热带地理 ›› 2020, Vol. 40 ›› Issue (6): 1150-1160.doi: 10.13284/j.cnki.rddl.003291
• 论文 • 上一篇
收稿日期:
2020-05-24
修回日期:
2020-09-30
出版日期:
2020-11-30
发布日期:
2020-12-10
通讯作者:
徐姗
E-mail:suihongxin2008@163.com;xushan86@cau.edu.cn
作者简介:
隋洪鑫(1984—),女,内蒙古赤峰人,博士,讲师,主要从事城市空间解析与城市更新研究,(E-mail)基金资助:
Hongxin Sui1(), Xiu Yang2, Shan Xu3(
), Daojing Zhou4
Received:
2020-05-24
Revised:
2020-09-30
Online:
2020-11-30
Published:
2020-12-10
Contact:
Shan Xu
E-mail:suihongxin2008@163.com;xushan86@cau.edu.cn
摘要:
文章首先基于西方城市更新发展历程,界定了城市功能更新的概念内涵,进而围绕城市功能更新背景与演替轨迹、城市功能更新类型与组织模式、城市更新空间模拟识别与评价、城市功能更新驱动机理与规划调控等国内外研究进展进行系统梳理,研究发现,城市功能更新趋势与经济社会发展水平、城市化所处阶段紧密相关,更新运作模式体现为政府、私有部门和社区等多元合作倾向,更新判定趋于多源数据融合辨识,更新策略的制定受政策调控力、经济驱动力、市场机制等多重因素叠加影响。基于此,伴随新时期中国城市发展转型调整,城市功能更新研究更加重视对更新实践的科学性认知、空间治理能力的精细化转向、治理理念的人本化回归,并主要聚焦城市功能更新理论体系与实操框架的构建、功能业态演替特征的精细考量、更新调控的因地施策等新时期研究热点。但既有研究主要从城市与区域宏观尺度上对单一功能类型的更新模式进行定性描述,对微观视阈下精细功能业态演替的多时相认知与客观评价仍显不足。为此,提出未来中国城市功能更新应重视加强微观空间尺度下功能业态更新模式的多维度量化解析研究;在研究方法上,应注重融入系统学研究思想及其综合方法。
中图分类号:
隋洪鑫, 杨秀, 徐姗, 周道静. 城市功能空间更新研究进展与新时期重点方向[J]. 热带地理, 2020, 40(6): 1150-1160.
Hongxin Sui, Xiu Yang, Shan Xu, Daojing Zhou. Progress and Hot Research on Urban Functional Space Renewal in the New Era[J]. Tropical Geography, 2020, 40(6): 1150-1160.
表1
西方城市更新发展历程"
概念 | 时期 | 更新特点 | 更新目标 | 典型城市活动 |
---|---|---|---|---|
城市重建 | 20世纪60年代 | 大规模推倒重建 | 清理贫民窟,清除破败建筑,提升城市物 质形象 | 欧美国家城市公共卫生运动、 城市美化运动 |
城市振兴 | 20世纪70年代 | 国家福利主义色彩的社区更新 | 解决城市贫困、就业问题,提升居住环境 | 美国现代城市计划 |
城市再开发 | 20世纪80年代 | 房地产驱动的旧城再开发 | 复兴旧城经济活力 | 英美国家绅士化运动 |
城市再生 | 20世纪90年代 | 渐进式、小规模再开发 | 持续改变地区的经济、物质、社会和环境 条件 | 英国城市挑战计划 |
城市复兴 | 21世纪00年代 | 物质环境、经济和社会等 多维度复兴 | 高度重视人居环境,提倡城市多样性和 多功能性 | 美国匹兹堡复兴 |
城市空间 可持续 | 21世纪10年代 | 城市功能提升的精细化更新 与治理 | 构建可持续发展的城市空间品质和人类住区 | 英国、瑞典等国家出台的SDGs 专项行动计划 |
Antonio Nesticò and Francesco Sica. 2017. The Sustainability of Urban Renewal Projects: A Model for Economic Multi-Criteria Analysis. Journal of Property Investment & Finance, 35(4): 397-409. | |
Cao Rui, Tu Wei, Yang Cuixin, Li Qing, Liu Jun, Zhu Jiasong, Zhang Qian, Li Qingquan and Qiu Guoping. 2020. Deep Learning-Based Remote and Social Sensing data Fusion for Urban Region Function Recognition. ISPRS Journal of Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing, (163): 82-97. | |
Chen Yimin, Chen Xinyue, Liu Zihui and Li Xia. 2020. Understanding the Spatial Organization of Urban Functions Based on Co-Location Patterns Mining: A Comparative Analysis for 25 Chinese Cities. Cities, (97): 182-194. | |
Cho M and Kim J. 2016. Coupling Urban Regeneration with Age-Friendliness: Neighborhood Regeneration in Jangsu Village, Seoul. Cities, (58): 107-114. | |
查君,金旖旎.2017.从空间引导走向需求引导—城市更新本源性研究.城市发展研究,24(11):51-57.[Cha Jun and Jin Yini. 2017. From Spacial Renewal to Demands-Oriented Renewal. Urban Development Studies, 24(11): 51-57. ] | |
陈世莉,陶海燕,李旭亮,卓莉.2016.基于潜在语义信息的城市功能区识别:广州市浮动车GPS时空数据挖掘.地理学报,71(3):471-483.[Chen Shili, Tao Haiyan, Li Xuliang and Zhuo Li. 2016. Discovering Urban Functional Regions Using Latent Semantic Information: Spatiotemporal Data Mining of Floating Cars GPS data of Guangzhou. Acta Geographica Sinica, 71(3): 471-483. ] | |
陈映雪,甄峰.2014.基于居民活动数据的城市空间功能组织再探究——以南京市为例.城市规划学刊,(5):72-78.[Chen Yingxue and Zhen Fen. 2014. Further Investigation into Urban Spatial Function Organization Based on Residents’ Activity Data—A Case Study of Nanjing. Urban Planning Forum, (5): 72-78. ] | |
邓羽,陈田,刘盛和. 2017. 城市物质空间更新研究进展与展望. 地理科学进展,36(5):540-548. [DengYu, ChenTian and Liu Shenghe. 2017. Progress and Prospects of Urban Regeneration Research. Progress in Geography, 36(5): 540-548. ] | |
Darchen Ladouceur. 2013. Social Sustainability in Urban Regeneration Practice: A Case Study of the Fortitude Valley RenewalPlan in Brisbane. Australian Planner, 50(4): 340-350. | |
David Yee. 2020. The Making of Mexico City’s Historic Center: National Patrimony in the Age of Urban Renewal. Journal of Planning History, 19(2): 90-111. | |
Dennis Gale. 2019. Hertz: The Battle of Lincoln Park: Urban Renewal and Gentrification in Chicago. Journal of the American Planning Association, 85(4): 587-588. | |
Dorota Kamrowska-Załuska and Hanna Obracht-Prondzyńska. 2020. Urban Regeneration in Urban Functional Areas in Poland Asan Instrument of Implementation of the EU Cohesion Policy. Growth and Change, 51(1): 278-301. | |
Farinosi M, Fortunati L, O’Sullivan J and Pagani L. 2019. Enhancing Classical Methodological Tools to Foster Participatory Dimensions in Local Urban Planning. Cities, (88): 235-249. | |
Frantál B, Greer-Wootten B, Klusáček P, Krejčí T, Kunc J and Martinát S. 2015. Exploring Spatial Patterns of Urban Brownfields Regeneration: the Case of Brno, Czech Republic. Cities, (44): 9-18. | |
方创琳.2019.中国新型城镇化高质量发展的规律性与重点方向.地理研究,38(1):13-22.[Fang Chuanglin. 2019. Basic Rules and Key Paths for High-Quality Development of the New Urbanization in China. Geographical Research, 38(1): 13-22. ] | |
Giles Thomson and Peter Newman. 2018. Urban Fabrics and Urban Metabolism—from Sustainable to Regenerative Cities. Resources Conservation & Recycling, (132): 218-229. | |
Goran Erfani. 2020. Sense of Place as an Investigative Method for the Evaluation of Participatory Urban Redevelopment. Cities, (99): 1026-1048. | |
郭源园,李莉.2019.中国收缩城市及其发展的负外部性.地理科学,39(1):52-60.[Guo Yuanyuan and Li Li. 2019. Change in the Negative Externality of the Shrinking Cities in China. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 39(1): 52-60. ] | |
Hao Wenxuan, Tong De, Liu Qing and Feng Changchun. 2016. Delimitation and Classified Planning Management of Functional Renovation Zone: Experience of and Discussion on Shenzhen's Practice of Urban Renewal. China City Planning Review, 25(2): 42-50. | |
韩会然,杨成凤,宋金平.2014.城市居住与就业空间关系研究进展及展望.人文地理,29(6):24-31.[Han Huiran, Yang Chengfeng and Song Jinping. 2014. Progress and Prospects of Jobs-Housing Spatial Relationship Research. Human Geography, 29(6): 24-31.] | |
浩飞龙,施响,白雪,王士君.2019.多样性视角下的城市复合功能特征及成因探测—以长春市为例.地理研究,38(2):247-258.[Hao Feilong, Shi Xiang, Bai Xue and Wang Shijun. 2019. Geographic Detection and Multifunctional Land Use from the Perspective of Urban Diversity: A Case Study of Changchun. Geographical Research, 38(2): 247-258.] | |
黄莉.2012.城市功能复合:模式与策略.热带地理,32(1):51-52.[Huang Li. 2012. Mixed Land Use for Urban Development: Models and Strategies. Tropical Geograph, 32(1): 51-52.] | |
Ilaria Zambon, Pere Serra and Luca Salvati. 2019. The (Evolving) Urban Footprint under Sequential Building Cycles and Changing Socio-Demographic Contexts. Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 75: 27-36. | |
Jiang Yanpeng, Nalini Mohabir, Ma Renfeng, Wu Lichao and Chen Mingxing. 2020. Whose Village? Stakeholder Interests in the Urban Renewal of Hubei Old Village in Shenzhen. Land Use Policy, 91:104411. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol. 2019.104411. | |
Kin Sun Chan and Yeung Fai Philip Siu. 2015. Urban Governance and Social Sustainability. Asian Education and Development, 4(3): 330-342. | |
Koichi Kana. 2012. An Experiment in Urban Regeneration Using Culture and Art in Senba, Osaka's Historic Urban Center, With a Focus on the Regeneration of Urban Space. City, Culture and Society, 3(2): 151-163. | |
Lawrence W C Lai and Frank T Lorne. 2019. Sustainable Urban Renewal and Built Heritag Conservation in a Global Real Estate Revolution. Sustainability, 11(3): 61-78. | |
Lawrence W C Lai, K W Chau and Polycarp Alvin C W Cheung. 2018. Urban Renewal and Redevelopment: Social Justice and Property Rights with Reference to Hong Kong's Constitutional Capitalism. Cities, (74): 240-248. | |
Lelévrier Christine. 2013. Social Mix Neighbourhood Policies and Social Interaction: The Experience of Newcomers in Three New Renewal Developments in France. Cities, (35): 409-416. | |
Leo Kwun-Sing Wong and Peter Hoi-Fuyu. 2015. Urban Renewal and Social Sustainability: An Exploratory Study of the Urban Life of Wan Chai. Springer Plus, 4(2): 1-2. | |
Li Linghin, Lin Jie, Xin Li and Fan Wu. 2014. Redevelopment of Urban Village in China—A Step towards an Effective Urban Policy? A Case Study of Liede Village in Guangzhou. Habitat International, (43): 299-308. | |
Li Xun, Hui Eddie C M, Chen Tingting, Lang Wei and Guo Youliang. 2019. From Habitat III to the New Urbanization Agenda in China: Seeing through the Practices of the “Three Old Renewals” in Guangzhou. Land Use Policy, (81): 513-522. | |
Lidia Morawska, Wendy Miller, Matt Riley, Sotiris Vardoulakis, Yong-Guanzhu, Guy B Marks, Prachi Garnawat, Prashant Kumar and Marie Thynell. 2019. Towards Urbanome the Genome of the City to Enhance the form and Function of Future Cities. Nature Communications, 10(1): 65-82. | |
Liu Guiwen, Chen Sijing and Gu Jianping. 2019a. Urban Renewal Simulation with Spatial, Economic and Policy Dynamics: The Rent-Gap Theory-Based Model and the Case Study of Chongqing. Land Use Policy, (86): 238-252. | |
Liu Yilun, Zhu A-Xing, Wang Jingli, Li Wenkai, Hu Guohua and Hu Yueming. 2019b. Land-Use Decision Support in Brownfield Redevelopment for Urban Renewal Based on Crowdsourced Data and a Presence-and-Background Learning (PBL) Method. Land Use Policy, (88): 111-124. | |
Luca Salvati. 2019. Examining Urban Functions along a Metropolitan Gradient: A Geographically Weighted Regression Tells You More. Letters in Spatial and Resource Sciences, 12(1): 19-40. | |
李苗裔,马妍,孙小明,王静远,党安荣.2018.基于多源数据时空熵的城市功能混合度识别评价.城市规划,42(2):97-103.[Li Miaoyi, Ma Yan, Sun Xiaoming, Wang Jingyuan and Dang Anrong. 2018. Application of Spatial and Temporal Entropy Based on Multi-source Data for Measuring the Mix Degree of Urban Functions. City Planning Review, 42(2): 97-103.] | |
刘贵文,易志勇,魏骊臻,胡鑫瑜.2017.基于政策工具视角的城市更新政策研究:以深圳为例.城市发展研究,24(3):47-53.[Liu Guiwen, Yi Zhiyong, Wei Lizhen and Hu Xinyu. 2017. Evaluation of Urban Renewal Policy Based on Policy Instrument: Case in Shenzhen. Urban Development Studies, 24(3): 47-53.] | |
刘易斯•芒福德.1989.城市发展史:起源、演变和前景.倪文彦,宋峻岭,译.北京:中国建筑工业出版社.[Mumford Lewis Marta Bottero. 1989.The City in History: Its Origins, Its Transformations, and Its Prospects. Ni Wenyan and Song JunLing. Trans.. Beijing, China: China Architecture & Building Press. ] | |
Marta Bottero, Francesca Bragaglia, Nadia Caruso, Giulia Datola and Federico Dell’ Anna. 2020. Experimenting Community Impact Evaluation (CIE) for Assessing Urban Regeneration Programmes: The Case Study of the Area 22@Barcelona. Cities,99(1): 82-94. | |
Miguel De Oliver. 2016. Gentrification as the Appropriation of Therapeutic ‘Diversity’: A Model and Case Study of the Multicultural Amenity of Contemporary Urban Renewal. Urban Studies, 53(6): 1299-1316. | |
Nazem Tahvilzadeh, Stig Montin and Mikael Cullberg. 2017. Functions of Sustainability: Exploring What Urban Sustainability Policy Discourse “Does” in the Gothenburg Metropolitan Area. Local Environment, 22(1): 66-85. | |
Nicholas Beech. 2020. Boom Cities: Architect-Planners and the Politics of Radical Urban Renewal in 1960s Britain. Planning Perspectives, 35(1): 226-227. | |
彭恺.2018.新马克思主义视角下我国治理型城市更新模式——空间利益主体角色及合作伙伴关系重构.规划师,34(6):5-11.[Peng Kai. 2018. A Study on Governance Based Urban Renewal Model from the Perspective of New Marxism: Restructuring of the Roles and Partnership of Different Spatial Stakeholders. Planners, 34(6): 5-11.] | |
Roshanak Mehdipanah, Giulia Marra, Giulia Melis and Elena Gelormino. 2018. Urban Renewal, Gentrification and Health Quity: A Realist Perspective. The European Journal of Public Health, 28(2): 243-248. | |
Sanne Holtslag-Broekhof. 2018. Urban Land Readjustment: Necessary for Effective Urban Renewal? Analysing the Dutch Quest for New Legislation. Land Use Policy, (77): 821-828. | |
Sarah Mekdjian. 2018. Urban Artivism and Migrations. Disrupting Spatial and Political Segregation of Migrants in European Cities. Cities, (77): 39-48. | |
Schenkel Walter. 2015. Regeneration Strategies in Shrinking Urban Neighbourhoods Dimensions of Interventions in Theory and Practice. European Planning Studies, 23(1): 69-86. | |
Seth Schindler, Diana Mitlin and Simon Marvin. 2018. National Urban Policy Making and its Potential for Sustainable Urbanism. Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability, (34): 48-53. | |
Simin Davoudi and John Sturzaker. 2017. Urban Form, Policy Packaging and Sustainable Urban Metabolism. Resources Conservation & Recycling, (120): 55-64. | |
申庆喜,李诚固,马佐澎,周国磊,胡述聚. 2016.基于服务空间视角的长春市城市功能空间扩展研究.地理科学,36(2):274-282.[Shen Qingxi, Li Chenggu, Ma Zuopeng, Zhou Guolei and Hu Shuju. 2016. The Expansion of the Functional Space of Changchun City Based on Service Space. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 36(2): 274-282. ] | |
隋洪鑫,王江浩,刘银喜,邓羽.2020.轨道交通站域的城市空间演替轨迹与更新模式判定—多例比对与城市可持续发展启示.遥感技术与应用,35(2):1-14.[Sui Hongxin, Wang Jianghao, Liu Yinxi and Deng Yu. 2020. Urban Functional Spatial Succession Trajectory and Determination of Renewal Mode in Rail Transit Station Area—Multiple Cases Comparisons and Sustainable Enlightenment. Remote Sensing Technology and Application, 35(2): 1-14. ] | |
Tighe J Rosie Ganning and Joanna P. 2016. Do Shrinking Cities Allow Redevelopment without Displacement? An Analysis of Affordability Based on Housing and Transportation Costs for Redeveloping, Declining, and Stable Neighborhoods. Housing Policy Debate, 26(4/5): 785-800. | |
Romano Fistola, Carmela Gargiulo, Rosaria Battarra and Rosa Anna La Rocca. 2019. Sustainability of Urban Functions: Dealing with Tourism Activity. Sustainability, 11(4): 354-366. | |
Vincenzo del Giudice, Pierfrancesco De Paola and Francesca Torrieri. 2014. An Integrated Choice Model for the Evaluation of Urban Sustainable Renewal Scenarios. Advanced Materials Research, (3470): 2399-2406. | |
Walaa Abou El-Haggag Mehanna and Wesam Abou El-Haggag Mehanna. 2019. Urban Renewal for Traditional Commercial Streets at the Historical Centers of Cities. Alexandria Engineering Journal, 58(4): 1127-1143. | |
Wei Zheng, Shen Geoffrey Qiping, Wang Hao, Jing Kehong and Li Zhengdao. 2017. Decision Support for Sustainable Urban Renewal: a Multi-Scale Model. Land Use Policy, (69): 361-371. | |
William J Collins and Katharine L Shester. 2013. Slum Clearance and Urban Renewal in the United States. American Economic Journal Applied Economics, 5(1): 239-253. | |
王丽艳,薛颖,王振坡.2020.城市更新、创新街区与城市高质量发展.城市发展研究,27(1):67-74.[Wang Liyan, Xue Ying and Wang Zhenpo. 2020. Urban Renewal, Innovative Neighborhoods and High Quality Urban Development. Urban Development Studies, 27(1): 67-74. ] | |
谢涤湘,范建红,常江.2017.从空间再生产到地方营造:中国城市更新的新趋势.城市发展研究,24(12):110-115.[Xie Dixiang, Fan Jianhong and Chang Jiang. 2017. From Space Reproduction to Placemaking: the new Trend of China's Urban Regeneration. Urban Development Studies, 24(12): 110-115. ] | |
严若谷,周素红,闫小培.2011.城市更新之研究.地理科学进展,30(8):947-955.[Yan Ruogu, Zhou Suhong and Yan Xiaopei. 2011. Studies of Urban Regeneration. Progress in Geography, 30(8): 947-955. ] | |
阳建强,杜雁.2016.城市更新要同时体现市场规律和公共政策属性.城市规划,40(1):72-74.[Yang Jianqiang and Du Yan. 2016. Urban Renewal Should Reflect both the Market Law and the Attribute of Public Policy. City Planning Review, 40 (1): 72-74.] | |
杨成凤,韩会然,张学波,宋金平.2016.国内外城市功能疏解研究进展.人文地理,31(1):8-15.[Yang Chengfeng, Han Huiran, Zhang Xuebo and Song Jinping. 2016. Progress of Urban Function Decentralization Research. Human Geography, 31(1): 8-15.] | |
叶强,莫正玺,许乙青.2019.1979—2014年长沙市城市功能用地扩展与驱动力研究.地理研究,38(5):1063-1079.[Ye Qiang, Mo Zhengxi and Xu Yiqing. 2019. The Expansion and Driving Forces of the Functional Space Land: A Case Study of Changsha from 1979 to 2014. Geographical Research, 38(5): 1063-1079.] | |
Zhang Liming and Pfoser Dieter. 2019. Using OpenStreetMap Point-of-Interest Data to Model Urban Change—A Feasibility Study. PLoS One,14(2): 1-34. | |
Zhao Liu, Shunyi Wang and Fang Wang. 2019. Isolated or Integrated? Planning and Management of Urban Renewal for Historic Areas in Old Beijing City, Based on the Association Network System. Habitat International, 93: 313-342. | |
Zhou Guolei, Li Chenggu, Li Moyin, Zhang Jing and Liu Yanjun. 2016. Agglomeration and Diffusion of Urban Functions: An Approach Based on Urban Land Use Conversion. Habitat International, 56: 20-30. | |
张杰.2019.存量时代的城市更新与织补.建筑学报,(7):1-5.[Zhang Jie. 2019. Urban Renewal and Urban Weaving in an Era of Stock Properties. Architectural Journal, (7): 1-5.] | |
张京祥,于涛,陆枭麟.2013.全球化时代的城市大事件营销效应:基于空间生产视角.人文地理,28(5):1-5.[Zhang Jingxiang, Yu Tao and Lu Xiaolin. 2013. Marketing Effects of Urban Mega-Event in the Era of Globalization: Based on Spatial Prodution Theory. Human Geography, 28(5): 1-5.] | |
张磊.2015.“新常态”下城市更新治理模式比较与转型路径.城市发展研究,22(12):57-62.[Zhang Lei. 2015. The Modes of Urban Redevelopment in New Normal: Diversification and Transformation. Urban Development Studies, 22(12): 57-62.] | |
邓智团.2015.空间正义、社区赋权与城市更新范式的社会形塑.城市发展研究,22(8):61-66.[Deng Zhituan. 2015. Spatial Justice Community Empowerment and Social Shaping of Urban Regeneration Paradigm. Urban Development Studies, 22(8): 61-66.] | |
吴良镛. 2005.区域规划与人居环境创造.城市发展研究,12(4):1-6.[Wu Liangyong. 2005. Region Planning and the Creation of Human Settlements. Urban Development Studies, 12(4): 1-6.] |
[1] | 保继刚, 张子昂, 曲鸣亚. 城市功能与地位转变的内在逻辑与实现路径[J]. 热带地理, 2020, 40(4): 604-611. |
[2] | 江海燕, 周春山. 广州公园绿地的服务特征及其成因分析[J]. 热带地理, 2011, 31(4): 397-402. |
|