背包旅行与身份构建:一名已婚女性背包客的自我民族志
孙琼(1984—),女,北京人,教授,博士,主要研究方向为旅游经济与旅游者行为,(E-mail)lytsunqiong@buu.edu.cn; |
收稿日期: 2022-09-03
修回日期: 2022-10-04
网络出版日期: 2023-07-10
基金资助
北京市属高等学校优秀青年人才培育计划项目(BPHR202203211)
北京工商大学数字商科与首都发展创新中心项目(SZSK202237)
北京联合大学校级科研项目(SK10202201)
Backpacking and Identity Construction: Self-Ethnography of a Married Female Backpacker
Received date: 2022-09-03
Revised date: 2022-10-04
Online published: 2023-07-10
文章借用自我民族志的研究方法,讲述了一名已婚女性的背包客旅行之路。研究发现,父母的旅游行为是背包旅行代际传递的主要方式,也是父辈对子女身份构建隐形影响的体现;在传统家庭观念中,已婚女性因其“依附者”角色而被排除在背包客之外,已婚女性背包客之路象征着已婚女性对社会角色刻板印象、文化观念和消费主义的抗争。研究表明,已婚女性背包客身份构建,打破了传统社会角色认知,塑造了新的社会角色特征,发展了背包客身份构建理论。背包客身份的构建不仅发生于与普通旅游者对立的“不同”,也产生于个体对自决的追求。现代背包客可以通过自决,实现对幸福感的追寻,反思消费主义。
孙琼 , 李林 , 黄先开 . 背包旅行与身份构建:一名已婚女性背包客的自我民族志[J]. 热带地理, 2023 , 43(6) : 1199 -1210 . DOI: 10.13284/j.cnki.rddl.003663
The identity construction of a "backpacker" has always been an important topic in research on backpacking. Most current studies analyze the backpacker group as a whole, with insufficient investigation into the differences among different groups. Western scholars found that female and male backpackers had obvious differences in tourism patterns. Considering the different social situations and differences in backpacker' behavior between China and the West, we must examine whether the Western research conclusions are applicable to China. Particularly, married females in China are the core members of the family. Compared with unmarried females, they shoulder more family responsibilities. There is insufficient research on their identity construction as backpackers. This study introduces a married female backpacker's journey through self-ethnography. The study found that parents' travel behavior was the main method of intergenerational transmission of backpacking, and it was also the embodiment of parents' hidden influence on the construction of children's identity. In addition, the will of parents was affected by traditional culture on the cognition of social roles, while the family shouldered the pressure to resist the traditional role concept of society. The disobedience of the owner of the family's power regarding the traditional role norms was a resistance to the traditional power system, which enabled children to break through the social stereotypes and prejudice and practice backpacking. In the traditional family concept, the married female was excluded from backpacking because of their "dependent" role. The path of the married female backpacker ran through the struggle against social role stereotypes, cultural concepts, and consumerism. The research proposed that the breaking of traditional social role cognition and the shaping of new social role characteristics were the important concept origin of the construction of the married female backpacker identity. Meanwhile, it also developed the theory of backpacker identity construction, and argued that the construction of the married female backpacker identity not only occurred in the "difference" against ordinary tourists, but also in the individual's pursuit of self-determination. Through backpacking, in a unique way, the married female could participate in behaviors that reflected their personal interests or values, and had the capability to engage in valuable or challenging behaviors. Thus, they established close ties with others, broke the role shackles under traditional social concepts with their actual behaviors, controlled their travel consumption decisions, integrated into the backpacker group, and shaped new social roles, and then realized the improvement of subjective well-being. Accordingly, modern backpackers are capable of realizing the pursuit of happiness and reflecting on consumerism through self-determination.
孙 琼:研究资料的分析,研究框架的设定,论文撰写与修订;
李 林:进度把控,论文修改与提升;
黄先开:协助文献资料收集,论文修改与提升。
Adkins B, and Grant E. 2007. Backpackers as a Community of Strangers: The Interaction Order of an Online Backpacker Notice Board. Qualitative Sociology Review, 3(2): 188-201.
|
Amaro S, Duarte P, and Henriques C. 2016. Travelers' Use of Social Media: A Clustering Approach. Annals of Tourism Research, 59: 1-15.
|
Anderson L, and Austin M. 2012. Auto-Ethnography in Leisure Studies. Leisure Studies, 31(2): 131-146.
|
芭芭拉·赫吉森. 2005. 女人旅行三百年纪事. 洪世民,译. 北京:人民文学出版社.
Barbara Hodgson. 2005. No Place for a Lady. Hong Shimin, Trans. Beijing: People's Literature Publishing House.
|
蔡晓梅,苏晓波. 2016. 迷失的优雅:广州白天鹅宾馆景观演变中的文化政治. 旅游学刊,31(3):16-25.
Cai Xiaomei, and Su Xiaobo. 2016. Falling from Grace: Cultural Politics and the Changing Landscape of White Swan Hotel, Guangzhou. Tourism Tribune, 31(3): 16-25.
|
Cai W, Cohen S A, and Tribe J. 2019. Harmony Rules in Chinese Backpacker Groups. Annals of Tourism Research, 75: 120-130.
|
Canavan B. 2018. An Existentialist Exploration of Tourism Sustainability: Backpackers Fleeing and Finding Themselves. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 26(4): 551-566.
|
Chang H. 2016a. Autoethnography as Method. New York: Routledge.
|
Chang H, Ngunjiri F, and Hernandez K A C. 2016b. Collaborative Autoethnography. New York: Routledge.
|
陈钢华,师慧敏,赵丽君,黄松山. 2021. 背包客与“众”不同吗?——中国背包客与大众游客核心自我评价比较研究. 旅游学刊,36(10):125-139.
Chen Ganghua, Shi Huimin, Zhao Lijun, and Huang Songshan. 2021. Are Backpackers Unique? A Comparative Analysis of the Core Self-Evaluation between Chinese Backpackers and Mass Tourists. Tourism Tribune, 36(10): 125-139.
|
Chen G, Zhao L, and Huang S. 2020. Backpacker Identity: Scale Development and Validation. Journal of Travel Research, 59(2): 281-294.
|
Cohen E, and Cohen S A. 2015. A Mobilities Approach to Tourism from Emerging World Regions. Current Issues in Tourism, 18(1): 11-43.
|
Cohen S A. 2011. Lifestyle Travellers: Backpacking as a Way of Life. Annals of Tourism Research, 38(4): 1535-1555.
|
Collins-kreiner N, Yonay Y, and Even M. 2018. Backpacking Memories: A Retrospective Approach to the Narratives of Young Backpackers. Tourism Recreation Research, 43(3): 409-412.
|
Currie R R, Campbell-Trant T, and Seaton S. 2011. Joining the In-Crowd: Symbols for Backpacker Identity. International Journal of Culture, Tourism and Hospitality Research, 5(1):47-56.
|
德里达. 2001. 书写与差异. 张宁,译. 北京:三联书店.
Derrida.2001. Writing and Differences.Zhang Ning, Trans. Beijing: Sanlian Bookstore.
|
Dayour F, Kimbu A N, and Park S. 2017. Backpackers: The Need for Reconceptualisation. Annals of Tourism Research, 66: 191-193.
|
DeHaan C R, and Ryan R M. 2014. Symptoms of Wellness: Happiness and Eudaimonia from a Self-Determination Perspective. In: DeHaan C R. Stability of Happiness. New York: Academic Press, 37-55.
|
邓绍秋. 2009. 构建和谐社会与自然生态美育. 湘潭师范学院学报(社会科学版),31(1):1-3.
Deng Shaoqiu. 2009. Construct Harmonious Society and Natural Ecological Aesthetic Education. Journal of Xiangtan Normal University (Social Science Edition), 31(1): 1-3.
|
Ellis C, Adams T E, and Bochner A P. 2011. Autoethnography: An Overview. Historical Social Research, 36(4): 273-290.
|
Elsrud T. 1998. Time Creation in Travelling: The Taking and Making of Time among Women Backpackers. Time & Society, 7(2/3): 309-334.
|
Elsrud T. 2001. Risk Creation in Traveling: Backpacker Adventure Narration. Annals of Tourism Research, 28(3): 597-617.
|
樊友猛. 2020. 旅游具身体验研究进展与展望. 旅游科学,34(1):1-19.
Fan Youmeng. 2020. Research Progress and Prospect on Tourist Embodied Experiences. Tourism Science, 34(1): 1-19.
|
费孝通. 1994. 个人·群体·社会──一生学术历程的自我思考. 北京大学学报(哲学社会科学版),(1):7-17,6,127.
Fei Xiaotong. 1994. Individual, Group, and Society-Reflections on My Life-Long "Pilgrim's Progress" of Learning. Journal of Peking University (Philosophy and Social Sciences), (1): 7-17, 6, 127.
|
郭建斌. 2008. 在场:民族志视角下的电视观看活动——独乡田野资料的再阐释. 传播与社会学刊,(6):193-217.
Guo Jianbin. 2008. Presence: TV Watching Activity from Ethnographic Perspective: Reinterpretation of Field Data in Duxiang. Chinese Journal of Communication and Society, (6): 193-217.
|
He Z, and Hao X. 2022. Emotional Labor and Employee Well-Being in Cross-Cultural Contexts: A Disney Frontline Staff's Autoethnography. Tourism Management, 91: 104518.
|
Hillman W. 1999. Searching for Authenticity in Touristic Experience: Female Backpackers in North Queensland. Townsville: James Cook University.
|
Hindle N, Martin A, and Nash R. 2015. Tourism Development and the Backpacker Market in Highland Scotland. Tourism and Hospitality Research, 15(3): 178-192.
|
胡林. 2017. “新大众旅游”的消费类型及其影响因素分析——以广州女性旅游者为例. 发展改革理论与实践,(9):15-18.
Hu Lin. 2017. Analysis on Consumption Types and Influencing Factors of "New Mass Tourism": A Case Study of Female Tourists in Guangzhou. Journal of Development & Reform, (9): 15-18.
|
解佳,孙九霞. 2020. 自由或自私?都市青年视野中分裂的背包客形象及其成因. 中国青年研究,(1):76-83.
Xie Jia, and Sun Jiuxia. 2020. Free or Selfish? The Split Image of Backpackers in the Vision of Urban Youth and Its Cause. China Youth Study, (1): 76-83.
|
Komppula R, and Gartner W. 2013. Hunting as a Travel Experience: An Auto-Ethnographic Study of Hunting Tourism in Finland and the USA. Tourism Management, 35: 168-180.
|
Larsen S, Øgaard T, and Brun W. 2011. Backpackers and Mainstreamers: Realities and Myths. Annals of Tourism Research, 38(2): 690-707.
|
雷汝霞,吴水田. 2017. 社会性别视角下女大学生背包客的旅游动机研究. 四川旅游学院学报,(3):57-61.
Lei Ruxia, and Wu Shuitian. 2017. A Social Gender Perspective: Motivations of Female College Student Backpackers. Journal of Sichuan Tourism University, (3): 57-61.
|
李超海. 2013. 家务劳动时间、家务决策权与妇女社会地位关系探讨——以第3期广东妇女社会地位调查数据为例. 重庆邮电大学学报(社会科学版),25(4):129-135.
Li Chaohai. 2013. Discussion on Relationship between Housework Time, Housework Decision-Making and Social Status of Women: Based on the Third Phase of the Guangdong Women's Social Status Survey Data. Journal of Chongqing University of Posts and Telecommunications: Social Science Edition, 25(4): 129-135.
|
李方圆,周小虎,张慧. 2022. 意义构建视角下愿景沟通对员工变革承诺的影响机制. 系统管理学报,31(2):290-301.
Li Fangyuan, Zhou Xiaohu, and Zhang Hui. 2022. Mechanisim of Vision-for-Change-Communication on Employees' Commitment to Change from the Perspective of Sensemanking. Journal of Systems & Management, 31(2): 290-301.
|
刘鲁,张静儒,吴必虎,Morrison A M. 2018. 身份认同视角下中国背包客的目的地选择偏好研究. 旅游学刊,33(4):80-89.
Liu Lu, Zhang Jingru, Wu Bihu, and Morrison A M. 2018. The Destination Choice Behavior of Chinese Backpackers: From a Perspective of Identity Theory. Tourism Tribune, 33(4): 80-89.
|
Lopez L, González R C L, and Fernández B M C. 2017. Spiritual Tourism on the Way of Saint James the Current Situation. Tourism Management Perspectives, 24: 225-234.
|
Luo X, Huang S, and Brown G. 2015. Backpacking in China: A Netnographic Analysis of Donkey Friends’ Travel Behaviour. Journal of China Tourism Research, 11(1): 67-84.
|
Maoz D. 2007. Backpackers' Motivations the Role of Culture and Nationality. Annals of Tourism Research, 34(1): 122-140.
|
Miles S. 2019. Immersive Narratives of 'Self-Work' in an Experience Society: Understanding the Cruise Ship Experience. Leisure Studies, 38(1): 1-12.
|
Morrow G R. 1935. Mind, Self, and Society from the Standpoint of a Social Behaviorist. The Philosophical Review, 44(6): 587-589.
|
Muzaini H. 2006. Backpacking Southeast Asia: Strategies of "Looking Local". Annals of Tourism Research, 33(1): 144-161.
|
Noy C. 2004. This Trip Really Changed Me: Backpackers' Narratives of Self-Change. Annals of Tourism Research, 31(1): 78-102.
|
O'Reilly C C. 2005. Tourist or Traveller? Narrating Backpacker Identity. In: Jaworski A, Pritchard A. Discourse, Communication, and Tourism. Clevedon: Channel View, 150-169.
|
Ong C E, and Du Cros H. 2012. The Post-Mao Gazes: Chinese Backpackers in Macau. Annals of Tourism Research, 39(2): 735-754.
|
Ooi N, and Laing J H. 2010. Backpacker Tourism: Sustainable and Purposeful? Investigating the Overlap between Backpacker Tourism and Volunteer Tourism Motivations. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 18(2): 191-206.
|
Park R E, and Burgess E W. 2019. Introduction to the Science of Sociology. Glasgow: Good Press.
|
Pearce P L. 1990. The Backpacker Phenomenon: Preliminary Answers to Basic Questions. Townsville: Department of Tourism, James Cook University of North Queensland.
|
Pearce P L, and Foster F. 2007. A "University of Travel": Backpacker Learning. Tourism Management, 28(5): 1285-1298.
|
Pearce P L, Murphy L, and Brymer E. 2009. Evolution of the Backpacker Market and the Potential for Australian Tourism. Gold Coast, Queensland: CRC for Sustainable Tourism.
|
乔纳森·H·特纳. 1987. 社会学理论的结构. 吴曲辉,译. 杭州:浙江人民出版社.
Jonathan H T. 1987. The Structure of Sociological Theory. Wu Quhui, Trans. Hangzhou: Zhejiang People's Publishing House.
|
Sedikides C, Ntoumanis N, and Sheldon K M. 2019. I am the Chosen One: Narcissism in the Backdrop of Self-Determination Theory. Journal of Personality, 87(1): 70-81.
|
Sharpley R, and Jepson D. 2011. Rural Tourism: A Spiritual Experience?. Annals of Tourism Research, 38(1): 52-71.
|
Song H. 2017. Females and Tourism Activities: An Insight for All-Female Tours in Hong Kong. Journal of China Tourism Research, 13(1): 83-102.
|
Teghe D, and Rendell K. 2005. Social Well-Being: A Literature Review. School of Social Work & Welfare Studies.doi:10.13140/RG.2.2.28891.26406.
|
Teo P, and Leong S. 2006. A Postcolonial Analysis of Backpacking. Annals of Tourism Research, 33(1): 109-131.
|
Tomazos K. 2016. Backpacking through an Ontology of Becoming: A Never-Ending Cycle of Journeys. International Journal of Tourism Research, 18(2): 140-148.
|
Urry J. 2011. The Tourist Gaze 3.0. London: SAGE Publishing Ltd.
|
吴帆. 2014. 相对资源禀赋结构中的女性社会地位与家庭地位——基于第三期中国妇女地位调查数据的分析. 学术研究,(1):42-49.
Wu Fan. 2014. Women's Social Status and Family Status in the Structure of Relative Resource Endowment: An Analysis Based on the Third Chinese Women's Status Survey. Academic Research, (1): 42-49.
|
吴建兴,吴茂英,汪菁. 2022. 自我民族志在旅游研究中应用评析. 旅游学刊,37(2):130-141.
Wu Jianxing, Wu Maoying, and Wang Jing. 2022. Auto-Ethnography in Tourism Research: A Perspective Paper. Tourism Tribune, 37(2): 130-141.
|
奚从清. 2010. 角色论:个人与社会的互动. 杭州:浙江大学出版社.
Xi Congqing. 2010. On Person Roles: The Mutual Interaction between an Individual and Society. Hangzhou: Zhejiang University Press.
|
Xu W, and Zhang X. 2021. Online Expression as Well-Be (com) ing: A Study of Travel Blogs on Nepal by Chinese Female Tourists. Tourism Management, 83: 104224.
|
杨菊华,何炤华. 2014. 社会转型过程中家庭的变迁与延续. 人口研究,38(2):36-51.
Yang Juhua, and He Zhaohua. 2014. Continuity or Change? Chinese Family in Transitional Era. Population Research, 38(2): 36-51.
|
姚延波,贾广美. 2021. 社交媒体旅游分享对潜在旅游者冲动性旅游意愿的影响研究:基于临场感视角. 南开管理评论,24(3):72-82.
Yao Yanbo, and Jia Guangmei. 2021. The Effect of Social Media Travel Experience Sharing on Potential Tourists' Impulsive Travel Intention: Based on Presence Perspective. Nankai Business Review, 24(3): 72-82.
|
易伟芳. 2015. 角色理论下的中国女性媒介角色形象研究. 北京:中国青年政治学院.
Yi Weifang. 2015. Research on Media Role Image of China's Women Based on Role Theory. Beijing: China Youth University of Political Studies.
|
余志远,谷平平. 2022. 女性自行车旅游者的自我意识觉醒与主体建构. 旅游学刊,37(6):106-120.
Yu Zhiyuan, and Gu Pingping. 2022. Self-Consciousness Awakening and Subject Construction of Female Bicycle Tourists. Tourism Tribune, 37(6): 106-120.
|
余志远. 2014. 背包旅游者的演变与概念重塑. 旅游科学,28(4):38-51.
Yu Zhiyuan. 2014. Evolution of Backpackers and the Concept Reconstruction of Backpacking. Tourism Science, 28(4): 38-51.
|
喻学才. 2004. 旅游文化研究二十年. 东南大学学报(哲学社会科学版),(1):63-70,124.
Yu Xuecai. 2004. Studies of Tourism Culture in Past Twenty Years. Journal of Southeast University: Philosophy and Social Science, (1): 63-70, 124.
|
Zhang J, Tucker H, Morrison A M, and Wu B. 2017. Becoming a Backpacker in China: A Grounded Theory Approach to Identity Construction of Backpackers. Annals of Tourism Research, 64: 114-125.
|
Zhang J, Morrison A M, Tucker H, and Wu B. 2018. Am I a Backpacker? Factors Indicating the Social Identity of Chinese Backpackers. Journal of Travel Research, 57(4): 525-539.
|
郑雄飞,黄一倬. 2022. 公共卫生事件中的个体多角色演绎与共同体互动秩序研究——基于“空间-关系-角色”的分析. 社会科学,(2):24-38.
Zheng Xiongfei, and Huang Yizhuo. 2022. Individual Multi-Role Deduction and Community Interaction Order in Public Health Events: Based on "Spatial-Relational-Role" Analysis. Journal of Social Sciences, (2): 24-38.
|
朱璇. 2018. 叙事分析下的中西方背包客真实性体验——以阳朔为案例地. 旅游学刊,33(3):116-126.
Zhu Xuan. 2018. The Comparative Study on Authentic Experience of Western and Chinese Backpacker Travelers Based on Narrative Analysis: A Case Study in Yangshuo, China. Tourism Tribune, 33(3): 116-126.
|
/
〈 |
|
〉 |