热带地理 ›› 2021, Vol. 41 ›› Issue (6): 1175-1187.doi: 10.13284/j.cnki.rddl.003402
胡志丁1,2,3(), 顾斐菲1(
), 黄艺丹1, 杜德斌1,3
收稿日期:
2021-03-08
修回日期:
2021-05-06
出版日期:
2021-11-05
发布日期:
2021-11-16
通讯作者:
顾斐菲
E-mail:2007@126.com;1678121202@qq.com
作者简介:
胡志丁(1986—),男,江西上饶人,博士生导师,研究员,博士,主要从事全球化与地缘环境研究,(E-mail)huzhiding 2007@126.com;
基金资助:
Zhiding Hu1,2,3(), Feifei Gu1(
), Yidan Huang1, Debin Du1,3
Received:
2021-03-08
Revised:
2021-05-06
Online:
2021-11-05
Published:
2021-11-16
Contact:
Feifei Gu
E-mail:2007@126.com;1678121202@qq.com
摘要:
北极地区历来是相关涉域国家博弈的战略高地。特别是21世纪以来气候变化的影响愈发显著,高度敏感的北极地区正在经历海冰的加速消融,掀起地缘政治学科对其的研究热潮。文章通过梳理Web of Science核心合集数据库中98篇北极地缘政治文献,归纳了西方地缘政治视角下的北极研究发展脉络、视角转向和热点议题,并展望未来北极地缘政治研究的发展趋势。结果发现:1)西方学界对北极地缘政治的研究领域广泛,主题丰富,研究规模总体上呈现波动增长态势;2)西方的北极地缘政治研究涵盖了古典、批判、流行、女性主义等多元地缘政治视角,研究内容以政治、经济为主,地缘政治文化研究相对匮乏;3)地缘政治、经济、文化视角的交叉融合趋势愈发明显;4)未来北极地区地缘政治研究将在理论框架研究、跨学科研究和情感文化等非物质领域产生新的研究思路与方向。
中图分类号:
胡志丁, 顾斐菲, 黄艺丹, 杜德斌. 西方地缘政治视角下北极地区研究进展与展望[J]. 热带地理, 2021, 41(6): 1175-1187.
Zhiding Hu, Feifei Gu, Yidan Huang, Debin Du. Progress and Prospects of Western Geopolitical Research in the Arctic Region[J]. Tropical Geography, 2021, 41(6): 1175-1187.
Arruda G M. 2015. Arctic Governance Regime: the Last Frontier for Hydrocarbons Exploitation. International Journal of Law & Management, 57(5): 498-521. | |
Babin J and Lasserre F. 2019. Asian States at the Arctic Council: Perceptions in Western States. Polar Geography, 42(3): 145-159. | |
Baker J S and Byers M. 2012. Crossed Lines: The Curious Case of the Beaufort Sea Maritime Boundary Dispute. Ocean Development & International Law, 43(1): 70-95. | |
Bennett M M. 2015. How China Sees the Arctic: Reading between Extraregional and Intraregional Narratives. Geopolitics, 20(3): 645-668. | |
Bohr J. 2020. Reporting on Climate Change: A Computational Analysis of U.S. Newspapers and Sources of Bias, 1997–2017. Global Environmental Change, 61: 102038. DOI: 10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2020.102038. | |
Borgerson S, Treadwell M and Williams M. 2008. The Arctic: United States Policy Opportunities & Challenges in a Dynamically Changing Region. Politics & Policy, 36(6): 1147. DOI: 10.1111/j.1747-1346.2008.00157_3.x. | |
Borgerson S. 2013. The Coming Arctic Boom: as Ice Melts, the Region Heats Up. Foreign Affairs, 92(4): 76, 78-89. | |
Brosnan I G, Leschine T M and Miles E L. 2011. Cooperation or Conflict in a Changing Arctic? . Ocean Development and International Law, 42(1/2): 173-210. | |
Brutschin E and Schubert S R. 2016. Icy Waters, Hot Tempers, and High Stakes: Geopolitics and Geoeconomics of the Arctic. Energy Research & Social Science, 16: 147-159. | |
Camilla T N Sørensen and Ekaterina Klimenko. 2017. Emerging Chinese-Russian Cooperation in the Arctic: Possibilities and Constraints. (2017-06-15) [2021-04-25]. https://www.sipri.org/sites/default/files/2017-06/emerging-chinese-russian-cooperation-arctic.pdf. | |
初冬梅. 2019. 俄罗斯北极政策:“创新探索的边疆”与“国家利益的前沿”. 当代世界,(12):71-76. [Chu Dongmei. 2019. Russia's Policy on North Pole: "a Border of Innovation and Exploration" and "a Front of National Interest". Contemporary World, (12): 71-76. ] | |
Dalaklis D, Drewniak M L and Schröder-Hinrichs J. 2018. Shipping Operations Support in the 'High North': Examining Availability of Icebreakers along the Northern Sea Route. Wmu Journal of Maritime Affairs, 17(2): 129-147. | |
Dalby S. 2019. Canadian Geopolitical Culture: Climate Change and Sustainability. The Canadian Geographer, 63(1): 100-111. DOI: 10.1111/cag.12472. | |
Depledge D, Dodds K and Kennedy-Pipe C. 2019. The UK's Defence Arctic Strategy. Rusi Journal, 164(1): 28-39. | |
Dittmer J, Moisio S, Ingram A and Dodds K. 2011. Have you Heard the One about the Disappearing Ice? Recasting Arctic Geopolitics. Political Geography, 30(4): 202-214. | |
Dodds K. 2010a. A Polar Mediterranean? Accessibility, Resources and Sovereignty in the Arctic Ocean. Global Policy, 1(3): 303-311. | |
Dodds K. 2010b. Flag Planting and Finger Pointing: The Law of the Sea, the Arctic and the Political Geographies of the Outer Continental Shelf . Political Geography, 29(2): 63-73. | |
Dodds K. 2012. Graduated and Paternal Sovereignty: Stephen Harper, Operation Nanook 10, and the Canadian Arctic. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space, 30: 989-1010. | |
Dodds K. 2019. Geopolitics and Ice Humanities: Elemental, Metaphorical and Volumetric Reverberations. Geopolitics, (3) : 1121-1149. DOI: 10.1080/14650045.2019.1697240. | |
Dowler L and Sharp J. 2001. A Feminist Geopolitics?. Space and Polity, 5(3): 165-176. | |
Drewniak M, Dalaklis D, Kitada M, Ölçer A and Ballini F. 2018. Geopolitics of Arctic Shipping: the State of Icebreakers and Future Needs. Polar Geography, 41(2): 1-19. | |
杜德斌,秦大河,马亚华,杨文龙,夏启繁. 2020. 冰冻圈地缘政治时代的到来. 中国科学院院刊,35(4):514-522. [Du Debin, Qin Dahe, Ma Yahua, Yang Wenlong and Xia Qifan. 2020. The Age of Cryopolitics is Coming. S&T and Society, 35(4): 514-522. ] | |
Duncan D. 2013. Emerging UK Arctic policy. International Affairs, 89(6): 1445-1457. | |
Ebinger C K and Zambetakis E. 2009. The Geopolitics of Arctic Melt. International Affairs, 85(6): 1215-1232. | |
Farish M. 2006. Frontier Engineering: from the Globe to the Body in the Cold War Arctic. Canadian Geographer/Le Géographe Canadien, 50(2): 177-196. | |
Granberg A G. 1998. The Northern Sea Route: Trends and Prospects of Commercial Use. Ocean & Coastal Management, 41: 175-207. | |
Hansen-Magnusson H. 2019. Arctic Geopoetics: Russian Politics at the North Pole. Cooperation and Conflict, 54(4): 466-487. | |
何奇松. 2010. 气候变化与北极地缘政治博弈. 外交评论(外交学院学报),27(5):113-122. [He Qisong. 2010. Climate Change and Arctic Geopolitics Game. Foreign Affairs Review, 27(5): 113-122. ] | |
Heininen L and Finger M. 2017. The "Global Arctic" as a New Geopolitical Context and Method. Journal of Borderlands Studies, 33(2): 199-202. DOI: 10.1080/08865655.2017.1315605. | |
Heininen L and Nicol H N. 2007. The Importance of Northern Dimension Foreign Policies in the Geopolitics of the Circumpolar North. Geopolitics, 12(1): 133-165. | |
Hong N. 2012. The Energy Factor in the Arctic Dispute: a Pathway to Conflict or Cooperation?. Journal of World Energy, Law & Business, 5(1): 13-26. | |
胡志丁,陆大道. 2015. 基于批判地缘政治学视角解读经典地缘政治理论. 地理学报,70(6):851-863. [Hu Zhiding and Lu Dadao. 2015. The Re-Interpretation of the Classical Geopolitical Theories from a Critical Geopolitical Perspective. Acta Geographica Sinica, 70(6): 851-863. ] | |
胡志丁,李钰华 ,王学文,廉成. 2020. 西方流行地缘政治研究进展与展望. 地理研究,39(7):1463-1477. [Hu Zhiding, Li Yuhua, Wang Xuewen and Lian Cheng. 2020. The Research Progress and Prospect of Popular Geopolitics in the West. Geographical Research, 39(7): 1463-1477. ] | |
Huebert R. 2018. Drawing Boundaries in the Beaufort Sea: Different Visions/Different Needs. Journal of Borderlands Studies, 33(2): 203-223. | |
Hyndman J. 2001. Towards a Feminist Geopolitics. Canadian Geographer, 45: 210-222. | |
James M. 2013. Identity Politics and the Russia-Canada Continental Shelf Dispute: An Impediment to Cooperation?. Geopolitics, 18(1): 60-76. | |
Jeffers J. 2010. Climate Change and the Arctic: Adapting to Changes in Fisheries Stocks and Governance Regimes. Ecology Law Quarterly, 37(3): 917-977. | |
Johannsdottir L and Cook D. 2017. Discourse Analysis of the 2013-2016 Arctic Circle Assembly Programmes. Polar Record, 53(3): 1-4. | |
Johnson L. 2010. The Fearful Symmetry of Arctic Climate Change: Accumulation by Degradation. Environment & Planning D Society & Space, 28(5): 828-847. | |
Jones A and Clark J. 2019. Performance, Emotions, and Diplomacy in the United Nations Assemblage in New York. Annals of the American Association of Geographers, 109(4): 1262-1278. | |
Kapyla J and Mikkola H. 2016. The Promise of the Geoeconomic Arctic: A Critical Analysis . Asia Europe Journal, 14(2): 203-220. | |
Keil K. 2014. The Arctic: A New Region of Conflict? The Case of Oil and Gas. Cooperation and Conflict, 49(2): 162-190. | |
Khrushcheva O and Poberezhskaya M. 2016. The Arctic in the Political Discourse of Russian Leaders: the National Pride and Economic Ambitions. East European Politics, 32(4): 187-218. DOI: 10.1080/21599165.2016.1231669. | |
Konyshev V and Sergunin A. 2012. The Arctic at the Crossroads of Geopolitical Interests. Russian Politics and Law, 50(2): 34-54. | |
Kovalev S and Gainutdinova L. 2012. Opening Up the Arctic. Russian Politics & Law, 50(2): 78-87. | |
朗斐德,罗史凡,林挺生. 2012. 加拿大面对的北极挑战:主权、安全与认同. 国际展望,(2):118-132,136-137. [Lasserre F, Roussel S and Lin Tingsheng. 2012. Canada’s Arctic Challenges: Sovereignty, Security and Identity. Global Review, (2):118-132, 136-137. ] | |
Laruelle M. 2012. Larger, Higher, Farther North … Geographical Metanarratives of the Nation in Russia. Eurasian Geography & Economics, 53(5): 557-574. | |
李振福. 2010. 北极航线地缘政治的复杂网络特征研究. 港口经济,(1):29-32. [Li Zhenfu. 2010. Study on the Complex Network Characteristics of Arctic Route Geopolitics. Port Economy, (1): 29-32. ] | |
李振福,吴玲玲. 2016. 交通政治视角下“一带一路”及北极航线与中国的地缘政治地位. 东疆学刊,33(1):55-61,112. [Li Zhenfu and Wu Lingling. 2016. The "Belt and Road" and the Arctic Route's Promotion to China's Geopolitical Position from the Traffic Political Perspective. Dongjiang Journal, 33(1): 55-61, 112. ] | |
陆大道,杜德斌. 2013. 关于加强地缘政治地缘经济研究的思考. 地理学报,68(6):723-727. [Lu Dadao and Du Debin. 2013. Some Thoughts on the Strengthening of Geopolitical and Geo-Economic Studies. Acta Geographica Sinica, 68(6): 723-727. ] | |
卢静. 2016. 北极治理困境与协同治理路径探析. 国际问题研究,(5):62-76. [Lu Jing. 2016. An Analysis of the Governance Dilemma and the Path of Collaborative Governance in the Arctic. International Studies, (5): 62-76. ] | |
Lundestad I and Tunsjo O. 2015. The United States and China in the Arctic. Polar Record, 51(4): 392-403. | |
Margaret B. 2012. Geopolitics and the Northern Sea Route. International Affairs, 88(1): 115-129. | |
Matishov G G and Dzhenyuk S L. 2012. Arctic Challenges and Problems of Polar Science. Herald of the Russian Academy of Sciences, 82(5): 355-362. | |
Medby I A. 2018. Articulating State Identity: 'Peopling' the Arctic State. Political Geography, 62: 116-125. | |
Medby I A. 2019a. State Discourses of Indigenous "Inclusion": Identity and Representation in the Arctic. Antipode, 51(4): 1276-1295. | |
Medby I A. 2019b. Language-Games, Geography, and Making Sense of the Arctic. Geoforum, 107: 124-133. | |
Misund O A. 2017. Academia in Svalbard: an Increasingly Important Role for Research and Education as Tools for Norwegian Policy. Polar Research, 36(1): 1308131. DOI: 10.1080/17518369. 2017.1308131. | |
Nicol H N and Heininen L. 2014. Human Security, the Arctic Council and Climate Change: Competition or Co-Existence?. Polar Record, 50(252): 80-85. | |
Nicol H N. 2010. Reframing Sovereignty: Indigenous Peoples and Arctic States. Political Geography, 29(2): 78-80. | |
Nyman E, Galvao C B, Mileski J and Tiller R. 2020. The Svalbard Archipelago: an Exploratory Analysis of Port Investment in the Context of the New Arctic Routes. Maritime Studies, 19: 1-13. | |
Raspotnik A and Østhagen A. 2019. What about the Arctic? The European Union's Geopolitical Quest for Northern Space. Geopolitics, 26(4): 1150-1174. DOI: 10.1080/14650045.2019. 1670643. | |
Roberts P and Paglia E. 2016. Science as National Belonging: The Construction of Svalbard as a Norwegian Space. Social Studies of Science, 46(6): 894-911. | |
Roucek J S. 1983. The Geopolitics of the Arctic. American Journal of Economics & Sociology, 42(4): 463-471. | |
Rowe E W and Blakkisrud H. 2014. A New Kind of Arctic Power? Russia's Policy Discourses and Diplomatic Practices in the Circumpolar North. Geopolitics, 19(1): 66-85. | |
Rowe E W. 2020. Analyzing Frenemies: An Arctic Repertoire of Cooperation and Rivalry. Political Geography, 76: 102072. DOI: 10.1016/j.polgeo.2019.102072. | |
阮建平. 2019. “地缘竞争”与“区域合作”:美国对“一带一路”倡议的地缘挑战与中国的应对思考. 太平洋学报,27(12):43-53. [Ruan Jianping. 2019. Geo-Competition vs. Regional Cooperation: Challenge from America against the Belt and Road Initiative and China's Countermeasure. Pacific Journal, 27(12): 43-53. ] | |
Schach M and Madlener R. 2018. Impacts of an Ice-Free Northeast Passage on LNG Markets and Geopolitics. SSRN Electronic Journal, 122: 438-448. | |
Scopelliti M and Conde Pérez Elena. 2016. Defining Security in a Changing Arctic: Helping to Prevent an Arctic Security Dilemma. Polar Record, 52(6): 672-679. | |
Sergunin A and Konyshev V. 2017. Russian Military Strategies in the Arctic: Change or Continuity?. European Security, 26(2): 171-189. | |
宋涛,陆大道,梁宜,王倩. 2016. 近20年国际地缘政治学的研究进展. 地理学报,71(4):551-563. [Song Tao, Lu Dadao, Liang Yi and Wang Qian. 2016. Research Progress of International Geopolitics, 1996-2015. Acta Geographica Sinica, 71(4): 551-563. ] | |
USGS. 2012. An Estimate of Undiscovered Conventional: Oil and Gas Resources of the World, 2012. (2012-03-15) [2020-06-28]. https://pubs.usgs.gov/fs/2012/3042/fs2012-3042.pdf. | |
王晨光. 2020. 意大利北极战略:动因、举措及前景. 边界与海洋研究,5(1):72-84. [Wang Chenguang. 2020. Italian Arctic Strategy: Motivation, Measures and Prospects. Boundary and Ocean Studies, 5(1): 72-84. ] | |
王礼茂,牟初夫,陆大道. 2016. 地缘政治演变驱动力变化与地缘政治学研究新趋势. 地理研究,35(1):3-13. [Wang Limao, Mou Chufu and Lu Dadao. 2016. Changes in Driving Forces of Geopolitical Evolution and the New Trends in Geopolitics Studies. Geographical Research, 35(1): 3-13. ] | |
王文涛,刘燕华,于宏源. 2014. 全球气候变化与能源安全的地缘政治. 地理学报,69(9):1259-1267. [Wang Wentao, Liu Yanhua and Yu Hongyuan. 2014. The Geopolitical Pattern of Global Climate Change and Energy Security Issues. Acta Geographica Sinica, 69(9): 1259-1267. ] | |
Wegge N and Keil K. 2018. Between Classical and Critical Geopolitics in a Changing Arctic. Polar Geography, 41(2): 87-106. | |
Woon C Y. 2020. Framing the "Polar Silk Road": Critical Geopolitics, Chinese Scholars and the (Re)Positionings of China's Arctic Interests. Political Geography, 78: 102141. DOI: 10.1016/j.polgeo.2019.102141. | |
肖洋. 2012. 北冰洋航运权益博弈:中国的战略定位与应对. 和平与发展,(3):42-47,70-71. [Xiao Yang. 2012. Gamesmanship for Shipping Rights and Interests on the Arctic: China's Strategic Position and Responses. Peace and Development, (3): 42-47, 70-71. ] | |
闫鑫淇,赵宁宁. 2021. 批判地缘政治学视角下原住民组织对北极事务的参与和影响——以因纽特环北极理事会为例. 世界地理研究,30(1):57-68. [Yan Xinqi and Zhao Ningning. 2021. The Participation and Influence of Indigenous Organizations in Arctic Affairs from the Perspective of Critical Political Geography: A Case of Inuit Circumpolar Council. World Regional Studies, 30(1): 57-68. ] | |
叶滨鸿,程杨,王利,杨林生. 2019. 北极地区地缘关系研究综述. 地理科学进展,38(4):489-505. [Ye Binhong, Cheng Yang, Wang Li and Yang Linsheng. 2019. A Systematic Review on Geo-Relations Research in the Arctic. Progress in Geography, 38(4): 489-505. ] | |
叶江. 2013. 试论北极事务中地缘政治理论与治理理论的双重影响. 国际观察,(2):32-38. [Ye Jiang. 2013. On the Dual Influence of Geopolitical Theory and Governance Theory in Arctic Affairs. International Observers, (2): 32-38. ] | |
Young O R. 2019. Is It Time for a Reset in Arctic Governance?. Sustainability, 11(16): 4497. DOI: 10.3390/su11164497. | |
张光新,张晶. 2018. 地缘政治视阈下日本的北极战略. 东北亚学刊,(2):26-30,54. [Zhang Guangxin and Zhang Jing. 2018. Japan's Arctic Strategy from a Geopolitical Perspective. Journal of Northeast Asia Studies, (2): 26-30, 54. ] |
[1] | 袁广盛, 安宁. 浅析话语分析方法在地缘环境解析中的应用[J]. 热带地理, 2021, 41(6): 1132-1141. |
[2] | 李鹏, 姚路超, 林郁倩, 封丹. 西方情感地缘政治研究进展[J]. 热带地理, 2021, 41(6): 1166-1174. |
[3] | 温飞, 游爱华, 薛积彬. 过去2 000年中国东南地区气温与降水的集成重建与分析[J]. 热带地理, 2021, 41(4): 778-789. |
[4] | 王小军, 刘光旭, 肖彤. 气候变化情景下油茶生长的适宜性特征[J]. 热带地理, 2020, 40(5): 868-880. |
[5] | 李灿松, 胡平平, 杨旺舟. 缅北局势及其对中缅经济走廊建设的影响[J]. 热带地理, 2019, 39(6): 823-832. |
[6] | 刘云刚, 宋宗员. 旅游地缘政治研究进展与展望[J]. 热带地理, 2019, 39(6): 931-941. |
[7] | 胡志丁, 王学文. 大国地缘战略交汇区的时空演变:特征、规律及其原因[J]. 热带地理, 2019, 39(6): 833-843. |
[8] | 张学珍,许越,李侠祥,张丽娟. 1950—2014年印度粮食单产对气候变化的响应[J]. 热带地理, 2018, 38(6): 828-835. |
[9] | 万智巍,贾玉连,蒋梅鑫. 华南北热带11.5―2.5 ka B.P. 温度集成重建与特征分析[J]. 热带地理, 2018, 38(5): 641-650. |
[10] | 李悦佳,贺新光,卢希安,谭子芳. 1960―2015年长江流域风速的时空变化特征[J]. 热带地理, 2018, 38(5): 660-667. |
[11] | 刘筱,王铮. 全球气候治理的伦理学讨论[J]. 热带地理, 2018, 38(4): 498-503. |
[12] | 董林垚,喻志强,徐金鑫. 地温示踪地表暖化过程中的气候变化和城市热岛效应[J]. 热带地理, 2018, 38(2): 236-243. |
[13] | 李嘉琪,白爱娟,蔡亲波. 西沙群岛和涠洲岛气候变化特征 及其与近岸陆地的对比 [J]. 热带地理, 2018, 38(1): 72-81. |
[14] | 王倩,宋涛,梁宜,邹嘉龄. 东盟与大国贸易联系及其影响因素[J]. 热带地理, 2017, 37(6): 852-861. |
[15] | 田 贺,梁 迅,黎 夏,刘小平,欧金沛,洪 晔,何执兼. 基于SD模型的中国2010―2050年 土地利用变化情景模拟 [J]. 热带地理, 2017, 37(4): 547-561. |
|