热带地理 ›› 2021, Vol. 41 ›› Issue (1): 167-176.doi: 10.13284/j.cnki.rddl.003311
收稿日期:
2020-04-15
修回日期:
2020-10-13
出版日期:
2021-01-05
发布日期:
2021-02-19
通讯作者:
曾刚
E-mail:51173902028@stu.ecnu.edu.cn;gzeng@re.ecnu.edu.cn
作者简介:
张翌(1994—),女,江西新干人,博士研究生,主要研究方向为企业创新与区域经济发展研究,(E-mail)基金资助:
Yi Zhanga,b(), Yuefang Sia,b, Gang Zenga,b(
)
Received:
2020-04-15
Revised:
2020-10-13
Online:
2021-01-05
Published:
2021-02-19
Contact:
Gang Zeng
E-mail:51173902028@stu.ecnu.edu.cn;gzeng@re.ecnu.edu.cn
摘要:
基于经济地理学领域的相关文献,系统梳理并评述了中资企业离岸研发的已有研究进展。研究发现,目前国内外经济地理学在中资企业离岸研发的区位选择、空间组织、行为主体等作用机制及溢出效应等方面取得了一批研究成果:中资企业离岸研发的区位主导因素因东道国特征和企业发展阶段不同而有所侧重,离岸研发的空间组织模式及其知识流动路径因其在全球创新格局中的地位而呈现差异化特征,其中跨国人员在帮助企业及地区获取其知识溢出并实现技术追赶中发挥重要的“边界扳手”作用;但同时现有研究也存在理论针对性不强、分析手段缺乏、溢出效应重视不够等问题:建议针对中资企业离岸研发活动的特点,从关系、制度、演化的视角入手,建立新的企业离岸研发理论假说。并从创新活动“流的空间”的视角入手,揭示多尺度下中资企业离岸研发空间演化规律;从关系和演化经济地理学视角入手,厘清不同尺度及多维邻近性视角下中资企业离岸研发区位因子;从中资企业特殊商业文化入手,分析华人华侨、海外人才等行为主体在中资企业离岸研发活动形成与发展中的作用;从创新溢出效应的视角入手,区分中资企业离岸研发活动对母国和东道国发展的影响。
中图分类号:
张翌, 司月芳, 曾刚. 中资企业离岸研发研究进展:经济地理学的探索[J]. 热带地理, 2021, 41(1): 167-176.
Yi Zhang, Yuefang Si, Gang Zeng. Research Progress on Offshoring R&D of Chinese Enterprises from the Perspective of Economic Geography[J]. Tropical Geography, 2021, 41(1): 167-176.
Awate S, Larsen M M and Mudambi R. 2015. Accessing vs Sourcing Knowledge: A Comparative Study of R&D Internationalization between Emerging and Advanced Economy Firms. Journal of International Business Studies, 46(1): 63-86. | |
Bathelt H and Li P F. 2014. Global Cluster Networks-Foreign Direct Investment Flows from Canada to China. Journal of Economic Geography, 14(1): 45-71. | |
Behrman J N and Fischer W A. 1980. Overseas R&D Activities of Transnational Corporations. Cambridge, MA: Oelgeschlager, Gunn and Hain. | |
Binz C, Tang T and Huenteler J. 2017. Spatial Lifecycles of Cleantech Industries-The Global Development History of Solar Photovoltaics. Energy Policy, 101: 386-402. | |
Buckley P J and Ghauri P N. 2004. Globalisation, Economic Geography and the Strategy of Multinational Enterprises. Journal of International Business Studies, 35(2): 81-98. | |
Bunnell T G and Coe N M. 2001. Spaces and Scales of Innovation. Progress in Human Geography, 25(4): 569-589. | |
Castellani D and Pieri F. 2013. R&D Offshoring and the Productivity Growth of European Regions. Research Policy, 42(9): 1581-1594. | |
Chen J, Zhao X and Tong L. 2011. China's R&D Internationalization and Reform of Science and Technology System. Journal of Science and Technology Policy in China, 2(2): 100-121. | |
Colovic A and Mayrhofer U. 2011. Optimizing the Location of R&D and Production Activities: Trends in the Automotive Industry, European Planning Studies, 19(8): 1481-1498. | |
Cornell University, INSEAD, WIPO. 2016. The Global Innovation Index 2016: Winning with Global Innovation. Ithaca, Fontainebleau, and Geneva: Cornell University, INSEAD, WIPO. | |
陈劲,景劲松,周笑磊. 2003. 我国企业R&D国际化的影响因素分析. 科学学研究,21(1):51-57. [Chen Jin, Jing Jinsong and Zhou Xiaolei. 2003. Influencing Factors for Internationalization of R&D of Chinese Enterprises. Studies in Science of Science, 21(1): 51-57. ] | |
陈劲,曾珍云. 2011. 开放式创新视角下中国企业R&D国际化的关键路径研究. 科技管理研究,31(3):13-15,8. [Chen Jin and Zeng Zhenyun. 2011. Research on the Critical Path of Chinese R&D Internationalization from the Perspective of Open Innovation. Science and Technology Management Research, 31(3): 13-15, 8. ] | |
陈岩,徐慧慧,景木南,郑江. 2015. 多维政府参与、企业动态能力与海外研发—基于中国创新型企业的实证研究. 科学管理,36(S1):127-138. [Chen Yan, Xu Huihui, Jing Munan and Zheng Jiang. 2015. Multiple Government Involvement, Dynamic Capabilities and Oversea R&D of Enterprises-An Empirical Study on Chinese Innovative Enterprises. Science Research Management, 36(S1): 127-138. ] | |
陈衍泰,李欠强,王丽,吴哲. 2016. 中国企业海外研发投资区位选择的影响因素——基于东道国制度质量的调节作用. 科研管理,37(3):73-80. [Chen Yantai, Li Qianqiang, Wang Li and Wu Zhe. 2016. Determinants of Chinese Enterprises Overseas R&D Location Choice: Based on the Moderating Role of the Host Country's Institutional Quality. Science Research Management, 37(3): 73-80. ] | |
D'agostino L M, Laursen K and Santangelo G D. 2013. The Impact of R&D Offshoring on the Home Knowledge Production of OECD Investing Regions. Journal of Economic Geography, 13(1): 145-175. | |
Demirbag M and Glaister K W. 2010. Factors Determining Offshore Location Choice for R&D Projects: A Comparative Study of Developed and Emerging Regions. Journal of Management Studies, 47(8): 1534-1560. | |
Deng P, Delios A and Peng M W. 2020. A Geographic Relational Perspective on the Internationalization of Emerging Market Firms. Journal of International Business Studies, 51(1): 50-71. | |
Dunning J H and Lundan S M. 2009. The Internationalization of Corporate R&D: A Review of the Evidence and Some Policy Implications for Home Countries. Review of Policy Research, 26(1/2): 13-33. | |
杜德斌. 2007. 跨国公司R&D全球化:地理学的视角. 世界地理研究,16(4):106-113. [Du Debin. 2007. R&D Globalization by MNCs: A Perspective from Geography. World Regional Studies, 16(4): 106-113. ] | |
杜群阳,邓丹青. 2015. 中国对非洲直接投资的空间分布及其影响因素研究. 地理科学,35(4):396-400. [Du Qunyang and Deng Danqing. 2015. The Spatial Distribution and Its Determinants of the Spatial Distribution and Its Determinants of Chinese Outward Direct Investment to Africa. Scientia Geography Sinica, 35(4): 396-400. ] | |
Ernst D. 2006. Innovation Offshoring: Asia´s Emerging Role in Global Innovation Networks. USA: East-West Center Special Reports. | |
Fan P. 2011. Innovation, Globalization, and Catch-up of Latecomers: Cases of Chinese Telecom Firms. Environment and Planning A, 43(4): 830-849. | |
Fifarek B J and Veloso F M. 2010. Offshoring and the Global Geography of Innovation. Journal of Economic Geography, 10(4): 559-578. | |
Gassmann O and Von Zedtwitz M. 1999. New Concepts and Trends in International R&D Organization. Research Policy, 28(2): 231-250. | |
Haakonsson S J, Ørberg Jensen P D and Mudambi S M. 2013. A Co-Evolutionary Perspective on the Drivers of International Sourcing of Pharmaceutical R&D to India. Journal of Economic Geography, 13(4): 677-700. | |
He S, Fallon G, Khan Z, Lew Y K, Kim K and Wei P. 2017. Towards a New Wave in Internationalization of Innovation? The Rise of China's Innovative MNEs, Strategic Coupling, and Global Economic Organization. Canadian Journal of Administrative Sciences, 34(4): 343-355. | |
胡曙虹,杜德斌,范蓓蕾. 2019. 中国企业R&D国际化:时空格局与区位选择影响因素. 地理研究,38(7):1733-1748. [Hu Shuhong, Du Debin and Fan Beilei. 2019. R&D Globalization of Chinese Companies: Spatial-Temporal Pattern and Influencing Factors of Location Selection. Geographical Research, 38(7): 1733-1748. ] | |
胡曙虹. 2018. 中国企业R&D 国际化:区位选择与空间组织. 上海:华东师范大学. [Hu Shuhong. 2018. R&D Internationalization of Chinese Enterprises: Location Selection and Spatial Organization. Shanghai: East China Normal University. ] | |
Santangelo G D, Meyer K and Jindra B. 2014. Why Do MNE Subsidiaries Outsource R&D in Countries with Weaker National IPR Regimes? The Role of Local Institutions. (2014-12-30) [2019-11-25]. Druid8.sit.aau.dk. https://conference.druid.dk/acc_papers/snk15121qf872bpool16vlnlsyxf.pdf. | |
Karreman B, Burger J M and Van F G. 2017. Location Choices of Chinese Multinationals in Europe: The Role of Overseas Communities. Economic Geography, 93(2): 131-161. | |
Lewin A Y, Massini S and Peeters C. 2009. Why Are Companies Offshoring Innovation the Emerging Global Race for Talent. Journal of International Business Studies, 40(6): 901-925. | |
Liefner I, Si Y and Schaefer K J. 2019. A Latecomer Firm's R&D Collaboration with Advanced Country Universities and Research Institutes: The Case of Huawei in Germany. Technovation, 86/87: 3-14. | |
梁育填,周政可,刘逸. 2018. 东南亚华人华侨网络与中国企业海外投资的区位选择关系研究. 地理学报,73(8):1449-1461. [Liang Yutian, Zhou Zhengke and Liu Yi. 2018. Relationship between the Location Choices of Chinese Outbound Enterprises and Overseas Chinese Networks: The Case Study of Southeast Asia. Acta Georaphica Sinica, 73(8): 1449-1461. ] | |
林初昇. 2020. 去中心化和(逆)全球化背景下中国人文地理学的批判性理论探索与方法创新. 热带地理,40(1):1-9. [Lin Chusheng. 2020. Critical Theoretical Engagements and Methodological Innovation for China's Human Geography in a Decentering and (Anti) Globalizing World. Tropical Geography, 40(1): 1-9. ] | |
柳卸林,吴晟,朱丽. 2017. 华为的海外研发活动发展及全球研发网络分析. 科学学研究,(6):37-44,65. [Liu Xielin, Wu Sheng and Zhu Li. 2017. Analysis on Huawei's Overseas R&D Activities Development and Its Global R&D Network. Studies in Science of Science,(6):37-44, 65. ] | |
Massini S and Miozzo M. 2012. Outsourcing and Offshoring of Business Services: Challenges to Theory, Management and Geography of Innovation. Regional Studies,46(9): 1219-1242. | |
Mathews J A. 2002. Competitive Advantages of the Latecomer Firm: A Resource-Based Account of Industrial Catch-up Strategies. Asia Pacific Journal of Management, 19(4): 467-488. | |
Mathews J A. 2006. Dragon Multinationals: New Players in 21st Century Globalization. Asia Pacific Journal of Management, 23(1): 5-27. | |
Mckinsey Company. 2016. Digital Globalization: The New Era of Global Flows(2016-02-24) [2019-11-25]. https://www.mckinsey.com/business-functions/digital-mckinsey/our-insights/digital-globalization-the-new-era-of-global-flows. | |
Meyer K E, Mudambi R and Narula R. 2011. Multinational Enterprises and Local Contexts: The Opportunities and Challenges of Multiple Embeddedness. Journal of Management Studies, 48(2): 235-252. | |
Minin A D and Zhang J. 2010. An Exploratory Study on International R&D Strategies of Chinese Companies in Europe. Review of Policy Research,27(4): 433-455. | |
Plechero M and Chaminade C. 2013. The Influence of Micro-Characteristics in Different Modes of Globalization of Innovation: A Comparative Study of Indian (Pune) and Chinese (Beijing) Firms. Industry and Innovation, 20(7): 661-682. | |
Rilla N and Squicciarini M. 2011. R&D Location and Offshore Outsourcing: A Management Perspective. International Journal of Management Reviews, 13(4): 393-413. | |
Ronstadt R C. 1978. International R&D: The Establishment and Evolution of Research and Development Abroad by Seven US Multinationals. Journal of International Business Studies, 9(1): 7-24. | |
Santos-Paulino A U, Squicciarini M and Fan P. 2014. Foreign Direct Investment, R&D Mobility and the New Economic Geography: A Survey. The World Economy, 37(12): 1692-1715. | |
Saxenian A. 2006. The New Argonauts: Regional Advantage in a Global Economy. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. | |
Schaefer K J and Liefner I. 2017. Offshore versus Domestic: Can EM MNCs Reach Higher R&D Quality Abroad. Scientometrics, 113: 1349-1370. | |
Schaefer K J. 2020. Catching Up by Hiring: The Case of Huawei. Journal of International Business Studies, 51(9): 1500-1515 . | |
Si Y. 2013a. Outward FDI from China Historical Development, Geographical Distribution and the Obstacles to Subsidiary Business Success. Giessen: Justus-Liebig-University. | |
Si Y, Liefner I and Wang T. 2013b. Foreign Direct Investment with Chinese Characteristics: A Middle Path between Ownership-Location-Internalization Model and Linkage-Leverage-Learning Model. Chinese Geographical Science, 23(5): 594-606. | |
Steinberg P J, Procher V D and Urbig D. 2017. Too Much or Too Little of R&D Offshoring: The Impact of Captive Offshoring and Contract Offshoring on Innovation Performance. Research Policy, 46(10): 1810-1823. | |
司月芳,陈思雨,Liefner I,曾刚. 2016. 中资企业研发国际化研究——基于华为WIPO专利分析. 地理研究,34(10):1869-1878. [Si Yuefang, Chen Siyu, Liefner I and Zeng Gang. 2016. Innovation Globalization of Chinese Multinational Enterprises: The Case Study of Huawei. Geographical Research, 34(10): 1869-1878. ] | |
司月芳,刘婉昕,朱贻文,聂雨涵. 2019. 中资企业研发国际化行为与创新绩效:基于2016—2018年中国国际工业博览会调研数据. 地理科学进展,38(10):1523-1534. [Si Yuefang, Liu Wanxin, Zhu Yiwen and Nie Yuhan. 2019. R&D Internationalization of Chinese Enterprises and Innovation Performance: Based on the Survey Data of Enterprises at the China International Industry Fair 2016-2018. Progress in Geography, 38(10): 1523-1534. ] | |
滕堂伟,胡森林. 2016. 跨国集群网络与丝绸之路经济带建设新模式. 兰州大学学报(社会科学版),(44):89. [Teng Tangwei and Hu Senlin. 2016. New Models for Multinational Cluster Networks and the Silk Road Economic Belt Construction. Journal of Lanzhou University (Social Sciences), (44): 89. ] | |
Verspagen B and Schoenmakers W. 2004. The Spatial Dimension of Patenting by Multinational Firms in Europe. Journal of Economic Geography, 4: 23-42. | |
Von Zedtwitz M. 2006. International R&D Strategies of TNCs from Developing Countries: The Case of China. Geneva: Globalization of R&D and Developing Countries Proceedings of an Expert Meeting, 117-140. | |
许晖,单宇,冯永春. 2017. 新兴经济体跨国企业研发国际化过程中技术知识如何流动——基于华为公司的案例研究. 管理案例研究与评论,(5):433-448. [Xu Hui, Shan Yu, and Feng Yongchun. 2017. How Does Technical Knowledge Flowing in the R&D Internationalization Process of EMNEs: A Case Study Based on Huawei. Journal of Management Case Studies, (5): 433-448. ] | |
Yeung H W C and Coe N M. 2015. Toward a Dynamic Theory of Global Production Networks. Economic Geography,91(1): 29-58. | |
Yeung H W C and Liu W. 2008. Globalizing China: The Rise of Mainland Chinese Firms in the Global Economy. Eurasian Geography and Economics,49(1): 57-86. | |
Yeung H W C. 2003. Chinese Capitalism in a Global Era: Towards a Hybrid Capitalism. London: Routledge. | |
曾刚,王秋玉,曹贤忠. 2018. 创新经济地理研究述评与展望. 经济地理,38(4):19-25. [Zeng Gang, Wang Qiuyu and Cao Xianzhong. 2018. Review on Innovation Economic Geography. Economic Geography, 38(4): 19-25. ] | |
张虹鸥,黄耿志,吴康敏,叶玉瑶,王洋. 2017. 中国对外直接投资的特征与若干经济地理研究议题:基于中国对全球与东盟的投资分析. 热带地理,37(4):443-451. [Zhang Hong'ou, Huang Gengzhi, Wu Kangmin, Ye Yuyao and Wang Yang. 2017. Characteristics of China’s OFDI and Related Economic Geography Research Themes: Based on an Analysis of Chinese Investment in the World and ASEAN Countries. Tropical Geography, 37(4): 443-451. ] | |
张建红,周朝鸿. 2010. 中国企业走出去的制度障碍研究——以海外收购为例. 经济研究,(6):80-91. [Zhang Jianhong and Zhou Chaohong. 2010. Excess Demand or Appropriate Demand?—Health Insurance, Medical Care and Mortality of the Elderly in Urban China. Economic Research,(6): 80-91. ] | |
朱贻文,曾刚,曹贤忠,司月芳. 2017. 不同空间视角下创新网络与知识流动研究进展. 世界地理研究,26(4):117-125. [Zhu Yiwen, Zeng Gang, Cao Xianzhong and Si Yuefang. 2017. Research Progress of Innovation Network and Knowledge Flow. World Regional Studies, 26(4): 117-125. ] | |
祝影,杜德斌. 2005. 跨国公司研发全球化的空间组织研究. 经济地理,25(5):620-623. [Zhu Ying and Du Debin. 2005. The Spatial Organization of R&D Globalization by Multinational Corporations. Economic Geography, 25(5): 620-623. ] |
[1] | 金利霞, 文志敏, 范建红, 杜志威. 乡村空间重构的理论研究进展与理论框架构建[J]. 热带地理, 2020, 40(5): 765-774. |
[2] | 傅沂, 赵子奇. 经济地理学制度理论的发展与建构的重要方向[J]. 热带地理, 2019, 39(5): 711-720. |
[3] | 曹贤忠,曾 刚. 经济地理学视角下创新网络与区域增长研究述评[J]. 热带地理, 2019, 39(3): 472-478. |
[4] | 刘 逸,杨伟聪. 全球生产网络视角下珠三角区域经济的战略耦合与产业升级[J]. 热带地理, 2019, 39(2): 155-169. |
[5] | 陈航航,贺灿飞,毛熙彦. 区域一体化研究综述:尺度、联系与边界[J]. 热带地理, 2018, 38(1): 1-12. |
[6] | 张虹鸥,黄耿志,吴康敏,叶玉瑶,王洋. 中国对外直接投资特征与若干经济地理 研究议题——基于中国对全球与东盟的投资分析 [J]. 热带地理, 2017, 37(4): 443-451. |
[7] | 杨佳意,朱晟君. 产业转移政策对地区产品结构演化的影响 ——基于广东省“双转移”政策的实证分析[J]. 热带地理, 2017, 37(4): 452-461. |
[8] | 唐勇, 覃建雄, 邓贵平, 钟洁. 地震遗迹景观研究进展及其分类方案探讨[J]. 热带地理, 2011, 31(3): 334-338. |
[9] | 李芦松. 旅游交通研究进展及启示[J]. 热带地理, 2009, 29(4): 394-399. |
[10] | 司徒尚纪, LI Ai-jun. 区域军事文化及其景观研究进展[J]. 热带地理, 2008, 28(4): 388-393. |
[11] | 陈子燊. 砂质海岸近岸地形动力过程研究[J]. 热带地理, 2008, 28(3): 242-246. |
[12] | 方远平, 闫小培, 毕斗斗. 1980年以来我国城市商业区位研究述评[J]. 热带地理, 2007, 27(5): 435-440. |
[13] | . 秦至宋时粤北经济与文化概观--对《粤北区域经济地理的历史变迁》的不同意见[J]. 热带地理, 2005, 25(3): 289-封三. |
[14] | 李海东, 司徒尚纪, 薛德升. 粤北区域经济地理的历史变迁[J]. 热带地理, 2003, 23(4): 339-344. |
[15] | 王爱民, 刘加林. 我国人地关系研究进展评述[J]. 热带地理, 2001, 21(4): 364-368,373. |
|