谁的遗产？——元阳梯田旅游经营者遗产认同比较

doi:10.13284/j.cnki.rddl.002868

Abstract

Abstract:

In order to discuss the basic question, “whose heritage”, from the perspective of heritage identity dissonance, this paper collects network text, images and field interviews of the Inn operators in Yuanyang terraces area, and then with the discourse analysis compares the differences between the heritage identities of the local and nonlocal operators. The findings show that the interpretation and communication of heritage for the middle class of nonlocal operators are diversified, cross-cultural and petty. They attach great importance to the heritage display and spreading, and consider that the heritage is “theirs”. But to the scale of “home” and local “place” they do not think the heritage area is their home and just regard themselves as outsiders. To the scale of nation and world, they believe that the heritage belongs to “our human beings”. Instead, the negative attitude toward the farmer identity of local operators leads to their heritage landscape elements being abandoned and hidden. However, to meet their need of tourism benefits, some local operators begin to be aware of the heritage display. Therefore, the heritage is not “ours” in the eyes of the farmers. But to the scale of “home” and “place”, the local operators believe the heritage is “ours” and worthy of attachment. Otherwise, they have no salient cognition of the scale of nation and world. Based on the above, the paper has some discusses about heritage protection and management.

Key words: the nonlocal tourism operator, the local tourism operator, identity, heritage identity

QU Ce，ZHANG Chaozhi. Whose Heritage?—A Comparison between Nonlocal and Local Tourism Business’s Heritage Identities in the Yuanyang Terraces Area[J].TROPICAL GEOGRAPHY, 2016, 36(4): 524-531.

References

[1] TUNBRIDGE J E，ASHWORTH G J．Dissonant heritage：the management of the past as a resource in conflict[M]．Chichester：John Wiley & Sons，1996：4-22．

[2] GRAHAM B，ASHWORTH G J，TUNBRIDGE J E．A geography of heritage：Power，culture，and economy[M]．Arnold： Oxford University Press，2000：13．

[3] SMITH L．Uses of heritage[M]．NewYork： Routledge，2006：87-113．

[4] SMITH L．Heritage，gender and identity[M]//GRAHAM B，HOWARD P．The Ashgate Research Companion to Heritage and Identity．Aldershot：Ashgate Publishing，2008：159-178．

[5] TUCKER H，CARNEGIE E．World heritage and the contradictions of ‘universal value’[J]．Annals of Tourism Research，2014，47：63-76．

[6] WATERTON E．Whose sense of place? Reconciling archaeological perspectives with community values：cultural landscapes in England [J]．International Journal of Heritage Studies，2005，11（4）：309-325．

[7] WATERTON E，SMITH L，CAMPBELL G．The utility of discourse analysis to heritage studies：The Burra Charter and social inclusion [J]．International Journal of Heritage Studies，2006，12（4）：339-355．

[8] WATERTON E，SMITH L．The recognition and misrecognition of community heritage[J]．International Journal of Heritage Studies，2010，16（1/2）：4-15．

[9] WATSON S，WATERTON E．Heritage and community engagement [J]．International Journal of Heritage Studies，2010，16（1/2）：1-3．

[10] CROOKE E．The politics of community heritage：motivations，authority and control[J]．International Journal of Heritage Studies，2010，16（1/2）：16-29．

[11] MYDLAND L，GRAHN W．Identifying heritage values in local communities[J]．International Journal of Heritage Studies，2012，18（6）：564-587．

[12] 季中扬．非物质文化遗产空间保护与文化认同困境[J]．江苏社会科学，2013（5）：197-201．

[13] 谢立中．多元话语分析：社会分析模式的新尝试[J]．社会，2010（2）：1-19．

[14] 詹姆斯·保罗·吉．话语分析导论[M]．杨炳钧，译．重庆：重庆大学出版社，2011：3-21．

[15] GRAHAM B，HOWARD P．The Ashgate research companion to heritage and identity[M]．New York：Routledge，2008：2-13．

[16] 金艳．媒体服饰话语中身份认同的建构与消解：《时装》杂志三十年服饰话语研究[D]．武汉：华中科技大学，2009．

[17] 麦肯奈尔．旅游者：休闲阶层新论[M]．张晓萍，译．桂林：广西师范大学出版社，2008：101-122．

Whose Heritage?—A Comparison between Nonlocal and Local Tourism Business’s Heritage Identities in the Yuanyang Terraces Area

PDF (PC)

Like

Knowledge

Abstract

Cite this article

share this article

References

Related Articles 14

Metrics

Comments

Recommended 0

[1]	Fei Li, Jigang Ma, Xianghui Liu. Residents' Perceived and Expected Value of Linear Cultural Heritage: The Example of the Yunnan-Vietnam Railway [J]. Tropical Geography, 2021, 41(1): 93-103.
[2]	Zhang Lingyu, Ye Haowei, An Ning. Hong Kong’s Cultural Identity from a Literary Geography Perspective [J]. Tropical Geography, 2019, 39(6): 880-888.
[3]	Liu Yungang, Song Zongyuan. Progress and Trends in Tourism Geopolitics [J]. Tropical Geography, 2019, 39(6): 931-941.
[4]	Chen Pinyu, Li Luqi. Region Building: The Policy and Strategy Response of Foshan Integrating into the Construction of Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Greater Bay Area [J]. Tropical Geography, 2019, 39(5): 625-634.
[5]	He Yinchun, Liang Yue, Zeng Bindan. The Connotation and Formation Path of Heritage Identity in the Process of Heritagization: A Case Study of the Laosicheng World Heritage, Yongshun [J]. Tropical Geography, 2019, 39(5): 749-758.
[6]	Zhang Longlong, Lao Yingyi, Cheng Guoyu and Wang Min. Geographical Imagination and the Construction of Place Significance under the Transformation of Industrial Landscape: A Case Study of Guanggang New Town, Guangzhou [J]. TROPICAL GEOGRAPHY, 2019, 39(1): 99-107.
[7]	GUO Wenlu，ZHONG Saixiang，LIU Yanfang and YANG Yuying. Exploring the Dimensions of University Students’ Place Identity Based on Grounded Theory and the Exploratory Factor Analysis Method：A Case Study of Wuhan University [J]. TROPICAL GEOGRAPHY, 2018, 38(5): 726-736.
[8]	YAO Huasong，HUANG Gengzhi，FENG Shanfu，CHEN Zaiqi and GUO Yan. Paths to Rural Governance Based on Cultural Identity and Participatory Capacity： A Social Practice of a Village in East Hubei [J]. TROPICAL GEOGRAPHY, 2018, 38(3): 405-412.
[9]	LIN Geng，CHEN Xiaoxuan，YANG Fan. Impacts of Festivals on Community Reconstruction in the Context of Modernity [J]. TROPICAL GEOGRAPHY, 2018, 38(2): 166-175.
[10]	KONG Xiang，ZHUO Fangyong，MIAO Changsong. Influence of Tourism Development on Traditional Local Culture Preservation： Based on the Field Work in Hongcun, Chengkan and Xucun Villages [J]. TROPICAL GEOGRAPHY, 2016, 36(2): 216-224.
[11]	WU Limin，HUANG Zhenfang，WANG Kun，ZHANG Chen. Review of the Research on Place Attachment in Tourist Destination both at Home and Abroad [J]. TROPICAL GEOGRAPHY, 2015, 35(2): 275-283.
[12]	DU Fangjuan，YUAN Zhenjie2. Ethnic Identity and Placeness of Gelao Minority in the Longtan Village, Wuchuan County [J]. TROPICAL GEOGRAPHY, 2014, 34(4): 438-444.
[13]	HUANG Jialing，HE Shenjing. Profile and Determinants of African Immigrants’ Sense of Place in Religious Space: A Case Study of Guangzhou Sacred Heart Cathedral [J]. TROPICAL GEOGRAPHY, 2014, 34(3): 308-318.
[14]	ZUO Bing，ZHOU Dongying. Interpretation and National Identity Constructing in the Whampoa Military Academy Memorial: An Effectiveness Assessment Based on SEM [J]. TROPICAL GEOGRAPHY, 2014, 34(2): 209-216.