-projects-talks-chinas-xi.html .
[29]	Nan Lwin . 2019b. Chinese Charm Offensive Aims to Win Support for Giant Pipelines in Myanmar.(2019-09-19)[2019-10-05]. https://www.Irrawaddy.com/news/burma/chinese-charm-offensive-aims-to-win-support-for-giant-pipelines-in-myanmar.html.
[30]	Power C . 2011. Conflict or Peace? Ethnic Unrest Intensifies in Burma. Nederland: TNI-BCN Burma Policy Briefing Nr 7. Policy. doi: 10.1364/AO.58.009305 pmid: 31873610
[31]	South A . 2018. “Hybrid Governance” and the Politics of Legitimacy in the Myanmar Peace Process. Journal of Contemporary Asia, 48(1):50-66. doi: 10.1080/00472336.2017.1387280
[32]	Thawnghmung A M and Furnari M . 2019. 10 Anti-state Armed Groups in Myanmar. Terrorism and Insurgency in Asia: A Contemporary Examination of Terrorist and Separatist Movements.
[33]	熊理然, 骆华松, 付磊, 胡志丁, 李灿松 . 2015. 缅北果敢冲突的时空演进及其对中国边境安全的直接影响——基于事件数据及实地调查的解读. 热带地理, 35(4):577-584. doi: 10.13284/j.cnki.rddl.002730
	[ Xiong Liran, Luo Huasong, Fu Lei, Hu Zhiding and Li Cansong . 2015. Spatial and Temporal Evolution of Kokang Conflict in North Myanmar and Its Direct Impact on China’s Border Security: Interpretation Based on Event Data and Field Investigations. Tropical Geography, 35(4):577-584. ] doi: 10.13284/j.cnki.rddl.002730
[34]	Woods K . 2019. Rubber Out of the Ashes: Locating Chinese Agribusiness Investments in ‘Armed Sovereignties’ in the Myanmar-China Borderlands. Territory, Politics, Governance, 7(1):79-95. doi: 10.1080/21622671.2018.1460276
[35]	王天韵 . 2018. 缅甸民族宗教冲突的外溢效应与国际回应. 中央民族大学学报(哲学社会科学版), 45(2):167-176.
	[ Wang Tianyun . 2018. Spillover Effect and International Response to Ethnic and Religious Conflicts in Myanmar. Journal of Central University for Nationalities (Philosophy And Social Sciences Edition), 45(2):167-176. ]
[36]	吴沨 . 2017. 缅甸民族问题与我国西南边疆安全. 聊城:聊城大学, 12.
	[ Wu Feng . 2017. Myanmar’s Ethnic Issues and China’s Southwest Frontier Security. Liaocheng: Liaocheng University, 12. ]
[37]	许正 . 2017. 大湄公河次区域安全机制构建研究. 苏州:苏州大学.
	[ Xu Zheng . 2017. Research on the Construction of Greater Mekong Subregional Security Mechanism. Suzhou: Suzhou University. ]
[38]	阳举伟, 左娅 . 2018. 缅甸族群冲突与和解进程探究. 东南亚研究 (3): 61-86, 155.
	[ Yang Juwei and Zuo Ya . 2018. Exploring the Process of Ethnic Conflict and Reconciliation in Myanmar. Southeast Asian Studies, (3): 61-86, 155. ]
[39]	伊鸿伟 . 2014. 克钦独立军的美国幻想. 看世界,( 11):39-42.
	[ Yi Hongwei . 2014. American Fantasy of the Kachin Independent Army. Look at the World, ( 11):39-42. ]
[40]	尹鸿伟, 刘斌, 李秀卿 . 2009. 缅甸冲突探源. 新华月报,( 10):30-31.
	[ Yin Hongwei, Liu Bin and Li Xiuqing . 2009. Exploring the Origin of the Myanmar Conflict. Xinhua Monthly News, ( 10):30-31. ]
[41]	张蕴岭 . 2019. 对“百年之大变局”的分析与思考. 山东大学学报(哲学社会科学版), 24(5):1-15.
	[ Zhang Yunling . 2019. Analysis and Consideration of the Great Change in the Century. Journal of Shandong University (Philosophy and Social Sciences Edition), 24(5):1-15. ]
[42]	钟贵峰 . 2016. 缅北民族冲突及其难民问题——从中国边疆治理的视角考察. 和平与发展 (5): 82-3, 117.
	[ Zhong Guifeng . 2016. National Conflict and Refugee Issues in Northern Myanmar: From the Perspective of China’s Frontier Governance. Peace and Development, (5): 82-93, 117. ]