Tropical Geography ›› 2022, Vol. 42 ›› Issue (8): 1314-1323.doi: 10.13284/j.cnki.rddl.003534
Previous Articles Next Articles
Received:
2021-07-26
Revised:
2021-11-17
Online:
2022-08-05
Published:
2022-08-24
Contact:
Kai Zhou
E-mail:daiyangui_19a@foxmail.com;zhoukai_nju@hotmail.com
CLC Number:
Yangui Dai, Kai Zhou. The Conceptual Framework and a Comparative Study of "the Right to the Village" in the Search for Spatial Justice[J].Tropical Geography, 2022, 42(8): 1314-1323.
Table 1
similarity and differences of the cases of Global South and Global North
案例 | 被迫非农化 | 自发再农化 | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
特征 | 共性 | 特征 | 差异 | |||
南 方 国 家 | 突尼斯 雷格布地区 | 传统农耕生产和非正规交易活动受到资本家、腐败政客的阻拦。 | 本质上都是受资本剥削后引发的非正义现象。 | 法律诉讼;自焚;游街。 | 村民个人或集体主要采取法律途径或极端方式。 | |
印度 那格浦尔地区 | 土地补偿的不公正和搬迁后的非农化生活。 | 法律诉讼。 | ||||
黎巴嫩 西奈村 | 难以负担起高额的土地租售价格,被迫选择进城务工。 | 法律诉讼;与地主和外来土地投机者谈判;动用武力。 | ||||
北 方 国 家 | 英国 赫特福德郡和达特穆尔国家公园 | 城市人口的进入和本地村民的流离失所。 | 成立社区土地信托。 | 国家政策的支持和村民集体能力的发挥。 | ||
法国 荒地圣母镇 | 村庄土地和生态保护区被大型项目占用。 | 利用科学知识、集体实践、哲学话语等方式。 | ||||
意大利 贾拉塔纳村 | 农业现代化对传统农耕生产模式的“挤压”。 | 多样化种植;建立市场和知识网络。 |
Barraclough L. 2013. Is There Also a Right to the Countryside?. Antipode, 45(5): 1047-1049. | |
Bautès N and Gonçalves R S. 2011. Improving Security in Poor Areas: Public Security and Spatial Justice in the Favelas of Rio de Janeiro. Justice Spatiale/Spatial Justice, (4). [2021-06-30]. https://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs-01518884. | |
Boughzala M and Hamdi M T. 2014. Promoting Inclusive Growth in Arab Countries: Rural and Regional Development and Inequality in Tunisia. Washington: Brookings Institution Press. | |
包亚明. 2003. 现代性与空间的生产. 上海:上海教育出版社. | |
Bao Yaming. 2003. Modernity and Space Production. Shanghai: Shanghai Educational Publishing House. | |
Cabalion J. 2013. Les Dimensions d'une Mobilité Socio-Spatiale Forcée en Inde Centrale. Regards Sociologiques, (45/46): 153-174. | |
Cabalion J. 2014. La Question Sociale de la Dépossession. Mouvements, (1): 25-33. | |
Cabalion J. 2015. The Value of Peasant Life Nayā Ambhora, a Village of Displaced Persons Incentral India. (2015-01-15) [2021-06-30]. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/272151342_The_value_of_peasant_life_Naya_Ambhora_a_village_of_displaced_persons_in_central_India. | |
Crampton J W and Elden S. 2007. Space, Knowledge and Power: Foucault and Geography. Aldershot: Ashgate. | |
曹诗图. 2017. 旅游开发的正义反思与求索. 旅游学刊,32(4):6-8. | |
Cao Shitu. 2017. Reflection and Exploration on Justice in Tourism Development. Tourism Tribune, 32(4): 6-8. | |
曹现强,张福磊. 2011. 空间正义:形成、内涵及意义. 城市发展研究,18(4):125-129. | |
Cao Xianqiang and Zhang Fulei. 2011. Spatial Justice: Context, Development and Connotation. Urban Development Studies, 18(4): 125-129. | |
曹现强,朱明艺. 2014. 城市化进程中的城乡空间正义思考. 理论探讨,(1):139-144. | |
Cao Xianqiang and Zhu Mingyi. 2014. Thoughts on Urban and Rural Spatial Justice in the Process of Urbanization. Theoretical Investigation, (1): 139-144. | |
陈昭. 2020. 基本福利的空间再分配:试论实践性空间正义及其规划应对. 国际城市规划, 36(4):73-81. | |
Chen Zhao. 2020. Spatial Redistribution of Fundamental Welfare: Hypothesis of the Practical Spatial Justice and Its Planning Implications. Urban Planning International, 36(4): 73-81. | |
陈志永,杨桂华,陈继军,李乐京. 2011. 少数民族村寨社区居民对旅游增权感知的空间分异研究——以贵州西江千户苗寨为例. 热带地理,31(2):216-222. | |
Chen Zhiyong, Yang Guihua, Chen Jijun and Li Lejing. 2011. Spatial Variation of the Tourism Empowerment Perception of Ethnic Village Community Residents: A Case Study of Xijiang Qianhu Miao Village in Guizhou. Tropical Geography, 31(2): 216- 222. | |
Da Via E. 2012. Seed Diversity, Farmers' Rights, and the Politics of Re-Peasantization. The International Journal of Sociology of Agriculture and Food, 19(2): 229-242. | |
Dourian T. 2021. New Farmers in the South of Italy: Capturing the Complexity of Contemporary Strategies and Networks. Journal of Rural Studies, 84: 63-75. | |
El Nour S, Gharios C, Mundy M and Zurayk R. 2015. The Right to the Village? Concept and History in a Village of South Lebanon. Justice Spatiale/Spatial Justice, (7). [2021-06-30]. https://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs-01512408. | |
European Network for Rural Development (ENRD). 2018. Smart Villages: Revitalising Rural Services through Social and Digital Innovation. (2018-05-22) [2021-06-30]. https://enrd.ec.europa.eu/sites/default/files/s7_smart-villages_seminar-highlights.pdf. | |
Fautras M. 2015. Land Injustices, Contestations and Community Protest in the Rural Areas of Sidi Bouzid (Tunisia): The Roots of the “Revolution”. Justice Spatiale/Spatial Justice, (7). [2021-06-30]. https://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs-01512398. | |
范建红,莫悠,谢涤湘. 2018. 资本循环视角下的中国城乡转型思考. 热带地理,38(5):699-706. | |
Fan Jianhong, Mo You and Xie Dixiang. 2018. Reflection about the Transformation of Urban and Rural Planning in the View of Capital Circuit Theory. Tropical Geography, 38(5): 699-706. | |
Gharios C, El Nour S, Mundy M and Zurayk R. 2016. Transformation Rurale, Paysage et Conflit Dans un Village du Liban Sud, Sinay. Économie Rurale. Agricultures, Alimentations, Territoires, (353/354): 9-26. | |
龚天平,张军. 2017. 资本空间化与中国城乡空间关系重构——基于空间正义的视角. 上海师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版),46(2):29-36. | |
Gong Tianping and Zhang Jun. 2017. Capital Spatialization and Reconstruction of Spatial Relation between Urban and Rural China: A Perspective of Spatial Justice. Journal of Shanghai Normal University (Philosophy & Social Sciences Edition), 46(2): 29-36. | |
Harvey D. 1973. Social Justice and the City. Oxford: Basil Blackwell. | |
Harvey D. 2012. Rebel Cities: From the Right to the City to the Urban Revolution. London: Verso. | |
何深静,钱俊希,徐雨璇,刘斌. 2012. 快速城市化背景下乡村绅士化的时空演变特征. 地理学报,67(8):1044-1056. | |
He Shenjing, Qian Junxi, Xu Yuxuan and Liu Bin. 2012. Spatial-Temporal Evolution of Rural Gentrification Amidst Rapid Urbanization: A Case Study of Xiaozhou Village, Guangzhou. Acta Geographica Sinica, 67(8): 1044-1056. | |
Jones R, Moisio S, Weckroth M, Woods M, Luukkonen J, Meyer F and Miggelbrink J. 2019. Re-Conceptualising Territorial Cohesion Through the Prism of Spatial Justice: Critical Perspectives on Academic and Policy Discourses. In: Thilo Lang and Judit Timár. Regional and Local Development in Times of Polarisation: Re-Thinking Spatial Policies in Europe. Singapore: Springer Nature, 97-119. | |
Kallio K P and Häkli J. 2017. Geosocial Lives in Topological Polis: Mohamed Bouazizi as a Political Agent. Geopolitics, 22(1): 91-109. | |
Koester S and Davis S. 2018. Siting of Wood Pellet Production Facilities in Environmental Justice Communities in the Southeastern United States. Environmental Justice, 11(2): 64-70. | |
Landy F and Moreau S. 2015. The Right to the Village. Justice Spatiale/Spatial Justice, (7). [2021-06-30]. https://hal.univ-smb.fr/HIPHISCITECH/halshs-01718604. | |
Lefebvre H. 1991. The Production of Space. Oxford: Blackwell. | |
刘辰阳,田宝江,刘忆瑶. 2019. “空间正义”视角下老旧住区公共空间更新实施机制优化研究. 现代城市研究,(12):33-39. | |
Liu Chenyang, Tian Baojiang and Liu Yiyao. 2019. Study on Optimization of Implementation Mechanism of Public Space Renewal in Old Settlements from the Perspective of "Space Justice". Modern Urban Research, (12): 33-39. | |
Méténier M. 2017. Facing Rural Gentrification in Protected Areas of England: Community Land Trusts as Actors of Rural Change. Braunschweig: European Rural Geographies Conference 2017. | |
Nordberg K. 2020. Spatial Justice and Local Capability in Rural Areas. Journal of Rural Studies, 78: 47-58. | |
Pailloux A-L. 2015. Deferred Development Zone (ZAD) Versus "Zone to be Protected": Analysis of a Struggle for Autonomy in/of Rural Space. Justice Spatiale/Spatial Justice, (7). [2021-06-30]. http://hal.cirad.fr/AO-GEOGRAPHIE/halshs-01512403. | |
Phillips M, Smith D, Brooking H and Duer M. 2020. Idyllic Ruralities, Displacement and Changing Forms of Gentrification in Rural Hertfordshire, England. Documents D'AnàLisi GeogràFica, 2(66): 259-287. | |
Podmore J A and Chamberland L. 2015. Entering the Urban Frame: Early Lesbian Activism and Public Space in Montreal. Journal of Lesbian Studies, 19(2): 192-211. | |
Pruvost G. 2017. Critique en Acte de la Vie Quotidienne à la ZAD de Notre-Dame-des-Landes (2013-2014). Politix, (1): 35-62. | |
Renard J and Rialland-Juin C. 2013. Le Projet D'aéroport de Notre-Dame-des-Landes: Les Rebonds d'un Aménagement Conflictuel. (2013-02-04) [2021-06-30]. http://geoconfluences.ens-lyon.fr/doc/territ/FranceMut/FranceMutDoc17.htm. | |
Soja E. 2010. Seeking Spatial Justice. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press. | |
孙萍. 2021. “乡村性”的概念重构——数字时代的淘宝村建构. 社会发展研究,8(1):96-110,243. | |
Sun Ping. 2021. A Reconceptualization of Rurality: An Examination of "Taobao Village" in Digital China. Journal of Social Development, 8(1): 96-110, 243. | |
唐溧,董筱丹. 2019. 乡村振兴中的空间资源利用制度创新——如何弱化“三产融合”中的空间“隐性剥夺”. 探索与争鸣,(12):113-123,159-160. | |
Tang Li and Dong Xiaodan. 2019. Rural Revitalization and Institutional Innovation of Spatial Resources Utilization: How to Weaken the "Hidden Deprivation" of Space in the "Tertiary Industrialization". Exploration and Free Views, (12): 113-123, 159-160. | |
Van der Ploeg J D. 2008. The New Peasantries: Struggles for Autonomy and Sustainability in an Era of Empire and Globalization. London and Sterling, VA: Earthscan. | |
Van der Ploeg J D. 2018. From de-to Repeasantization: The Modernization of Agriculture Revisite. Journal of Rural Studies, 61: 236-243. | |
Woods M. 2011. Developing the Rural. In: Woods M. Rural. London: Routledge, 130-161. | |
王维艳,李宏,沈琼. 2020. 乡村社区旅游空间不正义及其“住改商”制度症结——波兰尼嵌入性视角下的西江苗寨实证研究. 人文地理,35(5):77-84. | |
Wang Weiyan, Li Hong and Shen Qiong. 2020. Spatial Injustice in Rural Community Tourism and the Negative Impacts of the Residential-to-Commercial Conversion System: An Empirical Research on Xijiang Miao Village from the Perspective of Polanyi's Embeddedness. Human Geography, 35(5): 77-84. | |
习近平. 2019. 把乡村振兴战略作为新时代“三农”工作总抓手. 求是,(11):7. | |
Xi Jinping. 2019. Take the Rural Revitalization Strategy as the General Grasp of the "Agriculture,Rural Areas and Farmers"Work in the New Era. Qiushi, (11): 7. | |
杨丽娟,杨培峰. 2020. 空间正义视角下的城市公园:反思、修正、研究框架. 城市发展研究,27(2):38-45. | |
Yang Lijuan and Yang Peifeng. 2020. Urban Parks from the Perspective of Spatial Justice: Reflection, Revision and Research Framework. Urban Development Studies, 27(2): 38-45. | |
叶超. 2019. 空间正义与新型城镇化研究的方法论. 地理研究,38(1):146-154. | |
Ye Chao. 2019. The Methodology on Spatial Justice and New-Type Urbanization. Geographical Research, 38(1): 146-154. | |
张京祥,胡毅. 2012. 基于社会空间正义的转型期中国城市更新批判. 规划师,28(12):5-9. | |
Zhang Jingxiang and Hu Yi. 2012. A Critique on China's Urban Renewal from Social Space Justice Viewpoint. Planners, 28(12): 5-9. | |
赵静华. 2018. 空间正义视角下城乡不平衡发展的治理路径. 理论学刊,(6):124-130. | |
Zhao Jinghua. 2018. Governance Path of Urban and Rural Unbalanced Development from the Perspective of Spatial Justice. Theory Journal, (6): 124-130. | |
朱旭佳. 罗震东. 2018. 从视觉景观生产到乡村振兴:网红村的产生机制与可持续路径研究. 上海城市规划,(6):45-53. | |
Zhu Xujia and Luo Zhendong. 2018. From Spectacle Production to Rural Revitalization: Study on the Formation Mechanism of Web-Star Village and Its Sustainable Development. Shanghai Urban Planning Review, (6): 45-53. |
[1] | Nuoya Zhuang, Ren Yang, Jinfeng Lu, Shixiu Weng. Art Intervention in Rural Areas: Comparative Analysis of Multi-Level Benefits of Two Typical Modes in Rural Development Transformation [J]. Tropical Geography, 2022, 42(3): 396-408. |
[2] | Tao Xu, Ziyang Zhu, Huaxiang Ding, Jianneng Xiao, Yaolong Zhao. The Characteristics of Rural Homestead Housing in Guangdong Province Under the Background of Rural Revitalization [J]. Tropical Geography, 2022, 42(1): 148-159. |
[3] | Lin Zhu, Tielin Wang, Dan Xia. The Identification of County-Level Rural Territorial Function Types and Research on Rural Revitalization Path in Sichuan Province [J]. Tropical Geography, 2021, 41(4): 870-880. |
[4] | Jihong He, Bing Sun, Zhaowan Shi, Shuixing Luo, Xu Wang, Lei Chen, Ying Xiong, Jun Lin, Nancai Pei. Proposing a Conceptual Framework for Ecotourism Based on Pro-Poor Tourism Strategy in Lechang City, Guangdong Province [J]. Tropical Geography, 2021, 41(3): 645-655. |